This is the back half of the last part (I, II IIIa, IIIb, IVa, IVb) of our series looking at the vision of history advanced by Hearts of Iron IV, Paradox Interactive’s World War II grand strategy game and one of the most popular strategy games on the market today.
In the front half of this part, we looked at how Hearts of Iron IV understands industry and production, the game’s economic model. On the one hand, the military production model is interestingly nuanced and complex and the decision to simplify the civilian half of the model, in light of the game’s focus, makes a fair bit of sense. On the other hand, the game stumbles quite badly in that it – mostly for reasons of balance (a desire to make Nazi Germany more likely to win than it was historically – constructs an economic world where discredited Nazi theories of economics which were quite decisively humiliated during the war itself are instead represented as right and true. HoI4‘s economic system (unintentionally) employs the tremendous persuasive power of simulation to create the appearance that the Nazis and fascists did make the trains run on time.
Industry is going to remain relevant in this part, where we’re going to talk about HoI4‘s conception of strategy and in particular strategic ends. Paradox games are deservedly famous for not featuring many explicit ‘win states’ and allowing the player to define victory. At the same time, different game systems still push players to think about ‘winning’ in different terms. To take an extreme example, few players are going to define a ‘victory condition’ to be something the game doesn’t even track or simulate.
Here again, HoI4 is a victim of its streamlining: it is mostly interesting in having World War II and profoundly uninterested in the implications of World War II. It exists, in many ways, in a world without strategic ends and the strategic ends it does track – military size and map painting, primarily – are, like so many of its other design choices, fundamentally the ‘victory markers’ that mattered most to the Axis powers and least to the Allies, especially the western allies. Hearts of Iron IV thus, in its careless streamlining adopts in its strategic ends – as with so many of its other systems – an unintentionally fascistic vision of history, one in which what really matters is purely military strength and the ability to dominate.
Finally, this being the conclusion, we’re going to ask what the implications for all of these choices across all four parts are. Hearts of Iron IV has a lot to recommend it – the operational simulator is very impressive – but also quite a few flaws. Most of all, viewing these flaws together, one cannot be surprised that this is a game with a serious Nazi problem. Of course any World War II game is going to attract that sort to some degree, but we can hardly be surprised if a game whose systems repeatedly, if unintentionally, adopt a fascist ideological position is going to have a particularly intense Nazi problem.
Hearts of Iron IV shows World War II as modern neo-Nazis like to pretend it was and so it is unsurprising that they are drawn to the game – albeit, we must note, alongside a great many players who are not ideological Nazis.
But first, if you like what you are reading here, please share it, as I rely on word of mouth to replenish my manpower pool after poorly considered post topics. If you really like it, you can support me, my academic work and my public writing, including this project on Patreon! I can’t promise to use your support to buy a division worth of tanks, but I also will not promise not to do that. If you want updates whenever a new post appears or want to hear my more bite-sized musings on history, security affairs and current events, you can follow me on Bluesky (@bretdevereaux.bsky.social). I am also active on Threads (bretdevereaux) and maintain a de minimis presence on Twitter (@bretdevereaux).

In practice the game is basically over at this point. Massively expanding my core territory (although India is counted as non-core), gives me access to a lot more manpower and – as you can see – a huge number of effective factories, pushing me past even the United States in economic production. In terms of the war against the Axis, the outcome is, at this point, effectively decided – the question is not ‘if’ but ‘when.’
What Is It Good For?
We should begin by discussing strategic ends. Countries in the real world do not wage wars (usually) simply because they like bashing their tanks and airplanes together the way a small child plays with toys (or a large child plays with Hearts of Iron), countries typically have aims they hope to achieve in war. In particular, leaders typically have a desired end state, an image in their mind of what the world is supposed to look like if they achieve all of their objectives in war. Now, war is a tricky thing that tends to get out of hand, so countries often struggle to achieve these sorts of clear end-states, often ending up with something rather different than what they had planned, even when they win.
But these end-states sit at the heart of strategy because all strategic planning is meaningless if you have no conception of what you are even trying to do and so one would expect any strategy game to pay fairly close attention to strategic ends. So it is worth discussing the strategic aims of the major powers in World War II – what were they trying to achieve – and the degree to which Hearts of Iron IV is able to model those outcomes and the factors which led to them.
But first we should acknowledge that Hearts of Iron IV actually has explicit scoring. When a game ends, a ‘playthrough overview’ screen pops up, presenting a ranked list of countries, with an overall score which is a product of the size of their armies, their navies and air forces. In practice, the calculation is very odd as this is effectively another dead mechanic – the air score generally overwhelms every other component of the calculation and relative scoring often makes little sense. In the screenshot below, Imperial Japan – on the verge of surrender, with the home islands having been invaded – ranks above the United States, actively in the process of invading the home islands.

While factory counts are listed on this screen, from the tooltip information, they don’t seem to have any impact on actual score. As far as I can tell, the end-game score system has been like this essentially since the game launched and it is such an infrequently used feature that it has never really been updated. Nevertheless, it is worth mentioning here.
The other explicit system are the achievements and Hearts of Iron IV, like many Paradox games, has a lot of achievements (293 at current count) the player can earn. That said, achievements can only be obtained playing on ‘ironman’ mode (a single save file, so the player cannot go back and undo bad choices) and it is pretty clear from the achievement stats that very few players ever play ‘vanilla’ Hearts of Iron IV on ironman. The most common achievements are joining a faction (19% of players), researching Construction V (17%) and having 1000 convoys (17%) all of which are practically guaranteed to happen in most playthroughs, suggesting the total percentage of players to ever meaningfully engage with ironman and the achievement system is sub-20%.
The existing roster of achievements splits into basically two categories: a number of achievements for utilizing basic game mechanics and then the bulk of achievements which are about achieving specific things (in most cases, alternate-history things) as specific countries. Notably, very few of these achievements resemble the actual historical strategic end-states that the major powers were trying to achieve. Instead, most of the country specific achievements are, frankly, memes: a funny title to go with an unlikely outcome that is interesting either because of how absurd it is (‘Thai Fighters: as Siam have 10 aces’) or because achieving it is a demonstration of skill in the system because of how difficult or unlikely it is (‘I Didn’t Hear No Bell: As democratic Czechoslovakia, lose the Sudetenland, then grant autonomy to Slovakia, then defeat Germany’). There is a subset of players that pursue these, but very few of them are related to the historic strategic ends of the major players in WWII.
Finally, of course, there is map-painting. After all, like all of Paradox’s grand strategy games, Hearts of Iron IV is played on a gigantic world map, so it makes sense for players, looking to demonstrate or compare their success at the game, look to see who has painted as much of the map their country’s color. It is the most immediately perceptible outcome of effective gameplay and so one many players focus on. But, as we’ll see, while seizing or holding territory was obviously an important aim of many countries during WWII, it wasn’t the ultimate aim – no one was simply running armies around to engage in ‘map painting,’ they had goals that went beyond lines on a map.
So what were they? And can HoI4‘s systems model them?

The delaying factor here is that even with logistics companies (which reduce supply weight), my armored fist (now an army made of an even mix of 13 mechanized divisions and 13 armored divisions) needs a lot of supplies to operate, which means that after each ‘push,’ I need to make sure the logistics are untangled before I can set up for the next one, at least if I want to proceed with minimal losses.
Aims of the Axis
Broadly speaking, the Axis powers went to war with variations on the same basic strategic principle: they wanted to seize territory in order to access sufficient resources to enable a kind of ‘national greatness’ but also – as we’ve discussed – economic self-sufficiency (‘autarky’). The goal was thus not just map-painting for map-painting’s sake, but specific programs of conquest designed to secure specific resources in order to create a specific kind of state – a fully internally self-sufficient empire, based on racial hierarchies in all three cases.
The Nazi version of this approach is often encapsulated into the Nazi slogan Lebensraum (‘living space’), but it is important to be clear here that Lebensraum was about resources as much as territory. Had Hitler been offered the entirety of Antarctica or the Sahara Desert, this would not have qualified as Lebensraum. Instead, Hitler’s aim was about securing not just physical space but resources – critically, farmland – for an expanding (racially defined) German Volk. To some modern ears, the idea that the emphasis here was often on farmland of all things may seem strange, but recall that the Allied blockade of Germany during the First World War had inflicted significant suffering and demonstrated Germany’s lack of agricultural self-sufficiency. Moreover, the Nazi ideal – remember, this is a reactionary ideology – placed a fair bit of stock in the ideal of the (‘racially pure’) German farming family as the bedrock of the Volk.
Consequently, Nazi designs were directed towards seizing huge swaths of Eastern European territory – mostly for farmland (but also other resources) – and mass murdering or enslaving the existing inhabitants in order to replace them with German settler-colonists. The basic ideological foundations of these plans reach back into the pre-WWI period, but find clear expression in Adolf Hitler’s Mein Kampf (1925), so they are very early components of Nazi ideology. Perhaps the clearest (and most horrifying) vision of this end is in Generalplan Ost (‘General Plan East’), crafted in 1940 and 1941 in preparation for the invasion of the Soviet Union but building on earlier thinking. This plan – of which the Hunger Plan already mentioned was a component – proposed murdering tens of millions of Eastern Europeans in order to facilitate a mass program of German colonial settlement.
Italian fascists had their own vision of ‘living space’ – Spazio vitale in Italian. It envisaged both a campaign of settler colonization over the ‘small space’ (piccolo spazio) at the core of this new empire and then resource extraction from the ‘large space’ (grande spazio) of imperial dependencies. Once again, resources – viable agricultural land, raw materials and so on – were of core importance in defining the extent of this ‘living space.’ As with the German conception of Lebensraum, fascist Italy sought to conquer a region large enough to sustain an imperial state without trade, by creating a system of ethnic subjugation and resource extraction.
Japan’s conception of its war aims were only modestly different, albeit complicated by the fact that whereas Germany and Italy had singular leaders with singular ideologies, Japan’s belligerence was driven by competing factions within its government. Thus, for instance, the ignition of major war with China in 1937 was not the product of the central Japanese government but the actions of elements of the Kwantung Army. That said, the Japanese government backed these sorts of actions so I am going to take a view here, as it were, that ‘the purpose of a system is what it does.’ Thus, even if Japanese actions ‘bubbled up’ from junior officers or resulted from competition between the IJN and the IJA, the fact that Imperial Japan backed and justified those actions make them state polity. Viewed in that light, combined with the (sometimes retroactive) justifications, Imperial Japanese state policy is quite clear and, again, only modestly different from the other Axis powers.
Japan’s “Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere” – the euphemistic label Japan applied to its empire – was primarily focused on resource extraction rather than colonial settlement. The Japanese home islands were densely populated and – by the standards of the time – highly developed, but relatively resource poor. Rather than trade for these resources or resettle the Japanese population en masse outside of Japan itself, the Japanese aim was to construct an empire (composed substantially out of puppet occupation governments) where the conquered populace would serve as an expendable labor force for the extraction of raw materials for Japan’s industry and a captive market for the finished goods Japan produced. The main difference here is that whereas the Nazis imagined an empire almost entirely of colonial settlement with very little resource-extraction-overlordship and the Italian fascists imagined an empire split between the two, Imperial Japan’s aims were almost entirely for resource-extraction-overlordship, with very little colonial settlement.
In all three cases, these aims were fundamentally economic more than territorial. The end goal was not ‘buffer states’ or a return to some past territory (even Italian aims included territory never ruled even by the Romans, such as Ethiopia), but rather an empire whose brutal extraction could sustain a certain standard of living for the ruling racial class through the subjugation or murder of other racial classes.
Which then leads us to…


The Soviet Union has still not – and will not – join the war.
The Aims of the Allies
The western allies (Britain, the countries of its Commonwealth, France and the United States, inter alia), entered the war primarily as status quo powers, with stated war aims – the disarming of the Axis and the dismantling of their empires – which largely aimed to return the world to something like the pre-war status quo. That said the way the war turned out mattered greatly to these powers in ways worth discussing.
Britain and France both entered the war as the victors of WWI, leading global great powers and with large colonial empires. After the war’s end, both countries would strive, fight and eventually fail to retain those empires and to defend their great power status. In a very real sense, then, Britain and France, while winning the war, fundamentally lost a grip on their long-term strategic aims. For France, it isn’t hard to see why – they were occupied during the way and the process of dismantling their empire, only partially reversed by the war’s end, began while France, as an occupied country, could do little to stop it.
For the British Empire, despite winning the war and never being occupied, the war fundamentally, fatally weakened an empire that was already (as we noted last time) beginning to slip away in any case. Some of these causes were ideological and political: as in World War I, the Commonwealth states having done their bit felt a renewed sense of pride and increasingly independent feelings. This, as an aside, is one of the only things here HoI4 actually models: war participation by colonial states pushes them towards independence, so a United Kingdom that finds itself unable to win the war except by leaning heavily on its empire finds that empire slipping away even faster for the effort.
What is missing here are the economic causes: the United Kingdom, by the end of WWII was economically exhausted. Winning the war had required suppressing consumer demand and turning the economy over to military production which is a fundamentally unproductive kind of production in that no one can eat bombs. The United Kingdom had begun rationing food supplies and other basic necessities (clothing, soap, fuel, etc) in 1939 and kept rationing some essentials as late as 1954 as the economy struggled to recover. British economic weakness – currency weakness and reliance on fuel imports, among other things – created the leverage that the United States (in part) used to force the British to back down during the Suez Crisis (1956), the event which effectively marked the end of Britain and France’s status as great powers.
Meanwhile, understandably, a country still under rationing, recovering from the economic devastation of the war and absolutely exhausted by it, was equally unwilling to summon the will to spend even more money and even more lived in a likely doomed effort to maintain its overseas empire by force.
Of course the United States stands as a stark contrast: military spending during the war functioned as a massive economic stimulus, while at the same time the United States suppressed consumer demand via rationing (for a shorter time and far less harshly) during the war, leading to a lot of households ending the war with money in their pockets because there had been money to be made during the war but nothing to spend it on. The result, famously, when the war ended was the economic boom of the 1940s and 1950s, which provided the economic muscle for the United States to act as one of the world’s two Cold War-era superpowers.
There is, of course, an irony that the country that ended up at war’s end with the highest standard of living wasn’t the one that had conquered any territory for resources, but the United States, which owed its renewed prosperity to domestic, internal economic factors as well as a gleeful enthusiasm for one of the things the Axis powers hated: trade.
The Soviet Union’s war aims are a bit harder to parse, in part because some of the claimed aims (the USSR promised to create independent new countries in Eastern Europe) were disingenuous (the Soviet Union instead produced puppet-states, disciplined with military force) and because the Soviet Union spent some time, effectively, on both sides of the conflict. Initially, the USSR used the war, in 1939 and 1940, as an opportunity for territorial expansion into Romania, Poland, the Baltic states and Finland, with both an ideological objective (expanding the Soviet model of Communism) and a geo-strategic one (establishing ‘buffer states’ protecting the Soviet core). After the war, those same aims appeared with the Soviet creation of a network of satellite states built on the Soviet model (with the threat of the Red Army to maintain it) in what would become the Warsaw Pact, while at the same time combined with a desire (shared by the western allies) to limit Germany’s ability to upset the global order again.
This set of Soviet objectives are also one of the few Hearts of Iron IV can really model, as it is possible to create ideologically pliable satellite states in the peace conference system, although because the game ends in 1948 (and in practice runs out most of its content by 1945) these states mostly exist as trophies rather than actually doing anything. That said, it doesn’t really model them well; notionally this effort was also supposed to make believers in the Soviet system out of Eastern Europe but as we’ve discussed before the game’s political model is far too simplistic to really capture or simulate that kind of shift in political opinion or consciousness and by the time it would matter the game has lost interest in any event.
What you may note, however, is that for a lot of the countries involved – the USSR is a partial exception but only a partial one – the overall strategic end-states (both desired and achieved) end up as fundamentally economic in nature, revolving around the standard of living that the post-war order could provide and the consequent tolerance of the population for further spending on expensive foreign political programs (the British Empire, the Marshall Plan, the Warsaw Pact, NATO, etc.).
Can Hearts of Iron IV simulate these aims? Broadly speaking, no. I’ve noted the few exceptions, but generally no. It can simulate the map painting component, but the underlying economic realities that the map-painting (or lack thereof) are supposed to produce, it is almost entirely incapable of even simulating, much less representing to the player, much less presenting as an end-state. The actual strategic aims of the major powers in WWII largely fall completely outside of Hearts of Iron IV‘s vision of history, a striking failing for a grand strategy game which cannot model the grand strategies of any of the great powers of the 1940s.

At this point, the game is mostly an exercise in pointing and clicking – Axis armies are weak enough in most places (while my forces remain fully supplied, equipped and reinforced) that I can advance almost at will, even just pushing forward with my defensively-oriented infantry divisions.
Empty Shelves
The main problem here is that nearly all of these war aims historically fed back into economic questions: the availability of resources, of agricultural land (‘living space’), of a trade-based, prosperity-inclined global order, the existence or absence of rationing and consumer goods and overall standard of living. For Germany and Italy, these were combined by what we might bloodlessly term demographic goals – the mass murder and enslavement of tens of millions of people in order to enable a program of mass agricultural resettlement of their lands.
But Hearts of Iron IV‘s economic system doesn’t simulate any of this feedback, making it impossible for the game to even model these strategic priorities – I want to repeat that, the game cannot model the strategic priorities of countries like Germany, Italy, Japan, the United Kingdom or the United States – much less present them to players as potential strategic end-states.
A major part of the problem is the underdeveloped civilian industrial system. As noted last week, Hearts of Iron IV ‘taxes’ each country a certain percentage of its factories to produce civilian consumer goods, a percentage which decreases as a country increases its economic mobilization law, which reflects war-time rationing leading to less domestic consumption. Notably, however, these consumer goods factories both consume no resources (besides the coal that everything does) and produce nothing.
So on the one hand, there is no point to engaging in military expansion to secure the resources for any kind of domestic industry except armaments production, because no kind of industry except armaments production actually uses raw resources as the game models them. Armies do conquest and conquest feeds armies but neither of these ever feed back into anything else. In terms of raw factory counts, raw resources – except for coal – are entirely superfluous to industrial expansion. So long as building slots exist, any country can happily keep plopping down civilian factories and infrastructure and never really face any kind of resource shortage.
Meanwhile, HoI4 does not simulate standard of living or the civilian supply of goods at all. The contrast with Europa Universalis V or Victoria II or III – where goods production feeds back both into state revenues but also into the goods available for consumption by pops and thus into stability and politics – is marked. In HoI4‘s economic system, consumer goods usage is simply modeled as waste: it does not result in economic growth, it does not influence politics and there is no standard of living mechanic for it to influence.
Of course historically, rationing – which is how you actually reduce the ‘consumer goods’ percentage of industry – mattered a lot. It was politically contentious in the democracies both during the war and (for Britain) in the years following. In most countries, the demands of the war meant that most luxuries vanished from stores fairly early on, while in many countries – particularly the Axis powers and the Soviet Union – the war’s demands meant that necessities were rationed tighter and tighter, until things like calorie allotments for civilians were truly parlous. It matters, as a historical matter, that the outcome of a war that was supposed to guarantee prosperity and plenty to specific racial groups instead delivered them want and starvation.
Meanwhile the game is likewise incapable of modeling the post-war situation either. Apart from Germany’s unique MEFO bills, the game doesn’t simulate the ways in which countries fought the war by effectively borrowing from the future – either by direct debt financing or by suppressing consumer demand to focus entirely on military production. There is no way, for instance, for the United Kingdom to rack up lend lease debt or end up in a situation at the end of the war where the historical massive Anglo-American loan was required simply to keep the British economy running as it transitioned away from military production (which in turn would also require Marshall Plan assistance).
Instead, as discussed last time, Hearts of Iron IV‘s economic simulation features spiraling, out-of-control growth because it treats consumer goods as a kind of waste that is reduced by war economies, leading to economies becoming more productive rather than less as a result of mobilization (the opposite of the thing that happened). As a result, it has no way of simulating France and Britain being effectively bankrupted by the war, nor of simulating the United States’ unique position as the one major world economy that hadn’t been blasted into rubble. Instead, everyone finishes the war with vastly larger economies than when they started.
The only major exception to this rule is Germany’s MEFO bills. Historically, MEFO bills were an economic gimmick created by Hjalmar Schacht to allow Germany to run an enormous deficit without that deficit showing up on the government’s balance sheet thus enabling massive fiscal stimulus (via rearmament) without a visible exploding debt, though of course the whole thing about the MEFO bills is that they would have to come due eventually (these were 6-month bills, but you could ‘kite’ them for a time by issuing more), but Germany went to war, initiating rationing and a government controlled economy (and then collapsed) first.
The game models this interaction, with MEFO bills giving a quick injection of economic production and suppressing the consumer goods percentage, but with a nasty hangover down the line. However the game provides an a-historical ‘out’ – the start of the war enables the MEFO Bills national spirit to be transformed into ‘Economy of Conquest’ which then can be modified via ‘Autarky Achieved’ directly into Wirtschaftswunder (the term for the post-war economic recovery in Austria and West Germany) once Germany has seized enough raw industrial resources, which resolves the issue.
The major problem with this interaction, from a ‘vision of history’ perspective, is that it presents as if the Nazis could have permanently dodged the economic costs of their war if only they had won, which is almost certainly untrue. Historically, the Nazis looted aggressively across their new European empire and never got out ahead of the massive obligations the state was incurring doing all of the war – instead, even as the Nazis pushed deep into Russia, civilian supplies and rationing had to be aggressively cut back. It was not, in fact, possible for the Third Reich to conquer its way out of bad economic decisions and the fact that Hearts of Iron IV creates an entire focus and event chain to pretend that it was is another way that it ends up – for game balance reasons (Germany has to be able to win!) – endorsing a false and fascist view of history and economics.
Had the Soviet Union collapsed early in 1943, Nazi Germany would still had been burdened with internal debts it could not pay, store shelves it could not stock and people it could not feed, which is a big part of why it was planning to starve more than forty million of those people to death simply to make the math begin to work. I honestly find it a bit offensive that the game uses the historical term Wirtschaftswunder for the end-state here, because it implies that butchery and conquest – if it had worked – could have been a shortcut to the kind of prosperity that West Germany achieved in the 1950s, but the historical Wirtschaftswunder was based on sound currency (something the Nazis did not do), trade and economic integration (something the Nazis hated) and financial assistance from the United States (something the Nazis would never get). It feels like a piece of historical economic stolen valor, to be frank, to give the name of a historical thing accomplished with the opposite methods and ideology of the Nazis as the result of implementing Nazi economics fully.
However, beyond this industrial policy, the game cannot really model fascist economics either. Because of the already-discussed policy of indifference to Nazi war crimes, the game has no way of modeling Nazi efforts to create Lebensraum in the East or the possible effects this would have had. Nazi industrial policy is presented as a workable plan to use conquest as a short-cut to the kind of economy modern Germany has – highly industrialized, based heavily on trade – rather than an insane plan to attempt to murder their way to prosperity through a program of agricultural expansion that I think it is fair to say was doomed to failure no matter what happened. Homesteading was not going to be the winning economic model of the 1950s.
The result is a game that is incapable of modeling the actual war aims and strategic ends of the major combatants in World War II, despite being a grand strategy game about World War II.


Spain will be capitulated back out of the war by mid-July.
Will The Mods Save Us?
Before we can wrap this all up into a set of conclusions, we need to discuss the modding scene. Hearts of Iron IV is unusual as strategy games go because of the huge popularity of its mods, which range from small quality of life changes to massive total conversions which transport the game’s core structures into completely different settings. Something like two-thirds of Hearts of Iron IV players play with mods at least some of the time, though it is important to caveat that figure both that not every mod is a total conversion and also not every person running mods runs them all the time. Vanilla HoI4 is still the modal experience of HoI4, but the mod community is huge and a lot of players are running mods.
Can the mods fix Hearts of Iron IV? Kind of?
Most HoI4 mods are subscribed to through Steam’s Workshop feature, so we can get a decent view of the space here and I want to be clear that we’re really considering two separate things: the community of modders (who make the mods) and the community of mod-players. Here is, as I write this, the currently most subscribed mods on the workshop:

We have a few quality of life mods (Chinese localization, FPS Map, a peace conference system revision), a timeline expansion (The Road to 56), a mod that shifts the system earlier (The Great War) and later (Cold War Iron Curtain) and one alternate world total conversion (Old World Blues, set in the Fallout universe).
And then we have alternate-history What If Germany Won World War I? (Kaiserreich), and alternate-history What if Germany Won World War II? (The New Order) and Millenium Dawn, a modern day conversion to the game that got so popular with neo-Nazis that the creator – who is not a Nazi – had to burn down his own forums as the only way to get them out. Fully half of the top six mods for this game are ones that have – shall we say – unique appeal to Nazi-inclined gamers.
And that is the state of affairs, I must note, after Paradox Interactive actively purges the Workshop of openly Nazi mods.
Now, I want to be clear: is Kaiserreich a pro-Nazi mod? No, it is not. But in a crowded modding marketplace where most people only look at the titles, you would have to be a little daft not to recognize the bit of marketing work being done by a mod which overhauls basically the entire map calling itself Kaiserreich – and what it means for the community that this name was evidently the second best possible choice after “The Road to 56.”
Is The New Order a pro-Nazi mod? No, it is not; if anything it is more skeptical of the Nazi social, economic and political program than the base game, which is to say that it expresses any skepticism at all (and it does as does Kaiserreich). But do these mods have some obvious appeal to modern neo-Nazis? Yes, obviously. While it is the case that both Kaiserreich and TNO at this point have a ton of content for countries that are not Germany, it is also the case that they’re called Kaiserreich and The New Order: Last Days of Europe and that there are two alternate history ‘what if Germany won…’ mods in the top six mods (the 21st most popular, Thousand Week Reich, is also this). Before we get to any other country getting a focused alternate history, we also have to pass a mod named after the Nazi victory slogan (Endsieg; again, the mod is no more Nazi than Hearts of Iron but the appeal is obvious), to get to the first country-specific non-German overhaul, Pax Britannica (36th in popularity; ‘what if Britain but science fiction’), which has 12% of the subscribers that Kaiserreich does.
This is, I must stress, the situation with all the Nazi mods removed and their creators banned by Paradox as soon as they are noticed. In short, the Nazi problem in the Hearts of Iron IV modding scene is old and well-known.
I want to be clear here that I am not accusing the makers of these specific mods (as opposed to now-removed infamous Nazi mods like “Aryan Goddess” and “Deus Vult” (made by a guy calling himself TauronSS)) of being Nazis or fascists or friendly to Nazis or fascists. What I am pointing out is this is exactly the modding scene you would expect for a game that had a serious Nazi-bar problem, but also had the developers actively purging any openly pro-Nazi or pro-fascist modding content. You’d end up with the most popular stuff frequently being borderline material that isn’t pro-Nazi per-se but happens to focus on the elements that Nazi players want to focus on the most without breaching the modding rules.
If I may strain an analogy, if you walked into a store that sold key-chains with initials on them and realized looking at the shelf that they sell three times as many ‘SS’ keychains as any other letter combination, you would not rush to assume that it just so happens that everyone in town is named Simon Smith. You might even draw the conclusion that the store owner – despite not being named Simon Smith and professing that he didn’t like the Simon Smiths – nevertheless seemed a bit too comfortable making their keychains.
Of course real-world alternate history mods are not the only kind. As we’ve discussed, HoI4 has a remarkably good operational military model, one of the best out there. And there are any number of mods which take that operational model and transport it into a context where it is simply no longer expressing a theory of history at all – mods like Old World Blues (set in the Fallout universe) or Equestria at War (set, incredibly, in the My Little Pony universe). Those mods are really popular too (albeit generally not as much as the alt-history-Germany mods, make of that what you will), and there is certainly an argument that by transporting the game into an alternate world they ‘save’ the operational simulator by ditching the bad history it is freighted to in the base game.
What I think the mod scene signifies is the complex nature of the Hearts of Iron IV player-base. The joke I have heard is that the HoI4 player-base is effectively split three ways: one third are hardened Nazis, one third are History Dads and one third are purple-haired LGBTQ ultra-libs. I doubt those numbers are right, but it speaks to both the diversity of this player-base and also to its very awkward and quite visible Nazi problem. But I don’t think the modding community can ‘save’ Hearts of Iron IV, because it is simply a reflection of the game’s player-base.

This was notionally in preparation for a ’round 2′ against the USSR, however I ran into a snag here that has ended the playthrough: because the USSR didn’t actually enter the war (and the game doesn’t count the seizure of the Baltics or Eastern Poland as generating World Tension), I actually have no way of declaring war on the USSR to recover the rest of Poland (the ‘Embargo the Soviet Union’ and ‘Operation Unthinkable’ focuses are gated by the USSR producing meaningful World Tension).
Consequently, I’ve opted to end the run here, although if I could declare war on the USSR at this point I would have no problems winning, given the combined strength of the allies and my access to all of the resources and industry of central Europe.
Conclusions
The last time I am aware of that Paradox released who-plays-what-country statistics was in 2023. At that point, the top 10 played nations in the game were:
| Germany | 22% |
| Soviet Union | 12% |
| Nationalist China | 6% |
| Communist China | 6% |
| Italy | 4% |
| United States | 4% |
| Japan | 4% |
| France | 3% |
| The United Kingdom | 2% |
| Turkey | 2% |
And it just seems relevant in a game that is about a war between the Axis powers, the Soviet Union and the western allies, the western allies – the democracies in that war – have fewer players collectively (9%) than the two halves of the Chinese Civil War (12%) or the Soviet Union alone (12%), much less, of course, Germany. Indeed, more people are playing Germany than any given three other countries added together.
There’s a relic of the game’s development I find interesting: the game’s main theme, dating from the base game’s release in 2016, was the theme of the (western) Allies. The initial cover art features MacArthur in the center, with one commander each from Britain, Germany, Japan and the USSR. In short, at launch, the game attempted to present, in important ways, the Allies as the ‘main characters,’ a stance that made more sense at the beginning when the focus trees of the Allies were roughly as (un)developed as those of the Axis.
I do not think anyone looking at Hearts of Iron IV today has any problem correctly assessing that its ‘main character’ is Nazi Germany. Evidently the player-base knows.
And before I get a chorus of loud complaints in the comments, I want to be clear what I am saying here and what I am not saying. I am not saying that everyone who plays Hearts of Iron IV does so because they like Nazi Germany or the Axis more broadly. Instead, what we see in the community around this game is one in which the majority of players are what we may fairly call ‘anti-Nazis’ but that at the same time the game has attracted an unusually vocal, unusually large minority following of extremists, kept in check primarily by the fact that their voices are actively, continually suppressed in the Paradox forums, the Steam Workshop and related communities like r/hoi4.1
And that prompts a follow on question: why? One answer, of course, is simply that this is a World War II game and the Second World War is an obvious touchstone for Nazi-sympathizers. But certainly one does not get the immediate sense that all World War II games and media draw this kind of following.
I think in the process of working through Hearts of Iron IV‘s vision of history we come to a clearer answer: Hearts of Iron IV, often in the interest of streamlining and game balance, has blundered into offering a vision of history which is inaccurate in the specific ways that are likely to be flattering to pro-Nazi and pro-fascist players.
Whereas in practice, historians generally regard World War II as a contest between economic and political systems in which fascism proved inferior,2 HoI4 presents battlefield skill and operational art as the most important thing in war, exactly as the Axis powers thought. Whereas in practice, the war and the Cold War that followed it demonstrated the considerable advantages of liberal democracies and free market economies, HoI4 presents both democracy and market economics as liabilities, weak systems that are nothing but negatives, exactly as the Axis powers thought. Whereas historically, the Nazi economic plan of economic stabilization through conquest and mass murder had functionally no hope of success, in HoI4, it can work and even produce an economic miracle, exactly as the Axis powers thought.
In short, although the war itself demonstrated that Nazism, Italian fascism and Japanese militarism simply didn’t work as ideological, economic, political or cultural systems, Hearts of Iron IV instead posits a world in which they work exactly as their proponents – exactly as modern fascists – wish they did.
And of course, whereas historically the armies of the Axis, especially but not exclusively those of Nazi Germany, committed horrific atrocities wherever they went, Hearts of Iron IV functions as a ‘clean Wehrmacht simulator,’ reinforcing the post-war lie peddled by Nazi officers that presented the Wehrmacht as innocent of Nazi crimes (which were attributed all to the SS). That line, of course, plays into modern neo-Nazi minimization of Nazi crimes in a progression that has become blandly predictable in certain online spaces: they didn’t happen, or if they did happen the ‘clean’ Wehrmacht didn’t do them, or if they did they were good actually.
Put even more bluntly, Hearts of Iron IV has unintentionally created a simulator that presents World War II as modern fascists would like it to be. One suspects that at least some of the folks at Paradox are not wholly unaware of this – somewhat infamously the advertising for the major Germany update, Götterdämmerung, in 2024 veered more than a little uncomfortably towards Nazi propaganda.
Of course at the same time the shame of it is this game is built atop a truly remarkable operational simulator which does a really good job in expressing why operations in World War II took the form they did, shaped by terrain and logistics as much as by tanks and shells. And while the civilian industrial model is pretty flawed, the military industrial model is equally instructive in presenting some interesting trade-offs, even if it is forced to treat German and Japanese mistakes as if they were valid policies that could have succeeded in the long-run.
I do not think it is impossible to play Hearts of Iron IV responsibly. But I do think players need to go into this game forewarned and forearmed that the design and balance decisions made to make it an interesting strategy game also serve to skew the history it is presenting in very frustrating ways. And equally, I think the developers at Paradox need to give a lot more thought to how – if these balance choices are unavoidable for gameplay reasons – they can offer responsible historical framing to make clear to players what and how large the concessions to gameplay have been.
It might equally be worth asking, given where, very evidently, the development time and focus in the game have gone, why this is a game where the western allies – who emerged triumphant from the war and the Cold War that followed it – are less heavily played and have far less content than the Axis (or even really just Germany), who lost it.
But, for as much as I enjoy playing it (I have almost 600 hours in HoI4 and more than 300 in HoI3), Hearts of Iron IV is easily the most historically troublesome and flawed entry in Paradox’s catalog, a produce to be consumed with care because of how skewed its historical perspective is and how little effort there is to signal to the player the nature of that skew.
Instead, the game tilts unsteadily on the very edge of unintentional fascist propaganda, the sort of product that we do not teach…but find ourselves having to un-teach.
- I have seen relatively little in the way of systematic study of fascist and/or right-wing extremist views in the HoI4 player base, presumably in some part because the one company with the data to do such a study is Paradox Interactive and I imagine they have concluded that just about any result from that study would be bad for their business. But I cannot stress enough how anyone who has been in the HoI community, it is simply common knowledge that it has an unusually large contingent of extremists, even though they remain a minority of players.
- For a sense of this vision of the war in the scholarship, see R. Overy, Why the Allies Won (1995)
There are some intellectuals who
…are better at handling WordPress than me, and can finish their comments before posting them. Or figure out how to delete them when they err.
Trying again.
There are some intellectuals who talk about the pseudo-minds of organizations and markets. I’m the furthest thing from an expert on this sort of thing but I’ve heard people describe the overall market as an artificial intelligence that optimizes for capitalist ends. They say that there are ‘thoughts’ essentially encoded into the shape of the economy as a whole that guide the behaviour of those who try to make money within it.
Your description of how HoI has become very successful and uncomfortable fash-y over time made me think about that. It sounds as if any attempt to optimize a WWII game for sales is gonna push you in a Nazi-friendly direction. As if the market itself was a fascist.
Hey, my posts have been autocorrecting in the name of the pre Hitler Germans government to all sorts of unfortunate terms, you’re not alone.
There’s a complicated history here. One causal factor is that the less wrong blog, which was one of the foundational sites for the rationalist movement which spread early AI messaging through universities and businesses had a libertarian bent, arising from the biases and beliefs of Elizier Yudkowsky, a key figure in the movement. His non AI sci Fi writings often casually assumed a libertarian future with markets for things like drugs and sex alongside more emphermeral concepts like the decision making behind war and first contact being mentioned in passing, like a kind of amalgamation of popular opinion into policy recommendations and trade. He was explicitly non political but his post claiming that also spoke in favor of letting markets sell drugs even if a mother of four dies from an overdose, because it’s better overall for society than the war in drugs which kills more people.
(If he’s right is besides the point; that indicates the direction of his political position).
These ideas aren’t new, but that’s part of what led to AI bros hearing about them. Less wrong significantly influenced the space.
This naturally led to speculation that in the absence of AI markets themselves would act as profit maximizing engines. The alignment problem also influenced this, with some posters (including me under a different username) pointing out that in that framework markets are similar to misaligned AI, as they are optimizing something other than human happiness. Or whatever an aligned AI actually does. This actually suggests that capitalists should not be trusted with AI, as they participate in a misaligned system that should be expected to produce misalignment.
In part because the biases of space were pro corporation this often rapidly devolved into people saying that capitalist markets obviously optimized human happiness, look at the cold war, etc. and sometimes the discussion being nuked.
Because Elizier explicitly refused to alienate anyone politically (or so it goes) there was never any attempt to address these ideas by the early AI debaters and thinkers and synthesize anything like a conclusion to how capitalism interacts with alignment or resembles AI. Which is a shame because capital has eaten generative AI and all the spaces dedicated to AI safety are now idealogically toothless to do anything about it, or even meaningfully question the topic.
The idea still fits about in the background though.
All this to explain you aren’t crazy, that thought is a real thing that exists out there.
I’m very familiar with LessWrong, but wasn’t thinking about it in this context. Now that you mention it, the connection’s pretty obvious.
And viewed as an AI, yeah, the market is far from “aligned”.
How on Earth would this be an LW thing (or a markets thing). The concept of price signals serving an information-exchange function is bog-standard economic theory. It is an immediately following corollary that the part of putting information into the system is weighted by the money spent, so those with little money have little weight in it. It also follows that since it is often possible to extract money in a variety of ways that are bad for the functioning of the market, there are mechanisms where (to use this frame) “the market tells people to harm the market”.
Likewise, it is an utterly mainstream view that a central problem with autocracies of all kinds is that the government can ignore what the people want, whereas in democracies, voting throws information about the population’s desires into the face of politicians in a way they can’t ignore. The immediate corollary is that if some people can’t vote (e.g. grandma is allowed to, but forgot which day it was), their opinion is ignored. (Formally weighted voting was also a thing historically, see the Roman republic; less so today.) And the more complex corollary is that for various reasons, from “people are badly mistaken about how things work” to gerrymandering, the outputs that come out at the end of an electoral system aren’t consistently the options that would best deliver the things that people want (never mind their effect on what options are presented to be voted upon in the first place).
Yes, but most people don’t term the effect of market incentives as “Alignment”, nor relate these to AI.
That’s where the language and ideas of less wrong influence the way people think and talk about these concepts.
I’m not saying OP is right or coherent in how he views the market as being fundementally inclined to produce fascist propaganda like an AI, but he is right that there is a part of the AI space that talks like exactly like this. He didn’t invent it.
As for it being more obvious and mainstream to talk about similar effects in terms of price signals and electoral biases, I agree. I hope we don’t have to use the silicon valley cult language to talk about this stuff. But it does influence our society and it’s becoming more mainstream to talk about alignment, so it’s worth explaining what’s happening here to produce these seemingly insane references.
Well, AI went in five years from “not particularly interesting chatbot” to e.g. megacorps assigning mandatory training on it to every employee (as the one I work at has done). Of course people talk about it, realize they should extrapolate five more years into the future, boggle their minds, and look for ideas. The space around LW happens to have the best explanations on this topic, so their jargon is the one that spreads.
I hope people have the good sense to be able to distinguish separate ideas coming from the same source. It is kind of inevitable that unusual good ideas get picked up by people open to unusual ideas, who therefore tend to also have other unusual ideas. (Which makes them look like cultists.) And since nobody has perfect taste, they probably get some bad ideas among their good ideas.
If people find it more intuitive to talk about markets by borrowing the “alignment” terminology, IMO that’s a symptom of economics being insufficiently widely known. The borrowing is not complete nonsense, there is some shared mechanism, but markets are a very atypical edge case for this approach. Sort of like driving a nail with a wrench.
I mean, the less wrong people are, in my experience, largely cultists; last I checked they basically all fell for spiralism and most are now prone to anthropomorphize chatbot AI. They don’t have a great track record before that, what with multiple sex offenders involved in several sexual abuse scandals, which is a hallmark of cult isolation. Plus there’s the whole Zizian offshoot thing.
I have strong opinions here. I think I’ll leave it at that rather than vent further, it’s off topic.
Marte, AI was _already_ booming and hyping up way before OpenAI; even if we restrict outselves within the Generative Machine Learning/Neural Network subgroup, it was already toutet as edgecutter technology that’s a must-learn for information technologizers and their managers. And that’s before all the leaps-and-bounces advancements in other subfields and applications like audio processing, optical character recognision, Chinese keyboards etc.
Making it all about OpenAI and her imitators is, borrowing this post’s term, stolen valor if I’ll be frank.
The corporations-and-markets-as-AIs rhetoric predates ChatGPT, for what it’s worth.
And I’m not entirely convinced by it. It’s interesting but a bit too science-fictional to take entirely seriously. Thing is, our host’s description of how market incentives push Paradox towards apologia for the Nazis is very reminiscent of that stuff.
As for LessWrong, it has some cult-like qualities but I’m not as down on it as Terry. The main problem with high control groups is the high control, and LW is thankfully low-control. Offshoots like the Zizians can be very different, but the Zizians hate the mainline community and that’s no coincidence.
I would give a modification on your informational framing Basil. One that is rather important, that is the power of votes structurally is not uniform and distinctly hasnt been equal to other interest in multiple democracies for decades. This can very much be extended into more informational models for why things like monopolies are rather inevitable things to at least be attempted. The given labels and cultural mythology touted by such labels in economic theory is also if import in how information is distinctly distorted in legal practice, like with amendments vs. facilitated material conditions of the people voting on said legal changes.
@BasilMarte
Likewise, it is an utterly mainstream view that a central problem with autocracies of all kinds is that the government can ignore what the people want,
I realize this wasn’t your point, but there’s also another question about whether “what the people want” is actually normatively good, from the point of view of other goods (long-term economic, social, environmental, cultural, whatever) that you might want to optimize.
It’s pretty clear that people “want”, generally speaking, cheap gasoline fuel, low taxes (other things being equal), high quantities of sugar in their diet, etc.- whether the state actually wants to give them those things, or whether it should, is a separate question.
Well obviously the answer is to make humans no longer want those things, (fivehead meme goes here).
Slightly more practically, give them less destructive things they want. People want transit, not gasoline, give them nuclear engines, hee haw! People want to taste sugar, not eat it, wire the experience into their limbic system!
Or, you know, electric cars and low calorie sweeteners.
As pertains to this trying to determine what people should have versus what they want is a thorny road, and the foundation to a lot of technocratic failings is the enduring bias of small groups to convince themselves they know better than most people and act accordingly, even as their relative power and privilege biases them in ways utterly predictable to anyone with a history textbook and a working frontal cortex.
Hence why technocracies, even benevolently founded ones, are prone to autocracy. The inherent and unavoidable biases that effect whole populations are only worsened when affecting small elitist groups, and no one is immune to this.
A lot of technocrats are prone to bash democratic systems because of obvious failures. However the only robust way to ensure that the interests of most people are taken into account in any outcome is to give them power over the process. Small groups will rapidly define themselves as the in group and the population as the out group and act accordingly. And once their interests diverge the decisions they produce can be expected to be misaligned.
The best solution we have is to let people elect the technocrats and give them a narrow remit, or at least elect the people who appoint them, then accept their decisions even if they’re annoying. This is basically why the federal reserve exists as an independent organization and hence why the US economy hasn’t already collapsed. The reserve is appointed by politicians so has legitimacy, it has textual independence emphasizing it’s ability to act outside public whims, but their remit is narrow enough that they can’t randomly engage in large scale social engineering for kicks.
This is assuming the premise is contextually valid, of course, and people want, or rather inherently want, something they shouldn’t have, or can’t understand. That’s only a subset of problems. Many more involve manipulation of public will through information oligarchy than actually represent inherent human biases.
Technocratic organizations love to point out that elections are flawed and that they can bypass these flaws through other mechanisms of power, but there’s absolutely no solution to being misaligned with the public because it influences all downstream decisions, and no mechanism to correct the biases of elite groups. If you do have a benevolent technocracy the solution is thus to devote at least its primary means to improving the ability of elections to reflect people’s will and needs. To do that you need to be willing to identify the political problem, even if it alienates your support base, and do something about it.
Which is why I think the rationalist community is a failure.
@Hector
First, at least since Plato philosophers have tried to figure out what objective good is. They, ahem, have not yet succeeded at the task, to put it mildly. Holding a glorified opinion poll is the least bad alternative.
Second, I think you are slightly too pessimistic about people. It is very typical that John Example wants both smooth, high-capacity roads and low taxes, without realizing there is any contradiction. And furthermore he knows from ironclad experience that transit is useless and inconvenient, so he dismisses as a pipe-dream any suggestion it could be made useful, and as tall tales any claims that it is useful elsewhere. However, when the matter is brought to his attention, usually he recognizes other people’s plight as fellow humans/citizens/etc., and does want to help them, and so he does vote that the transit agency should run moving soup kitchens for the needy. (Pardon.) Even within most individual people, the impulses for good are there; the “raw material” is present.
Now, this is just the beginning of complexity. Differently structured elections lead to not merely different outcomes, but altogether different political cultures, when given the same distribution of popular wants. Just to give a well-known example, single-seat “first past the post” legislatures push systems toward having two parties, and consequently a political culture where it benefits a candidate to throw poo at their opponent, so there is a great amount of poo-throwing. By contrast, in a party-list proportional system, there are several “real” parties (which tend to spread out better across issues, so most people have a party that better represents what they care about than in a two-party system), thus even if flinging poo at an opponent does harm that opponent, most voters who “move” will move to unrelated candidates rather than to the attacker.
Furthermore, holding elections — or even just public hearings — about any little thing is reliably terrible. Even if they approved everything (ha!), adding delay and friction to e.g. building houses obviously makes houses more expensive. And, of course, it is very much the case that this kind of process asks those who live nearby, but does not ask those who stand to benefit (primarily, the future residents of the houses to be built), and thus they reliably produce a result of “don’t build anything”.
So, to avoid the failure modes both of NIMBYism (far too much “democracy”) and of modern architecture (no “democracy”, people reliably hate modernist buildings and like older styles), there needs to a balance. And not just as a knob; the details of the implementation matter (see above regarding electoral systems), but naturally that discussion does not fit into a comment.
Perhaps I should also say that I’m idly curious about other methods, not just voting. (Broadly: in a small country (~10M), how would I fill a second legislative chamber in a way that is perhaps weird but neither stupid nor too highly correlated year-to-year with a party-list-proportionate house to serve as an effective counterweight to them?) I also have a, call it Vicky-inflected, notion that a recognizable type of political breakdown (maybe “stasis”?) is caused by some kind of “real” power going without representation in the political system. So if someone claimed that this factor is e.g. income/wealth, and suggested a (vaguely Roman-inspired) system where people who last year paid over some threshold in taxes got a second vote, I would be moderately skeptical but wouldn’t dismiss it out of hand just for being undemocratic by a one-voter-one-vote definition.
@Basil Marte
Switzerland, with 9 millions people, have a popular chamber and a cantonal one. It also strikes a functioning balance between only electing a few people every x years and voting on everything.
“I realize this wasn’t your point, but there’s also another question about whether “what the people want” is actually normatively good, from the point of view of other goods (long-term economic, social, environmental, cultural, whatever) that you might want to optimize.”
Sure, but there is a major problem here. Who is “you” in that statement? Who gets to decides what is and is not to be optimized? Which is another way of asking “Who is sovereign within a polity?” Is there a better alternative to “A majority of voters?”
@Basil,
I don’t think I’m “pessimistic”, to be clear. I think people absolutely have natural inclinations towards altruism, cooperation, generosity, love of nature, etc.., just as they also have natural inclinations towards selfishness, individualism, overindulgence in things that are bad for them, short term thinking, , etc.. Which of those comes to the fore at any given point, and which become less important vs. more important through a person’s life, is affected by economic factors, social and cultural factors, and, yes, by political factors as well. I think it’s the role of the state (or in pre-state societies, the role of the community) to try and cultivate some of these personality traits in people and suppress or at least limit others.
@Hector
“I think it’s the role of the state (or in pre-state societies, the role of the community) to try and cultivate [virtues] in people and suppress or at least limit [vices].“
Oh indeed. While our host rightly likes to remind us that humans are humans in all eras and places, the natural result of dumping a pile of humans outside a society is …not pretty. For instance, as gangsters lose access to courts to peacefully resolve their business disputes, evidently they don’t reinvent it, but resort to (unsuccessfully) attempting to deter each other by performative thin-skinnedness and eagerness to violence.
This idea that there is much to “society” beyond the crowd of people constituting it is central to small-c conservatism. Just as we usually can’t shut down physical utilities citywide for months while we rebuild the whole system, instead we have to do in-place upgrades, we can’t shut down society to apply reforms. And that just as utilities can suffer cascading failure, such as a blackout (in turn overwhelming other systems), society can collapse, too.
@Basil
Oh, but gang leaders are trying to reestablish judges, just in the sense that the original judges were either warrior-kings or priest-kings. At least in western jurisprudence all judicial power is derived from Roman kingship.
You can see this in the behavior of successful gang leaders-the projection of strength, performance of local customs and even charity, and the use of symbols of wealth and even authority.
Of course they’re competing against the state in this regard, and only persist on the edges of state power in places where the state has chosen not to satisfy a need. But humans are humans; they are, in fact, reestablishing a version of state power in that vacuum, just a fundementally limited, personalistic, exploitative, and brutal version of it.
You can see this most clearly in failed states. The gangs become the government. I think that literally happened in the capital of Haiti, but the media stopped talking about it and I just accepted that the situation was FUBAR.
Same thing happens with corporations, as an aside; let them run long enough and they do things like buying land, mercenaries, and setting up company towns with their own arbitration. State power is a vacuum that will be filled by the opportunistic, the only working alternative is to democratize the state. If this fails, democratize harder. Option B. is death and oppression.
@Terry
I did not mean to analyze gangs as protostates, because in that case the places that persistently have them technically fail to enforce the monopoly of legitimate violence and thus don’t count as states. And beyond the opinionated choice to not view gangs’ violence as legitimate, my understanding is that objectively, most gangs earn their income mostly from e.g. drug dealing (business revenue) rather than protection money (taxes). Thus the validity of the international relations view should be understood as a failure to apply market/legal tools.
Otherwise, thanks for reinforcing my above point: with the same population, you can see a functional state that keeps pax; or an edge-of-being-a-state with organized crime running rife; or a lack of rule (an-arche), or as the Sumerian King List puts it: “then who was king? Who was not king?”
However, I can’t help but point out that East Asia has seen a number of military dictatorships that greatly benefited their subjects without giving them democratic input for a while. From the US occupation of Japan post-WW2, through South Korea and Indonesia to China. To be very clear, these are counterexamples, not an argument for dictatorship.
It’s an honest question. You can easily make the case that they can only exist within a larger interstate framework and are thus not really states, but they do claim dominion over the legitimate use of force. Almost solely to deny it to others, but they do so.ivil wars often end when one gang of vaguely idealogical criminals wins, and either exterminates or subordinate all rivals. The line between legitimate and illegitimate force is very hazy during state failure.Of course this is academic. I’m just nitpicking versions of bad.
The thing with the Asian dictatorships is that they had popular buy in, just not elections. Mao had military authority but his primary support base was the population writ large, and the civil society of China produced enough institutional robustness to overcome his more eccentric moments (kill all sparrows!). These are democratic in the sense that they represent a diffusion of power away from the central authority, even if they aren’t elected.
It was a damn near thing with China, in fact. Mao yielding to internal pressures to slow the great leap almost certainly saved tens of millions of people, the way things were going. But that’s precisely because he wasn’t a pure dictator. People representing institutions within and without the party were capable of contradicting him.
When these institutions also failed you got Pol Pot or the Kims, a rapid devolution in idealogy and breakdown of any connection between the revolutionary organization and the population. Similarly several latino left wing revolutionary organizations which engaged in drug trafficking steadily became gangs, precisely because their new stream of revenue had no power relationship to the civil society the paramilitary lived in.
A very similar thing happened with the original soviets, as in the labor organization. It’s hard to reasonably argue that the original soviets were less democratic than their alternatives, which was literally the Tzars government. They elected representativs, but their increasing integration with the military and alienation from the rural population led to first dismissal of election results, then shooting protestors, then dictating who could be a candidate and the establishment of an autocracy.
In other words a lot of non electoral communist systems had some measure of democracy, it just wasn’t reliable. Hence the wildly divergent outcomes, dependent highly on how functional the self correcting mechanisms were in their iteration of the system. It certainly wasn’t the only factor, but it mattered a lot.
A wise man once said all systems are democratic, you just vote with swords. As a corollary all systems might have traces of democracy, but that doesn’t make them equal.
WordPress was a bit weird and smashed my deleted sentences together, disregard everything in the first paragraph.
It’s not anything about the market, but it is about storytelling.
It is unsurprising that the Western Allies are not popular. Their motivation is transparently reactive; “if it were up to them”, nothing of interest would happen. By contrast Germany, the USSR, Italy and Japan are the actors with initiative, the ones who want to change the international order at the start of the game. (I’m surprised Japan isn’t more popular.)
One obvious way to rescue the situation is to follow the standard arc of hero plots. Truncate the game to start after the Fall of France! (Sorry, France.) Then it becomes a protagonist story to try to change the situation in which the villain has half won.
I will also say that in general Paradox has leaned into promoting wildly ahistorical outcomes being possible, not just in HoI. For instance, in CK3 they’ve leaned into the memes about a certain Norse count, Haesteinn, with a strong starting event army (I do not remember him from my Viking history class but apparently he was a big deal in France at the time) going on wild adventures with a dedicated achievement (Fishing in China) for conquering China with him referencing a youtuber named koifish known for wild adventures with that guy. And in their promos for the recent Christianity DLC they made Ritual Cannibalism a main tenet of Catholicism, illustrating how easy it is.
My personal bugbear, since I’m a huge anime nerd and thus have adjacent interests in Japanese culture and history, is that it’s so easy for the Japanese imperial throne to leave the dynasty it often happens without player intervention. Long story, but basically the reason Japan has had a titular emperor from the same dynasty as far back as records go is that according to legend they’re patrilineal descendants from the major sun kami Amaterasu and this is considered pretty important.
I would generally say there’s two systemic factors which cause the market to act fascist friendly, although I’d not go as far as to say it’s inherently fascist.
Firstly, games that make people uncomfortable don’t sell (and also, game proposals that make executives uncomfortable don’t get funded), which makes depiction of historical atrocities difficult. See also Bret’s discussion about Assassin’s Creed Valhalla and how its decisions to make playing a Viking palatable results in uncomfortable implications.
Now there is a culturally contingent component to this in that what’s judged to be acceptable is not inherent to the nature of the market. Like that depicting people being burned to death is apparently more acceptable than showing a nipple is something that could be changed. But that uncomfortable topics make media harder to sell is systemic as long as we have a free market. The free market is squeamish, one might say.
Secondly, there is a large demand and apparently also a large desire to supply art that is about conflicts being resolved violently, and usually also through killing. I wouldn’t say this is inherent to the market but also historically contingent (although I’m not against people like Bret making an argument that it’s sort of inherent in human nature and culture because of it being the winning strategy for thousands of years).
Taken both of those things together, it’s no surprise that we arrive at a market which has lots of games about war that don’t depict war crimes with the severity they should. Which is fascist-friendly for certain, because “Let’s do a war because it’s manly” is part of Eco’s diagnosis of Ur-Fascism.
there is a large demand and apparently also a large desire to supply art that is about conflicts being resolved violently, and usually also through killing.
This may or may not be inherent to human nature, but it is so widespread across such a huge proportion of all the human societies that have ever existed that we should probably act like it is.
“And ever since historian writ
And ever since a bard did sing
Did each exalt with all his wit
The noble art of murdering”
It’s pretty universal to the development of the state at least. Some pre state societies might have been truly pacifistic. Even the tribal societies that survive post date the state as an institution, and often have state like structures; there are only remnants of the exceptions.
It’s pretty universal to the development of the state at least. Some pre state societies might have been truly pacifistic.
This is a huge discussion that has happened on this site before, but tl;dr: the archaeological evidence strongly suggests that pre-state societies were generally extremely violent.
No, it does not. Yes we debated this. There’s a lot of bad conclusions out there.
It basically depends on how you define a state versus non state society. To get at the conclusion that pre state societies were extremely violent you need to make one of two main category errors; classifying modern tribes as stateless, or classifying any society that didn’t basically build cities as fully stateless.
The first is a category error because the collision between pre state societies and state societies is often exceedingly violent, and there aren’t any stateless societies left that aren’t in contact. By definition if we can study them they’re in contact, after all.
The second is a category error because the hierarchical systems of agriculture that developed into the state are a gradient; is a tribal elite in an agriculturist society a specialist? To a degree yes, but there often isn’t a formal system in place to ossify this hierarchy.
To put it another way the Gauls and the Maori are stateless societies for at least most of their history, and an uncritical view would classify them alongside nomadic hunter gatherers. Yet Gallic society hsd more in common with states like Rome than it did with the Maori people, and neither was in any way comparable to true hunter gatherers. Hell, the Maori transition to agriculture before contact, and their degree of violence changes, alongside increasing stratification.
If you account for this then the core hypothesis falls apart.
Apply a sober category analysis and the best conclusion becomes that truly stateless societies had low to moderate violence, while societies transitioning to a state had very high rates of violence. States themselves have moderate to extremely high rates.
Modern society is still more peaceful on the whole than all but the most outlier stateless societies, but only when it’s still functioning and the state isn’t massacring its people.
So…does your theory define the Ache and Hiwi as “transitioning to a state”?
No, that’s just bad science. This conclusion for the Hiwi and Ache based on pre and post contact dates. For the Hiwi at least the original study is available online. Pre contact is define as pre 1960.
The Hiwi have been massacred in Indian hunts by ranchers and loggers since the 1870’s. At least. The 1960 date is the known date of first peaceful first contact. Violent contact had been happening for a hundred years.
Hence he’s not comparing death rates pre and post contact. He’s comparing death rates before and after the Hiwi had recognized *rights*.
Not quite? For the Aché at least, 1960s was actually the peak of the genocide which took place under Paraguay’s Alfredo Stroessner. As one of the comments on that video quotes Wikipedia, the majority of the Aché were killed and the rest pushed from “nearly 20,000 square kilometers…to two reservations totaling little more than 50 square kilometers”. Stroessner didn’t take power until 1954, and apparently didn’t begin to focus on the Aché until 1956 at the earliest. I believe the definition of “contact” used by Hill and Hurtado is based on the fact that both the Hiwi and the Aché have suffered mass mortality from introduced diseases in the 1960s.
As in, if violent contact was more prevalent earlier, then the surviving tribesmembers in the 1960s would have already had immunity, as their ancestors would have been devastated by those diseases back then. This means that even when they were still more-or-less in their original lands, with at most sporadic attacks/slave raids from the Paraguayan settlers who didn’t go deep enough into the forest to spread disease to the bulk of the tribe, the Aché tribes were still the kind of a society where a man could randomly murder his wife and avoid consequences besides being shunned by other women in the tribe. (See the slide on 10th minute, which describes that case, and notes it took place in 1947.)
A similar case is attributed to a Hiwi man (who had bizarrely claimed he had to shoot a 17-year old 2nd wife with a bow because the first one had rejected her and wanted her to die and apparently “annulment” wasn’t an option?), though it is undated in the slide. Either way, trying to connect it to the tribes being confined on reservations seems like a tenuous link – as opposed to all the infanticide, which can be easily attributed to constrained resources.*
On the other hand, ritual duels (though as he points out at 12th minute, those club fights didn’t always stay as duels, with at least one having half a dozen join in on one guy’s side) are again rare in settled societies – and I do not think e.g. sword/pistol duels had ever led to a loser’s child buried alive alongside his body, as had happened in those tribes at least one occasion. (The slide at around 7:40 – he notes that there was no-one left who wanted (key word choice) to raise the 12-year old girl, and even if you attribute that to being squeezed by Stroessner-encouraged violence + disease introduction, it still means her father went into the duel gambling with her life as well as his.)
I’ll add that Azar Gat also believes the earliest societies have represented the peak of warfare; I could even quote the relevant section of the book, but perhaps you have discussed this already in older threads I missed (if so, please point me to those).
P.S. Looking at papers related to Hill & Hurtado’s work brought me to this.
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.4161/cib.4.2.14320
*And either way, as I have discussed in older threads, infanticide was highly widespread in the settled societies of the antiquity as well (though much less common in Ancient Egypt than Greece or Rome – to the point the Egyptians in Ptolemaic or Roman times were often known to adopt infants discarded on dung heaps by the families of their colonizers) so focusing on it is hypocritical. Having said that, I cannot quite recall settled society equivalents to one’s infant daughter to accompany an older man into the grave, as described around the 7th minute of the video.
The ache had documented first contact in 1620.
If the claim is that the group being immunologically naive is indication they didn’t have any contact or influence from Europeans it’s just bunk. If the claim is further that hiwi or ache deaths from Europeans started in the 60’s then that’s also bunk, we have documented massacres for both going back to the late 19th and early 20th century.
Even if you maintain that contact was limited to the fringes if society, having a massive, incredibly dangerous group of strangers suddenly appear and start disappearing people for a hundred years, slowly closing in on your heartland, might just influence the cultural development of the society.
It is possible for an immunologically naive population to exist post contact. It does not mean that group has not had exposure to either the disease or the disease carriers, just that it hasn’t gotten into the larger population enough to change genetics. Hunter Gatherers are actually natively prone to this, and we know disease epidemic rates were much lower, because villages often burned out a disease locally rather than spreading it to neighbors. Further the repeated waves of epidemics among native populations in the Americas after known and clear first contact shows that immunity takes time to develop, even when we have clear histories of exposure.
I’m not new for pointing out the Ache and Hiwi aren’t pristine labs for anthropological study. The robust scholarship here avoids anthropology based research because it is nearly tautologically impossible to get pre contact death rates. Archeology is prone to gaps, but it’s what we have. And archeology shows great variations depending on how the society functioned.
There is no single definitive definition of “Fascism,” but let me propose that a key component is a desire to return to a mythologically simpler past in which “masculine virtues” predominate. Basically it’s a working class male power fantasy. To the extent that this is right, wargames and war adjacent entertainment is just going to appeal to that demographic. This is not to say that all or most working class males are fascist, but I am saying that fascist movements typically find their strongest support there.
I’m not sure if the market itself is fascist. Happy to engage in experiences that center violence, sure, but that isn’t necessarily fascist*, whether or not the centering of violence is fascist depends on the scope of the experience. A game that focuses entirely on a military operation, or a somewhat connected series of military operations (i.e. the campaigns of most strategy games that aren’t grand strategy games), isn’t necessarily fascist simply for leaning into mechanics that emphasize gaining control of territory, murdering the opposing force, and which values strength, skill, and discipline, over compassion, creativity, and careful consideration of all sides. Those mechanics are appropriate for the scope of pitched battle, no matter the motivations of a given side.
Scaling that up to the level of broader social aims, and explicitly treating it as the only activity that matters in the world, is where the problems Bret has been talking about come up. The fascist part isn’t in having the values and aims of military operations be given pride of place in the limited context of military operations, the fascist part is in taking those values and aims and assuming those are the only values and aims that matter in *any* context, no matter how broad or ill-fitting. This is my read on the issue HoI4 has, according to Bret’s analysis. You get a game that builds from fascistic assumptions, entirely due to the tools given for the scope presented being inappropriately limited for that scope, in the exact way they are in the fascist imagination. It’s from *that starting point specifically* that it struggles to exist as a game which fits the market expectation (i.e. that every pre-game choice is equally viable competitively) without also providing rhetorical support for fascism.
*Admittedly in aggregate the plethora of games in the strategy space that focus on military operations, to the exclusion of all else, can narrow the scope of possible ideas for conflict resolution in the audience, but other games do exist to provide other narratives and ideas, albeit not as often in the strategy genre. To me that’s more a definitional problem of strategy games than a broader issues with the market. Strategy games are largely defined as specifically military strategy games, so the focus seems narrow because the focused has been narrowed. Ultimately, they are only one genre among many for games, and if nothing else I’ll take the enduring popularity of Stardew Valley and other games that take a completely different focus to military strategy as a good sign that video games and their market isn’t inherently proto-fascist.
(re-posting because WordPress handles line breaks unpredictably, and ate mine)
I’m not sure if the market itself is fascist. Happy to engage in experiences that center violence, sure, but that isn’t necessarily fascist*, whether or not the centering of violence is fascist depends on the scope of the experience. A game that focuses entirely on a military operation, or a somewhat connected series of military operations (i.e. the campaigns of most strategy games that aren’t grand strategy games), isn’t necessarily fascist simply for leaning into mechanics that emphasize gaining control of territory, murdering the opposing force, and which values strength, skill, and discipline, over compassion, creativity, and careful consideration of all sides. Those mechanics are appropriate for the scope of pitched battle, no matter the motivations of a given side.
Scaling that up to the level of broader social aims, and explicitly treating it as the only activity that matters in the world, is where the problems Bret has been talking about come up. The fascist part isn’t in having the values and aims of military operations be given pride of place in the limited context of military operations, the fascist part is in taking those values and aims and assuming those are the only values and aims that matter in any context, no matter how broad or ill-fitting. This is my read on the issue HoI4 has, according to Bret’s analysis. You get a game that builds from fascistic assumptions, entirely due to the tools given for the scope presented being inappropriately limited for that scope, in the exact way they are in the fascist imagination. It’s from that starting point specifically that it struggles to exist as a game which fits the market expectation (i.e. that every pre-game choice is equally viable competitively) without also providing rhetorical support for fascism.
*Admittedly in aggregate the plethora of games in the strategy space that focus on military operations, to the exclusion of all else, can narrow the scope of possible ideas for conflict resolution in the audience, but other games do exist to provide other narratives and ideas, albeit not as often in the strategy genre. To me that’s more a definitional problem of strategy games than a broader issues with the market. Strategy games are largely defined as specifically military strategy games, so the focus seems narrow because the focused has been narrowed. Ultimately, they are only one genre among many for games, and if nothing else I’ll take the enduring popularity of Stardew Valley and other games that take a completely different focus to military strategy as a good sign that video games and their market isn’t inherently proto-fascist.
“but other games do exist to provide other narratives and ideas, albeit not as often in the strategy genre.”
To be fair, I don’t think that’s entirely true: Management and city builder games are a decent chunk of strategy games after all.
To give a bit of credit to the players of italy/germany/nationalist china/japan, in any historical game it can be more compelling (as an expression of your skill as a player) to reverse the verdict of history rather than reproduce it. ‘Winning’ as America in WWII happened without any help from a skilled ‘player’ so in some sense it’s a less impressive feat to execute (unless you’re doing one of the ‘meme’ paths as you did with this series).
That’s a valid argument, but I’d argue not the full picture. Because there is a matter of framing of what are interesting verdicts of history to put in front of the player to reverse. HOI IV heavily puts its thumbs on the scale by basically only giving you the mechanics of reversing “Who wins the war?”. If the game was set up and framed not as “WWII Simulator” but as “Post-WWI Politics Simulator” (as frankly a Paradox GSG should), then there’s many other events in history that could be presented as interesting and challenging to reverse: Avoiding the Great Depression, avoiding Decolonization, avoiding the collapse of the Weimar Republic and rise of Hitler, spreading Communism as a not self-destructive USSR, etc. But with its relentless focus on the operations of war and the reduction of everything else to Meme Politics, HOI IV does not give any of those other counterfactuals any space to actually be meaningful.
That “Post-WWI Politics Simulator” sounds like a game I’d pay good money for to play. If only because in contrast to HOI4 it does not cover a time span that’s awkwardly short for a grand strategy game. Usually those give you more time to set up the politics, economy and military of the polity you play. Even Terra Invicta gives you more time to work with than HOI4.
Then it would be more similar to Victoria 3. Hoi4 is less a “WWII Simulator” but rather a “operational art simulator”. WW2 must happen in Hoi4 so the player can produce tanks and order their divisions around – which is the main point of the game.
I found myself thinking, especially as I read the conclusions part, that it could be interesting to have Germany be a sort of “burn” faction, where all its bonuses are mortgaging the future. It could possibly also provide room to make the defeat of France happen without leaving things too powerful later (even though that’s really on France, honestly), as the actual conquest plan falls apart in the face of reality.
I’m curious if with Resistance DLC, communist Spain becomes more attractive than fascist Spain, solely because it’s alt-his. If it doesn’t, the alt-his enjoyers can’t beat allegations (and vice-versa)
That’s one aspect for sure, but another one is that as the fascist countries and the Soviet Union, you simply get to the war a lot faster. Participation in the Spanish civil war, China, Finland, Poland, Ethiopia.
When you’re playing as the US, you have to sit on your hands for a long time, just building up, clicking through a pretty lackluster focus tree, and wait until you’re finally allowed to join the brawl. So you spend quite a few hours getting through the bits of the game that are barely there until you reach the bit that’s actually fleshed out.
Britain has a pretty challenging starting position, having its armies and navies spread out all over the world. It’s tedious to organize and prioritize. And the focus tree isn’t very good or interesting.
France has a trainwreck of an economy and political system at game start and takes a long time (and a lot of focuses) to fix.
Germany on the other hand? All you have is nicely concentrated, you start off with a strong economy, a decent army, and if you want to go the non-aligned route, you can get rid of Hitler as literally the first thing you do. It’s nice and easy, there’s a massive and powerful focus tree, and you can start fighting almost immediately, either in the civil war if you decide to end fascism, or in the Spanish civil war (where a couple of good divisions and air wings will do WORK).
My point: the fascist countries and the SU let you get to the fun faster, and the game mechanics favor them. I suspect that is why faction choice is so skewed in their direction.
There is, of course, another solution: take political and economic decisions out of the players hands. In this case, after picking a nation, they would be playing the “General Staff” of the country in question – in charge of the military forces, but things like what territories to take and what armies to attack would be imposed on them by the game. That way, it could be 100% a “Military Operations” simulator and all the uncomfortable strategic decisions made by the game developers.
I think it’s important to note that sound currency here has almost nothing to do with what gold standard advocates term “sound money”, i.e. gold. Or crypto, because cryptocurrency and gold attract the same interest groups.
In context sound currency means that the Deutsche Mark (D-marks) introduced in 1948 were intentionally limited in distribution with only a 10% increase in supply allowed (10 billion issued, provisions allowing 11 billion). There was also some independence secured from government meddling with the supply, in that the finance admin who pulled this off did so via sidestepping the occupation government, de facto signalling they were an independent economic regulator like the federal reserve. It took a while for the Bundesbank to be formed as a truly independent organization, but these steps signalled financial independence.
And, most critically, Nazi era price controls were abolished, and wage controls were removed from central planning and delegated to labour union and trade representatives. You see the Nazis had formed a central committee to set what prices would be, which was both to encourage rationing and war production and depress or increase consumer good prices according to the whims of the party. They also set wages for basically all labor and, which should come as no surprise, cut them to the bone in a terrible deal to labour. German workers worked long hours for depression era wages, in part because the Nazi government openly collaborated with business leaders and this ensured their support, primarily because this increased war production.
The allies kept this system in place for a few years as they tried to settle things. This state of affairs had already produced a black market under the Nazis, which they punished with concentration camps when they felt like it, and without that punishment the black market took off.
The removal of both controls was critical. The end of price controls caused goods to become profitable on the open market, killing the black market. However in 1948 itself this did basically nothing because wage controls meant no one could buy shit; exports increased but domestic consumption didn’t fully increase. The continuing infusion of Marshall plan funds and the further abolishment of wage controls by the state in favor of unions negotiating with employers led to the beginning of the rebuilding in truth and the acceptance of the policy by the population.
(This wage system has proven fairly good at ensuring German workers aren’t overly exploited, but has had its own issues relating to how the state recognizes the unions and the potential for state interference in favor of businesses, so I caution against both over and under praise. Certainly better than Nazi central planning.)
Which makes the fact the game calls Nazi economic victory by the reconstruction name even more infuriating, as reconstruction was predicated on directly abolishing the Nazi central planning that the player just finished implementing, it’s as wrong as possible.
Just wanted to clarify because there were some gold bugs who showed up in the comments a while back when Alf Landon came up, and it’s worth pointing out that the miracle had nothing to do with “sound money” as used today except that there was a currency limit imposed by the regulator.
That was very interesting, thanks for adding that!
Yes, that’s a good point, when I say ‘sound money’ I do not mean the gold bug definition of the phrase, but rather sober economic management of a central currency. Basically, “do not do Weimar inflation.”
One of the surprises, for me, in Tooze’s “Wages of Destruction” is that the first third of the book is multiple cycles of “guys, the overvaluation of the Reichsmark is killing our economy, we might have to devalue it or even let it float” followed by “no, no, we need a strong currency, we’ll just create a new ReichsBitchKreis of petty bureaucrats and business leaders to ration foreign currency / control prices / make everyone stand on their heads, it’ll be fine.”
Which speaks to the enduring necessity of an independent central bank, if your economic system is using money at all. You need the people making decisions on money supply to be be able to make decisions that defy a lot of powerful domestic and foreign influences, based purely on what their economic mandate says.
This doesn’t really help if the entire bureaucracy is high on its own supply or if the economic situation is bad for reasons separate from monetary policy, but it helps avoid a lot of very obvious pitfalls.
“Which makes the fact the game calls Nazi economic victory by the reconstruction name even more infuriating, as reconstruction was predicated on directly abolishing the Nazi central planning that the player just finished implementing, it’s as wrong as possible.”
So, this is actually one of the weird bits that kinda needs explaining:
The german industrial tree has two major branches:
This is the historical one; It largely involves managing the MEFO bills (and later the “Economy of Conquest” spirits) by various stopgap measures and looting the various countries to try to staunch the flow of ever increasing Consumer Gods factor.
This is the alt-historical branch: Notice how a lot of the focus talks about precisely the policies you’re talking about. In game terms this branch basically removes a lot of the early bonuses you have and then lets you build back up a much more solid economy that doesen’t have to deal wiht the economy of conquest. This is actually the branch that gives you the Wirtschaftswunder spirit normally (and then keeps improving it.
The weird bit is that the Autarky Achieved spirit basically gives you the same spirit (I *think* it’s the base spirit rather than the fully upgraded Wirtschaftswunder). Now, to be clear, “Autarky Achieved” basically means you have won the war (it requires you to control a metric fuckton of resources) this particular resolution is one of the more baffling decisions in the game, but to be clear, the actual Wirtschaftswunder path doesen’t represent nazi economic policies at all. I *think* they just wanted to have capstone focus for “winning”, but reusing the spirit from the other branch is just weird. It’s one of the more baffling decisions since it seems clear that whoever designed the focus tree had at least *some* idea of what was actually going on. It almost feels like someone designed the focus tree with some basic knowledge of the economy and then someone else come ina nd wnet “Wait, we need a capstone to the historical branch”. It’s very weird.
EDIT: Yep, the autarky achieved version of Wirtschaftswunder is weaker.
I would posit that at least part of the reason the Western Allies are less popular is precisely because they won. Having the Western Allies win is boring because we already know that story – it’s in our history textbooks.
I must admit, I enjoy the alternative history of The New Order, primarily because I love to see the US (and it’s democratic alliance, the OFN) on the back foot, struggling against a Eurasia that has been consumed by darkness, and then being able to liberate the world and return democracy’s light. Because the US is the obvious underdog, and there’s more tension and uncertainty there.
As a long time follower of TNO: The US is not an underdog. Sure, its alliance has been absent from the Old World since WW2 ended, but it’s still by a large margin the strongest superpower and it’s the one superpower that needs to actively fail to lose, as opposed to Japan/Germany that are failing by default and need to reform themselves for a shot at winning. The real underdog on the global stage is Russia, and it’s not a coincidence the bulk of the mod’s content is Russian reunification.
I don’t want to defend Paradox, but I really do struggle to think of a way out of the bind that they are in.
Broadly speaking, we can take a good hard look at the various aspects of the game, and perhaps improve individual aspects. Truth is an antidote to sin after all, and so perhaps it is right to make the economics, the industry, and the demographics more simulationist in the vein of Victoria 3.
As it becomes clear that fascist economics are inferior, their ideologies are insane, and their actions relied on both luck, and poor decision making from Allies(which can be averted by players who know history) we might be able to get a version of the game which is more responsible with regards to how it treats history.
Unfortunately I see two problems with that approach. The first is the possibility that it would make the game less fun. PDX monetary policy relies strongly on the continued flow of DLC for continuing revenue stream. The developers might be hesitant to let that dry up, for fear that it affects the bottom line. Something something hard to get a man to understand when his paycheck relies on his ignorance.
The other problem, which might be more insidious, is that it doesn’t make the game less fun. Games are meant to be a challenge. A gameplay design which leaves Germany as a brutal and unfun grindfest risks causing the game to lose it’s fans. A gameplay design which makes Germany harder but does not do so enough might ironically spark more interest.
Can a player successfully carry out the operations of the German war machine while dealing with the maluses inflicted by the genocide and ethnic cleansing? If we tightly integrate the effects of conquering land, stationing military to avoid uprising, and try to outrun the debts incurred by the war machine, how much of the player base will be intrigued simply by virtue of wanting the challenge to beat the odds?
To be clear, I find the idea that a subset of the player base would want to play such a modified Germany in order to brag about winning with the handicap of Germany’s ideological and strategic goals perverse in it’s own right.
Feel like the actual solution is to simply extend Victoria 3 by twenty years.
Or just having a “World War” game focused on 1900-1950. Part of me wants that, and the other part thinks the game would benefit from starting in ’38 just to reduce all the shenanigans that can happen in ’36-’37
Victoria III Is barely able to handle the Great War, actual maneuver will probably break it. I like V3 quite a bit, but it’s very much a game well made for the era it’s actually about, with some limitations on doing later things.
It’s funny that I think that Vic2 pulls it better solely by emergent gameplay. I remember realizing that I have to maintain front fucking manually then I started winning
The main conclusion I’ve come too over the course of this series is that the responsible thing for Paradox to have done would be to not make the game.
A strange game. The only winning move…
(Sorry, couldn’t resist.)
At last, it’s our turn to ask the game if she feels like the hero yet.
Pulling in some of the ideas I’ve floated in previous installments’ comments, Germany’s critical path to victory would be more “destabilize internal politics of foes” than economic or even military. If they fail to set off a French crisis of faith in their government, the German invasion fails pretty much immediately, any French player that avoids a right-wing coup can then slug it out. If they focus on Britain, but can’t lower British civilian morale to the point of a no-confidence vote, they’re unlikely to mount a successful landing, let alone conquest. If they focus on the USSR, they need massive propaganda to try to keep the US out of the war and Britain at bay.
And making them vulnerable to the same sorts of counter-play – Germany facing a revolt due to not looting enough to give their core civilian supporters enough luxury – gives them some new loss conditions that fashy players wouldn’t enjoy. A neo-nazi would consider a game where they fought well but were outmatched in the field by a better opponent to be their fault, should’ve ubermensched harder; a neo-nazi would consider a game where France actually fought back after losing Paris, stalled out their conquest, and then Berlin revolted because they tried to enforce rations too strict for a war they were supposedly “winning”, to be antifa propaganda and a reason to quit, go back to HOI4.
(And I suppose making a game centered around liberal economic principles is propaganda, but that’s just reality’s well-known liberal bias showing through.)
IMO, make HOI5 have enough economic depth to simulate the reasons why and the methods how the war was fought, make the Axis powers a de-facto Hard Mode, and relegate the historically-implausible weirdness to alternative start conditions rather than alternative win conditions, and most of the remaining issues solve themselves.
Part of the problem is that nerfing germany to historical levels doesen’t just make the game less fun *as Germany* but also *as the allies* since you want to actually have a challenge.
And also because liberal economic policies worked because of a lack of central economic planning and this is a game where the player is cast as a sort of psychic god-being devoted to central economic planning. Giving the weird situation where not only should playing as the allies be easier, but it also should be easier if you just never open the economics screens, which in turn has the weird effect of slightly undermining the point of the re-design via ‘well, no-one will ever really need to look at this anyway’.
By that point you’re simulating enough that you’ll start to run into the weird effects of the axis not being run by fool. The most obvious being ‘if Japan actually had a god-being with a central military plan to start with, it’d basically have done none of this stuff, given their issue was that the central government wasn’t able to control its own military’, and ‘why on earth would Italy voluntarily decide to switch from being in the entente to the Axis between the two World Wars – Sure, Germany wanted a do over of WW1, but they lost WW1, Italy was on the winning side, and could probably have remained so quite easily’.
I mean, what we now call the Axis wasn’t formalized until after the Fall of France (on 27 September 1940, specifically) when it briefly seemed like Germany defied the economic-industrial odds and would stay on winning. Mussolini stayed out of the war in its first 9 months, and didn’t invade France until it was already two weeks away from surrendering. (Remarkably, he literally exported at least 700 military trucks to the French over the preceding months!)
Admittedly, Mussolini apparently wanted to ally with the losing side even under Weimar; conversely, the ascent of Hitler had actually tanked their relationship for a year, because Mussolini was adamant on Austria remaining independent. Then, the self-inflicted international isolation from invading Ethiopia gradually pushed him back towards Hitler; the same thing happened with Japan in the aftermath of invading China.
P.S. “liberal economic policies worked because of a lack of central economic planning…not only should playing as the allies be easier, but it also should be easier if you just never open the economics screens” is really overstating the case. Consider all the wartime rationing even in the US (which was but a fraction of what the UK had been forced into); amongst all the other things (the article lists them better than I could), the civilian car manufacturing went from ~3 million per annum to basically zero!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rationing_in_the_United_States
My recollection is that John Kenneth Galbraith, who was deputy administrator of the US Office of Price Administration during WW2, consistently described the WW2 US economy in his writings as centrally planned.
Reading this series has really solidified my belief that a historically plausible WWII strategy game and a Paradox-style GSG are mutually incompatible. The former requires a specific sequence of events to trigger a war that is comparable to the historical one, and the range of plausible national strategies and capabilities are highly constrained by the material and political conditions of the time. The latter emphasizes player agency and a sandbox style ability to do whatever you want with any nation over the scope of the game, best exemplified by HOI4’s mission tree system. That sandbox element directly pushes against the historical plausibility, as it does in all Paradox games, but in Hearts of Iron the dissonance is heightened by the short timeframe and the extent of our knowledge about the historical period. It’s hard to play as the “spirit of the nation” of Germany when that spirit from 1936-1945 was the spirit of Adolf Hitler (and would be even if he’d been assassinated).
I’ve never moved on from HOI3 to 4, at first because I was waiting for the wargame mechanics to improve. But over time the focus on the wacky and overpowered alt-history mission trees really turned me off the whole thing. Hearts of Iron is for playing around with World War 2. If I want a mix and match nation and ideology sandbox with a side of World War game Victoria 2 lets me do so without having my suspension of disbelief smashed by a lemon wrapped around a large gold brick. HOI3 has its issues, many of which are the same as those Bret’s detailed in this series, but its more constrained sandbox and focus on lower level tactical movements helps keep the cognitive dissonance more manageable. After reading this series I doubt I’ll ever move on.
HOI4 started the trend of Paradox games becoming more “frictionless” and letting the player do anything easily, at the cost of both historic plausibility, and as Bret so excellently details, promoting an authoritarian and wrong view of history. States were not these omnipotent Nietzschean entities that merely had to exert their will and direct the nation to their liking. Reality has always and will always harshly constrain any single entity’s attempts to exert control over history. Things like CK3’s eugenics or “pick and choose your religion” mechanics, or Vicy3’s implausibly easy state-directed industrialization just feel too frictionless, too unrealistic to me. A good grand strategy game should let you try to do some crazy stuff, but the harder you push reality the harder it should push back. HOI4 just doesn’t have that push back, both in terms of its material mechanics, or in representing how inflexible, self-destructive, and ugly the ideologies driving the nations of this era were.
I’m inclined to agree with the immediate conclusion. World War II is too contingent on outcomes we weren’t guaranteed to face, it plays exceptionally poorly with paradox games’ focus on simulation. But the claims on prior games just seems difficult to countenance, at least wrt Victoria. Sure, you industrialize more easily, but politics is significantly harder, literacy is less insane (ottoman nobility had 10% literacy in V2, my beloathed…) and like yeah you have council republic and the unabomber, but it’s Victoria. V2 has bespoke communist flags for every country. You only see any of this shit if you try, you just weren’t cognizant of people trying for whatever reason. And they were trying, because those communist flags are a hoot (also Victoria 2 is barely a game with an lfcap economy, and last I checked the simulation breaks down in 1870. The simulation breaks a lot less in v3, which is saying a lot. I did like inventions tho, that was a neat idea.)
Perhaps I’m being too harsh on Vic3 in it’s current state, I haven’t really kept up with it over the last year. Both 2 and 3 let you push some crazy and ahistoric behavior, but I’ve seen a far wider range of wacky political and economic outcomes from 3 that I know would be impossible to reproduce in 2, things like the BeNeLux megacity, insane levels of economic growth, or finishing the tech tree before 1900 for example. And last I heard 3’s economic simulation also seems to break down around 1900, not to mention it’s difficulty reproducing the world wars. Vic3’s probably not as egregious as HOI4 or CK3 in it’s “meme mechanics,” but it feels similar to me in how it was built to be much more of a frictionless sandbox for the player than earlier titles.
Again, politics is straightforward in being harder now. Getting a desired party into power ended all policy struggles in v2. Getting a desired party into power is generally step 2 of X now, and realistically you’ll need intermediary parties for most countries to start breaking the landowners. V2 had fewer diplomacy levers against you even compared to the base game vs hod. Economic growth, maybe, I don’t care to track gdp vs. gdp and reserving at least some capacity to develop necessities helps force a dumdum ai through. And hypothetically the economy matters more to you to that degree, that’s fine. But there are plenty of places the simulation gives friction that it objectively didn’t in 2, and it’s at most one field the other way around. And rn you definitely can get to the end date without the economy going into a horrible crash and burn, tho reliability can’t really be easily checked on that myself. The full tech tree is stale, but yeah, that did happen for a bit. IIRC you don’t finish it at all rn? I know they tried to force a choice in focus in the last tiers but I can’t recall if that’s working out.
TBQH I made my first game in v2 to be get communists in power. Succeeded. It was harder to me to do that than V3. Now to be fair that was a much harder game militarily and diplomatically because that was a different nation but then, V3 also specifically doesn’t let you micromanage the military to accomplish absolute bullshit. Again, I can see the economy mattering more to a person, it’s your free time, but the idea that it’s objectively more sandboxy just isn’t true. Most I can figure for it is that you’ll see the unabomber law in that tab. It’ll be at 0% all game probably, but you’ll see it.
also while it’s technically not related to enforcing your will on the world, I gotta say, “European nobility has 10% literacy” literally became one of my white whales of absurd start positions in paradox games, which I have rated every future simulation against, alongside the minamoto ruling in the eu timeframe. Also bureaucrats who technically do almost nothing.
Yeah, I kinda disagree. Not that these aren’t problems with Vicky 3 (though as usual they’re constantly tweaking it) but they were definitely *moreso* in Vicky 2. Politics especially put up a lot more of a fight, though the economy is basically a wash.
I remember that for abit in Vicky 2 the game would inevitably end up with most countries going socialist because of lack of fruit (fruit production was concentrated in certain areas like Brazil, a lot of these tended to have revolts, while under occupation territory doesen’t produce anyhting, food was a fairly important need which meant fruit shortage lead to radicalization and constant revolts. End results could be a revolt in Brazil causing most of the world to go communist…)
Now to be fair, they did fix this eventually, but just pointing out that Vicky 2’s economic simulator was not exactly any more robust.
I suspect, without having played Vic2, that Vic3 allows more stable wacky outcomes, although some places do definitely still get into the serial revolt state, whereas what you’re describing there makes it sound like the world economy is balanced on a couple of precarious pillars which can doom everybody to a bizarre hell world if they break.
The frictionlessness really started in EU4. The mission trees were a way to guide the AI nations into behaving in a roughly historical manner, which is great when it unfolds that way.
But it can be crude. A glaring example is how Spain’s mission tree just gives you claims on the Low Countries, regardless of Spain’s diplomacy and dynastic claims in that game. So essentially Isabella becomes queen and says “Right, first we take over Granada, then its on to Belgium, obviously.”
It’s a genuine problem to simulate what is essentially, very specific stuff happening. On the one hand, yes, the entire Habsurg inheritance shenanigans was to some extent a game of chance, but without them succeeding most of the time the early-modern period very quickly stops feeling like the early-modern period at all. They’ve tried various approaches in various games (and often in the *same* game at different points in time) but there isn’t really a satisfying solution.
Edit suggstion: “and it does as does Kaiserreich”. Should that be “as does Kaiserreich”.
To add my own two cents, every time I have tried to play as one of the Western Allies (which granted has been a while, I play HOI only intermittently and vanilla HOI even more rarely), I have simply been bored. There is something FUN about playing a map painter, which unfortunately pulls towards the axis.
This is why I consider Kaiserreich the actual superior game compared to vanilla, as all three major factions and some of the bigger independents (Russia, Japan, Austria) have *some* incentive to go map painting (or in the case of the Internationale, regime change the entire world into socialist states).
When I was a teenager I used to play Battle Cry, a U.S. Civil War game, with my friend, who was an expert at it. (He grew up to be an Air Force officer.) For the sake of the game, it made the North and South equal in resources including railroads, when the North obviously had most of the advantages.
I notice that whereas Brett says, “[H]istorians generally regard World War II as a contest . . . in which fascism proved inferior,” he doesn’t claim (because it would be false) that “historians generally” believe in the “considerable advantages of liberal democracies and free market economies.”
I’m also curious (I haven’t played the game), does the game accurately model the behavior of the Red Army? Historians generally have a tendency to excuse and conceal that, including Adam Tooze, although to be fair he was more critical of the Red Army in the classroom than in his book.
If I understand the question, then outside of the purge, no. There’s no mass suppression of Eastern European partisans or tracking of civilian deaths as the red army advance, no reprisal killings, no wartime sexual violence, none of that. I think the only exception ever mentioned in any hoi was the rape of nanking. There’s similarly no mention of the sexual violence against Italian civilians by allied troops either, or any of the similar crimes during or after the battle of Okinawa.
Of course that’s basically a drop in the bucket compared to the complete lack of mention for the Holocaust and other axis atrocities, which is a much bigger absence as it represented strategic policy.
In general the games system for modeling any form of occupation is whitewashed and exceedingly weak.
“There’s no mass suppression of Eastern European partisans”
There kinda is, it’s just handled by the usual resistance mechanics (IE: As you advance out of soviet cored territory you’ll start to suffer from resistance)
The HOI4 resistance system is actuall,y genuinely kinda interesting, it just sorta operates in that weird space where you don’t *interact* with it. It’s just sorta there eating up infantry equipment in the background.
I’m guessing that by “the behavior of the Red Army” you mean towards civilians, and it does not. It doesn’t model the behavior towards civilians of any army, really, because civilians are hidden behind so many layers of abstraction that they effectively cease to exist. For example, to train new divisions you require manpower, which is generated by the provinces you hold. Each province has a population number, and a percentage of it is added to your available manpower on a regular basis based on things like your conscription and occupation laws (i.e. you don’t get as many recruits from your colonies as from your homeland).
Now, here’s the thing, that population number? Nothing can make it go down. Not invasion, not bombing, not even getting hit by a thermonuclear bomb. Oh, nuking a province gives it a -70% Manpower Generation malus (or something along those lines) for a while, but once that effect runs out the population is effectively the same as before.
If you go strictly by the text of the game you can fight and win WWII, and WWIII if you feel like it, without ever harming a single civilian.
That’s baffling! What a bizarre choice for a game based on an era of total war and unprecedented civilian casualties!
Well, it’s because the population number doesn’t represent the number of civilians in the territory, it’s an abstraction showing an ideal population. So a -70% manpower generation malus represents the deaths of ~70 of the population number; from the distant perspective of the player, those deaths are temporary as unmodeled population movements and birthrate changes will eventually fill in the difference. Nearly every named number in any Paradox game is an abstraction of multiple factors, and consequently most of their names for numbers are misnomers.
As some one who has played more Kaiserreich than base HOI4 I feel the need to defend it a bit. Especially, in the last couple of updates has gone out of its way to highlight that the more right wing authoritarian paths are bad outcomes and highly unlikely to work in the long run. Savinkov’s path for Russia ends with an event showing him to a depressed drunk loser who started 2 World Wars out of his own egomania and delusions of grandeur and who’s empire is going to wither away due to corruption and neglect. For Germany by far the best outcome narratively is shown to be the SPD’s path where Germany transitions to full a British style constitutional monarchy, while Schleicher’s authoritarian militarist path alludes to the fact that even right after the end of the war corruption and mismanagement are already seeping into the foundations of the German state, and heavily implies that Germany will waste its victory trying to cling onto its empire in Africa to the bitter end.
For criticism, I will say the depiction of the more democratic paths of the French Exiles (socialist revolutions broke out in both the UK and France after WW1 and their governments fled to the colonies) is not great and kind of tries to side step that they’re running a white supremacist regime over large parts of Africa while conscripting Africans to die in their reconquest of the French Mainland, and they can also fully integrate and core all their colonies afterwards, which is highly unrealistic to say the least. Japan also doesn’t show Democracy to be any different that their militarist paths, but that’s in large part because Japan’s content is ancient. Finally, there’s Mustafa Kemal’s path for the Ottoman Empire, which is very progressive and secular, but is also be pretty authoritarian given his goal is basically dragging the entire Middle East kicking and screaming into being more like the Western World.
They’re updating both France and Britain soon so we’ll see how they depict those regimes, especially since in Kaisserreich’s world Syndicalism is the dominant socialist ideology rather than Marxist-Leninism.
I’ve never played it, but from what I’ve heard it should also be noted that it’s called Kaisererich to signify it’s not about Nazis because it’s a “What if Germany did better in WW1 and the Kaiser still ruled instead of being replaced by a democracy and then Nazis, but now alt-WW2 is coming around”, which is fertile ground for non-Nazi What Ifs, although I am sure it has a number of fans who play it as Germany taking whatever Nazi-adjacent path exists.
The closest to a Nazi path in Kaiserreich for Germany itself is Kurt von Schliecher’s path which does set up a heavily militarized and authoritarian corporatist state, but is way less genocidal than Nazi Germany. The closest though is a secret path for the United Baltic Duchy which requires the National Populists/Fascists to take over and then for Germany to lose WW2 and then the United Baltic Duchy alone to manage to defeat both Russia and the Third International to reconquer Germany. It’s absurdly hard to do without cheating because the UBD has so little manpower and industry you struggle to field even a full general’s worth of actual proper divisions. By the same token, if the UBD collapses and Socialist Latvia manages to conquer Russia somehow they can reform the USSR.
On a related note of defending Kaiserreich, I want to add on to object to this sentence in particular:
“[Y]ou would have to be a little daft not to recognize the bit of marketing work being done by a mod which overhauls basically the entire map calling itself Kaiserreich”
“Marketing work” is implying a level of intentionality to the idea that the devs of KR are appealing to Nazis via the name, one that I find borderline slanderous. Even including Bret’s prior sentence of explicitly denying that Kaiserreich is a Nazi mod, I still think this is a wildly irresponsible way of objecting to the mod’s name. Like, think about what “marketing work” means in this context. If you’re marketing a product, even a free mod, you are trying to entice people to, in this case, play the mod by making it appealing to them. Notice it is an act of doing– one *does* marketing, not have marketing done to them by circumstance. A product’s name is especially an intentional choice– like you can theoretically unintentionally name a product after a dogwhistle you weren’t aware of, but you still chose the name.
So when Bret says that “marketing work [was] done… calling itself Kaiserreich”, I can’t help but read it as “the name Kaiserreich, in specific, was chosen to appeal to the Nazis within the modding community”. Which, to me, is a really big claim that needs a lot more evidence than just the fact the mod is named after a colloquial term for the German Empire. The German Empire, a different government that predates the Nazis in which the Nazis had an ambivalent (although obviously more positive than the republican era) relationship towards. One whose existence within the context of the mod sidesteps the formation of the NSDAP entirely, and intentionally writes off most of its historical leadership to not even give the player the option to put them into power (Goering being the one major exception due to his family’s aristocratic background and role in administrating Africa being too much of a hole to write him off in the narrative, but they make sure to make him universally incompetent and doomed to fail in his job, and also he can’t leave the African colonies either).
Like, sure, call me a little daft, but I don’t think Kaiserreich, as a name, is a dogwhistle (Neo-Nazi appropiation of Imperial aesthetics does not change the fact the German Empire itself existed independently of the Nazis and can be used in fiction on its own independent merits), but even if for the sake of argument we assume it is, I sure as hell don’t think its an intentional dogwhistle. But saying that the name was “marketing work”, to me, is akin to saying that it was an intentional dogwhistle, and that’s why I as someone who spent a lot of time in the KR community take some extreme umbrage to this statement. I would not have spent the countless hours making my own fan content for Kaiserreich if for a second I thought the mod was intentionally trying to court Nazis in a wink wink sort of way. And I also say that as someone who had gotten booted off projects in the HOI4 modding community for calling out nazis when I see them, to the point where it influenced why my name says former. I am not trying to say the problem doesn’t exist writ large. It absolutely does. But “marketing work” is just… too far, imo.
As an addendum, after I shared this post with a friend (but before it was approved), they pointed out to me Goering was removed from the mod a while ago and I just somehow never noticed because I just don’t play the mod as much as I used to when I was more involved with the community. So even that caveat wasn’t necessary.
Goering is still in the mod, but he’s a minor member of the Reichstag who gets convicted and thrown out for corruption.
On an unrelated note I just wish there somehow can be a Kaiserreich in Vic3. HoI4 is really boring with all the clicking events and focus tree before the big war happens.
Yeah, the idea that Kasierreich is somehow, as Brett puts it, “borderline material that isn’t pro-Nazi per-se but happens to focus on the elements that Nazi players want to focus on”, just does not seem remotely plausible to me. (And attending to the *name*, in isolation, is ridiculous beyond belief; was If the protagonist of Vanilla HOI4 is Nazi Germany, the closest thing Kaiserreich has to a protagonist is the Commune of France, with a strong supporting cast of other revisionist powers, and an overly detailed subplot focused exclusively on the United States. Vanilla is about Hitler trying to conquer the world; Kaiserreich is about Germany’s victims coming back for revenge on the one hand, and the coming world revolution on the other.
Something like fascism does exist, in Romania, Japan, and potentially Russia, but it is very much a second-class citizen of Kaiserreich’s implicit theory of history. It is, generously, on the same tier as Catholic integralism in National France or the Confederate throwbacks in Huey Long’s America: more like local branding on the same right-wing authoritarian template than a force in its own right. The only alt-Nazi who is a real historical force is Savinkov, who by the endgame is very explicitly a psychotic monster trying to bring about a nuclear apocalypse.
The narrative spine of Kaiserreich is, in the end, something like this: the German Empire is dying, and it probably deserves to; the Entente are simmering in exile, a tiny foreign aristocracy atop an angry public, hoping to turn back time; Paris stands poised on the edge of a knife, la devise to the one side and Bonaparte on the other; the fate of Europe may well rest again in the hands of the Americans, and they’re about to fight a civil war. Kaiserreich is, to a first approximation, about the final struggle between the international socialist revolution and the German world order. The best Internationale paths are borderline utopian; socialist America especially is embarrassingly contemporary. The absolute best German path, for both Germany and the world, is a kinder gentler imperial hegemony, beneath the Vichy SPD. The right wing paths are all corrupt, incompetent, *doomed* regimes. No remotely defensible authoritarian Germany is on offer, to anyone, ever. I can’t claim intimate knowledge of the Nazi mind, because like everyone else here I do not have much to do with Nazis, but nonetheless I’m pretty sure this is not the sort of narrative they’re after.
I love Millennium Dawn, it’s such a fantastic mod and way better than the vanilla game, and I had no idea it was so popular among neo-Nazi.
A bit of a sidenote, but as someone who started playing Paradox games during the Falalalalan era, its weird to me how Kaiserreich morphed, and I keep wondering what the original creator, Sarmatia1871 thinks of it.
It started in the olden days of HoI2 with a “what is Germany lost WWI but the RCW ended in a stalemate” mod, called All The Little Russias. Then it went into “what is Germany _won_ WWI, and that is why the RCW ended in a mutual loss”, with Russia still taking about 50% of the content.
And I have no idea anymore what the idea and ethos, if there is any, behind Kaiserreich is anymore in these days. As wacky as it is, Red Flood seems like a more coherent vision (“the Great War burned away all previous ideas and mores, let the cauldron of ideologies bubble and overflow”)
Modern Kaiserreich, has mainly focused on sanding down a lot of the zanier stuff and instead trying to create an overall more grounded scenario with a lot of historical research involved (the amount of niche Chinese political figures from the Interwar period who get an absurd amount of detail going into the nuances of their specific ideologies is absurd. Between all the various Chinese tags there’s at least a dozen different Kuomintang paths, and there’s also the Federalists, the Zhili Clique, and Fengtian.) They’ve also put a lot more focus on narrative, though not so much it becomes a visual novel like TNO, especially in the past couple of updates which focused on Germany, Eastern Europe, and Russia. There’s still some crazy stuff like the Second American Civil War which largely is still there because it’s an iconic part of the mod that’s been there since before HOI4 even released.
I think in my mind I merged Kaiserreich and Kaiserredux. When did this re-cohering of the KR vision take place? I stopped paying attention in approx 2021.
It was pretty soon after that, it was around the time of the China rework, and it really accelerated with the various Eastern European reworks. With the Germany Rework having been the big 1.0 release. Germany’s content now revolves around managing Black Monday and the economy, trying whichever political path you’re going from getting tossed out of office by their rivals with a mechanic for simulating Reichstag support as well as internal coalition tensions, and using diplomacy and spies to desperately try to delay WW2 while sending volunteers to intervene in proxy wars to try and shape a more favorable geopolitical situation.
Russia’s content is less complicated, but still gives more focus to things like trying to break German economic influence over Europe and depending on what path you’re going either keeping the military and populace from getting pissed off enough that they overthrow Savinkov, getting them pissed enough that they overthrow him but keeping the military content enough that they stop a socialist revolution from happening, or getting both of them so angry that military high command loses control over the army and the socialists retake power. Assuming the socialists don’t take over whether Russia restores the Republic or becomes a Constitutional Monarchy depends on whether Denikin or Wrangel is selected as the head of the Russian Army.
I might try it out again, thanks
“(the amount of niche Chinese political figures from the Interwar period who get an absurd amount of detail going into the nuances of their specific ideologies is absurd. Between all the various Chinese tags there’s at least a dozen different Kuomintang paths, and there’s also the Federalists, the Zhili Clique, and Fengtian.)”
Oh, interesting! This reminds me, I’ve been wondering for a while (at least since reading this https://nathangoldwag.wordpress.com/2025/06/06/the-young-marshals-long-career/ ), did anyone in Chinese politics at the time other than the CCP and the KMT bother working out a half-way coherent ideology?
It depends, on what time period you were talking about. The Federalist movement wanted a more American style Federal system, and was mainly led by Sun Yat-Sen’s one time friend Chen Jiongming, but they have a following out during the 20s, Chen shells Sun’s house and causes Sun’s wife and fellow revolutionary Soong Ching-Ling to miscarry which sours their friendship to say the least. Sun and the KMT then beat the Federalists and Chen ends up dying of Typhoid in the early 30s.
Oh, thank you! Interesting!
Well, “coherent” is a hard sell but some warlods like Yan Xishan did try to create their own bespoke ideology: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yan_Xishan
Sarmy’s reaction is mostly amusement mixed with horror of what he created, IIRC: But then again he is british.
If a young man plays hearts of iron two there are two possible outcomes. Either he can become a nazi or she can transition and become a communist.
Hey, I played it as a teenage boy and while I did transition my favorite political philosopher is John Stuart Mill.
By the terms of modern political discourse anyone who has a favorite political philosopher who isn’t Ayn Rand or a fascist/neonazi is a communist.
Sorry you had to find out this way. Was the same for me. 🙁
Or it’s that anyone that is farther to the right than a democratic socialist is considered a fascist, and the former are on thin ice.
They might even both be true. Schrodinger’s Extremist.
To comment on the actual meat: While there are many, many terrible design decisions in HoI4, I don’t think its unreasonable for it to be Germany-focused. Germany, historically, lost, so reversing that trend is an interesting challenge, while playing historically is not. Interesting anti-Germany gameplay requires, due to the 1936 start date, either an unrealistically buffed AI Germany, of the introcution of a 1941 start date for USSR/USA players.
I’m close to an aster-wearing social democrat in the old vein, but I play exclusively Germany, if I play unmodded HoI4 at all, simply because it has a lot more to do than any other nation. Which, yes, is the problematic design choice.
The thing is that on consideration, the shift it represents is not “discrete alternate history sells.” It appears to be “losers are more interesting than winners.” It’s too irritating to track how eu4 releases changed after Death before Dishonor (the first crack at Germany trees), but CK3 has released large amounts of bespoke content for other factions and cultures (though you could make the case moderately that the game is still kinda brittaifrench bespoke content to start with). In V3, Britain has events, sure, and there’s the civil war for America, but the overwhelming bulk of bespoke content is well, for people who less won the Victorian period. The biggest winner who’s gotten serious focus so far is Japan. Britain has some bespoke content, Germany has some, USA, the USA…. The dlc focuses have far more been unambiguous losers of the period like Persia, India, Iberia, Austria and the like. Granted, I don’t have my finger on eu5’s pulse.
Sure, but, especially for the “Wages of Destruction is a holy text” folks, like our dear author, WWII is an overdetermined conflict where the anti-Axis coalition is sure to win. There simply isnt much material to be mined out of that.
By contrast, it was in no way overdetermined that the UK or USA would “win” the Victoria 2/3 period. Victoria covers a genuinely transformative period of history, while the actual transformation in OTL WWII took place before and after. Any genuine transformation, that is, any genuinely interesting gameplay, requires an Axis non-defeat.
And now, I feel I will have to take a shower after typing this, but I have to defend TNO (and Thousand Week Reich).
I haven’t played TNO in a while, but back in the day, apart from being an interactive novel, it was explicity anti-authoriterian and anti-nazi. The insane SS state in Burgundy are the explicit BAD GUYS, who want a new, now nuclear genocide. Even if Himmler (?) does not succeed in this, in most games, Germany is destined to fail and collapse under its internal contradictions, being either a Francoist Spain analogue, or something more functional.
TWRs Germany likewise collapses.
Now, in both mods, managing and somehow reversing this collapse is the _interesting gameplay_ when playing Germany, but the text-as-written is not exactly pro-Nazi in either mod. Or at least it wasnt a few years ago. Nazi chuds might misinterpret that, but Nazi chuds would probably misinterprest the Dead Kennedys.
Nazi chuds apparently did, which is why the Dead Kennedys felt moved to write Nazi Punks Fuck Off.
It’s a great song but not exactly subtle.
To focus on one small detail of the post for a moment, I think simulating the strategic aims of the major Western allies might be a bit difficult because the countries in question weren’t necessarily clear on those themselves. To use one concrete example, within the British War Coalition, Churchill and Attlee might well have had quite different war aims. Even the IJA and the IJN were probably closer to each other in their ideas about ultimate end goals.
Interestingly, there are currently mechanics in HOI4 (added in some DLC but I have no idea which one) for creating the sort of Italian or Japanese resource-extration focused empire OGH described. In a peace deal you can create puppet govts and force said puppets to hand you their resources, as well as the economic might of their civilian and military factories.
Just a little detail I thought worth mentioning. Another area where the game seems more interested in modeling the economic viewpoints and theories of fascist and militarist govts, instead of liberal democracies.
Iron delights have iron ends?
Out of curiosity, would there be any way to wrangle WordPress to provide a better overview of the *latest* comments at any given moment here?
Not that I know of. My workaround is to use my browser’s search function to look for the date and hour, like “October 30, 2026 at 6:” to go through the new posts one at a time. Of course, you will have to skip past the am comments when looking for the pm ones.
Thank you, that’s more or less what I sometimes do. Wondered if there was a better way
I just subscribe to comments on the posts and go through the emails one by one. Not sure how to subscribe while logged in, though; I had to log out and log back in on this post.
Also I’d like to be able to subscribe to comments on a post without commenting, but my experience on Wildbow’s web serials is that the default implementation of that button doesn’t work. So I feel compelled to find something to say about a post to watch the discussion and have missed some discussions when I couldn’t think of anything worth posting on it.
Side question
Sorry, error caused while logging in trying to figure out how to subscribe to comments; for future reference, does anyone know how to subscribe to comments on a post while logged into a wordpress account? I got the popup when I logged in on the above after having been unable to find it previously. Is it automatic going forwards?
Anyway, that is certainly a failure of modeling goals as compared to Victoria and CK.
Victoria 3 has its “score” as prestige, which goes up by being higher tier*, increasing GDP, being a leading producer of a good (variable by good in the ways you’d expect),a powerful army and especially navy, and various specific achievements and monuments, plus a share of your subject’s prestige, so basically you want to be an industrialized British Empire with vast direct or indirect colonial holdings. Having enough to put you at either x5 average or 75% of #1 (initially Britain by a mile) while being independent and a Recognized Power (a status much of Asia and Africa have to break into) makes you a Great Power with various mechanical effects. Strikes me as suitable for an industrial revolution nation to aspire to. Or if you want to pursue more modern sensibilities, your average Standard of Living and literacy rate are prominently displayed and have their own important mechanical effects.
CK2 didn’t have a mechanical impact of score but it summed up the piety and prestige of each ruler when they died and then told you which historical dynasty the game considers you to have done better than, so basically you want a succession of well-respected and/or godly rulers who have a ton of titles, do well in wars, go on Crusades, etc.
CK3 ditches having an official score but you do have a Level of Splendor reflecting the Renown your dynasty has achieved, with the main sources being Royal Court quality, total number of dynasty members up to a cap, and the highest title of every member of your dynasty who isn’t subordinate to other members of your dynasty, plus marriages to landed rulers. This has direct mechanical effects that grant every member of your dynasty prestige on birth and make them better marriage prospects, plus you can spend Renown to unlock dynasty-wide perks and for a couple other useful options like kicking a son out of inheritance in a reversible manner, very useful if you have multiple sons and one of them sucks. I actually think this isn’t a great score system since durably taking control of a reborn Roman Empire holding most of Europe with every kingdom-level subdivision held by your dynasty forever is worth less Renown than having three tiny Iberian kingdoms that got split among multiple heirs and can’t manage to reunify or expand, and I really don’t feel like the mechanical benefits are big enough to let my realm split or put forth effort to putting dynasty members on other thrones that aren’t then my vassals, but it’s got a clear goal of growing your dynasty and marrying among nobility to eventually establish a Hapsburg or Karling situation where your dynasty rules a bunch of independent kingdoms.
It also has some Major Decisions that serve as de facto run goals for me where they’re in a special section of the decisions tab and their requirements are visible way before you can take them. Stuff like restoring a unified Roman Empire (unlocks Dismantle the Greek/German pretenders CBs to unequivocally be the only Roman Emperor and has a special challenge mode available that’s sadly badly implemented), uniting the Slavs, having ten independent kings of your dynasty, making Japan transition from rule by burecrats to a proper Shogunate, making the Emperor of Japan the temporal ruler in practice, restoring China after it goes through a “Long United, Must Divide” situation with yourself as emperor**, etc. Frankly, CK3 is too easy and Paradox’s efforts to fix this have so far resulted in things that are still too easy but also annoying, so often I de facto call a game after achieving one of these, often in a single lifetime with a not-to-insane custom character.
*This is fixed for a nation “tag” with many nations having some sort of path to upgrading to a higher-tier tag, like going from Austria to Germany to potentially a Central Europe power
**mechanically China, Rome, United India, Dar Al Islam, (uniting Islam under your rule) Mongol Khans, and something Jerusalem based called the Kingdom of Heaven that I think is new are a super-emperor tier called hegemon who can have regular emperors as vassals. China also has a special government (neighboring China-influenced states can share some mechanics) that anyone who claims the Mandate of Heaven must use, although if you’re an invader you get a window in which it’s super-easy to impose rulers of your culture in an attempt to not get culturally assimilated entirely.
Hegemony is the tier that’s above Emperor, they’re all bespoke (currently they’re China, the only one that actually exists in any start position, Dar-al-Islam, the Roman Empire (technically there’s two if you decide to cleave the empire, in an eastern and western one) the Khaganate and the Kingdom of Heaven, which requires you to be a christian ecclestiastical government and hold Jerusalem, which is a fairly tricky one since ecclestiastical governments can’t declare normal wars, though you can fudge it in various ways)
Note that pretty much all Paradox games have “end game tags” of that kind of type. HOI4 has a bunch of them (though usually for smaller nations) often very silly, but challenges like taking the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kumul_Khanate and restoring the Mongol Empire or creating a pan-turanian state as Turkey is there for late game silliness. It’s just that it’s largely not something the actual majors can do. (closest thing is the Imperial Federation silliness, and a potential EU tag for various european democracies, etc.)
Typo watch:
“Thus, even if Japanese actions ‘bubbled up’ from junior officers or resulted from competition between the IJN and the IJA, the fact that Imperial Japan backed and justified those actions make them state polity.”
Last word should be “policy”. (Unless I’m very seriously misunderstanding the intended statement.)
Typo Hunt:
“even more money and even more lived in a likely doomed effort to maintain its overseas empire by force.”
ITYM “even more lives”
Reading this, it occurs to me that I don’t really have as good a grasp on Italy/Mussolini’s war aims as I do the other Axis powers. Probably because they did so terribly in fighting the war, Italy doesn’t get discussed as much. Are there any particularly recommended books for WWII focusing on Italy?
Assuming you don’t read Italian, focusing strictly on the war from the Italian pow, and in no particular order:
If you wish more specific suggestions please let me know.
You could do a lot worse than consulting this person (a member of the Libyan Jewish diaspora in Denmark, who views fascism primarily through the lens of the genocide they perpetrated in Libya in the 1930s.) There are two book recommendations at the end of that thread, (although they are less about WWII specifically and more about the overarching goals of the Mussolini’s state) and he has a whole thread of review essays pinned to his account. While some of his conclusions currently go too far even for me (i.e. he appears to view the entire concept of the nation-state as enshrined in the UN as a legacy of colonialism), he nevertheless appears to have read just about every book on both Mussolini’s Italy and European colonialism in North Africa.
Regarding your note 1, I agree it’s common knowledge on the internet that the game’s community has many extremists, but two of the posts you linked as examples have their own problems.
One, on r/SocialistGaming, devolves into a complaint about “rightist” over-representation in general and treats the absence of Marxist theory as a lack of “proper economic understanding”; the other is titled “Hoi4 community tab is full of alt right non-sense” while being an outright denial of North Korea’s problems (to put it politely) as illustrated by the well-known “night lights” satellite images.
Surely you could have found more neutral (or less “tankie”) forum examples.
going to reddit to learn about political topics (aside from purely academic subs like r/AskHistorian) is a bad idea anyway.
It was surreal to see those two listed here given the host’s politics and history with the very kind leftists he’s citing.
What are you referring to?
I suspect it’s about the various clashes with Bluesky userbase, which is frequently well to the left of him. I.e. I think the below was by far the most controversial statement he had made over there, but there have been other episodes. (I.e. arguing that voting for the Democratic candidates in America always represents “the lesser evil”, as he predictably did more recently, is a reliable way to get a number of users angry – there were even questions if electing Hindenburg only for him to appoint Hitler anyway was the lesser evil.)
These disagreements are pretty insubstantial, in truth. The idea that fascism is permanent is true in current context even if you disagree in the abstract. That’s one of those largely theoretical disagreements that falls aside outside of online arguments.
More significant has been his vote blue no matter who stances. Intellectually this was torpedoed to death about two days ago by Stevens attempting to ratfuck senator El-Sayed in an unhinged maniacal act of Zionist derangement, which ex facto proves she’d have been an utterly intolerable candidate if elected. It’s also an absolutely damning indictment of Schumer and all the establishment dems who pushed for her, given that they couldn’t see what she was despite meeting her, while the left generally hss been warning about her behavior since the primary.
On the other side of Platner hadn’t stepped down I doubt Bret would have supported him, so the idea was already fraying.
I expect these events to help push Bret to abandon that stance overall, but given that the Stevens debacle happened two days ago and there was a massacre of an election in between it might take a bit for Joe Lib to internalize that supporting some candidates is worse than doing nothing.
In other words Bret might have just been behind the curve here, but there’s plenty of evidence to support change.
I mean, I should have noted he’s also had a number of clashes with “tankies” who apparently make up the bulk of either subreddit for the more classic “legacy of the USSR/criticism of the PRC/arguing it’s bad for Iran to win the ongoing conflict outright” reasons. The argument about the alleged permanence of fascism is just the one which had pulled in a lot more people outside of that core orbit, and so was the first thing which came to mind.
Anyway; we have preferential voting over here, which means that the whole debate is thankfully just not a thing for us. Hence, my thoughts here are, in a sense, purely theoretical. Nevertheless, it seems to me that in a narrow sense, the Stevens debacle had only conclusively proved that some in the party have always been hypocritical about the notion. You could even argue the fact that, to the best of my knowledge, she had already been expelled from the state party and condemned by virtually every Democrat of note (besides Gavin Newsom, that is) only reinforces the principle.
Now, the opposite idea you hold to – “supporting some candidates is worse than doing nothing” seems to rest on two principles:
In general, the only two cases I can recall where the principle clearly wouldn’t seem to hold up are Platner and maybe Fetterman (the latter requires one to imagine Senator Oz as a strongly moderating force on the rest of his party’s Islamophobia – which is both speculative and presumes that would have been better in the long run than the GOP stumbling into this year’s disaster). Then again, I am thankfully not in the US, so perhaps you could tell me of others.
P.S. For the record, this was our host’s position on Platner at a point he had formally won the primary but before the rape allegations which ultimately led him to drop out. I wish his position had been firmer, earlier, but at least it’s not e.g. Will Stancil going “if Platner refuses to drop out the utilitarian logic doesn’t really change” after the allegations – even as he was against Platner in the primary from the start, before people even knew about his SS tattoo. (And after Platner did drop out, Stancil eulogized him as “someone whose path to any kind of redemption has been thoroughly wrecked by a bunch of political figures who saw him as a vehicle to power”, so that “you could almost feel sorry for him”, for good measure.)
The vetting angle is major too, though. I really need to emphasize that Platner had no credible allegations before basically the week he dropped out; everything prior to that was exceedingly weak, with no evidence and very biased sources.
(Of sex crimes. He clearly had a period of far right sympathy at some point, but no one disputed that.)
What changed was that there were allegations which were made prior to him entering public life, with a paper trail, that came out.
Stevens, meanwhile, has been like this the entire time, unstable and deranged. It strains belief that anyone within the party could pick her for anything except these qualities, that no one, including Schumer who heavily supported her, could not have known she was petty, unstable, and dumb. That indictment of the party is significant here.
I think you’re missing an angle.
It’s not just about issues, it’s about voter confidence in an electoral process. You can absolutely frame it as “Stevens made the party worse on such and such issue”, and I think it is pretty much a given that this is true. “Israel comes to me in my dreams” is on the extreme end; millions in AIPAC money is an outlier. She was worse than El Sayed on everything.
But much more damning is the idea that your vote doesn’t matter. If Stevens won she was just a Republican. Any differences were minor, policy wise she was borderline and she obviously believed in zero policies besides supporting Israel anyway. Every time people learn that the election is a farce, that you can go out on principle and vote to change the party and country, and nothing fucking changes, it’s permanent damage to democracy itself.
The worst possible result is not yet past us. It’s not if Republicans won yesterday, it’s if Democrats won, drop all prosecutions, approve ICE, vote to continue the war, and pat themselves on the back for condemning Hamas and Bibi both even as Eiserot or whomever he is occupies the west bank. It’s if Democrats are Republicans with blue hats.
The worst outcome is one where voters give up on democracy. That’s what AIPAC actually wants and what people like Stevens represents. Likewise it’s more damaging to say “rapists welcome”, even if it’s right in some mathematical function of issues.
Everything I said is also an absolutely damning indictment of Schumer and Jefferies too, and them remaining in power is very bad if it happens, particularly past 2028. It’s also worth noting that what I said becomes less true if Schumer and Jefferies aren’t in charge, in which case Stevens being a Republican is a minor fluke rather than an intentional act by democratic leadership.
In that context refusing to vote and letting an open monster win over a secret monster is better. Trust in democracy is more important than any other outcome.
Well…
Just went on an all mighty rabbit hole to try to figure this out.
So, first off, neither critique is that bad and they only indicate bias if they’re wrong etc. we can talk later.
But what really interests me is the post on north Korea blackout. Comments range from reasonable, pointing out the hypocrisy of depicting north Korea as an arch threat and also backwards, to the idealogical but not wrong, pointing out that China is lit up, to the deni hialist. However the denialist comments aren’t just going through uncommented, and they seem to have evidence supporting them.
This image.
This image is a problem. It looks legitimate, who would hand draw fake lights? How? Why?
If you’re prone to believe people will engage in information control even on scale then you rapidly spiral into either-“this person is lying to me” or ” the popular narrative is a lie”. Both are reasonable conclusions. But the behavior of those posters does not fit traditional deceptiveness. These appear to be legitimate beliefs.
However there really is no evidence of a conspiracy. Yes, north Korea has blackouts and is brighter the rest of the time, but that’s not this image. Faking one image is one thing, faking yearly images and videos that are distinct but similar is nuts.
What’s happening? Hint, the original is not digital, that’s a poster.
I think I found it. It’s from a map of human footprint depicted as bright spots, by a geospatial scientist in 2016.
https://www.grahamfoundation.org/grantees/5435?body_class=grantee&mode=overview
Look at the top right map in his cluster.
Someone applied a yellow filter, intentionally or accidentally, then cropped it. It might even be a mistake.
This is a high level information fuck up. To untangle it you need not only information literacy, but also time. Being fooled by it isn’t surprising. It’s almost the same map; footprint versus light versus economic activity, it’s just barely different.
In one major way that convinced a bunch of left leaning gamers north Korea wasn’t that backwards.
There’s also the fact that when the Soviet Union did enter the formal conflict in 1941, it basically spent the first three years in what was effectively “survival mode”, with the most Stalin doing about post-war aims was some half-hearted attempts to ask the British and Americans to recognize the Soviet borders acquired in the MR Pact (something they ultimately partly compromised on – recognizing the Soviet acquisition territories from Poland and Romania, but not the annexation of the Baltic States – but only once it became obvious the Soviets were gonna have that territory anyway in 1944). It isn’t until almost the end of 1943 – after the retaking of Eastern Ukraine and right around the Tehran Conference – that we see the Soviets start to seriously start thinking about longer term war goals with the Foreign Commissariat producing the first tentative proposals for how their influence is to be extended over what would eventually become the Warsaw Pact countries.
The Soviet Union entered the formal conflict in 1939, when they invaded Poland as allies of Nazi Germany. For the first two years of WW2 the Soviet Union wasn’t in “survival mode”, it was map painting in Poland, the Baltics, and Finland.
I mean, I was using a rather specific definition of “formally involved in the war”. The invasion of Eastern Poland was only minorly contested by the Poles themselves and did not result in the USSR getting drawn into fighting with either the Western Allies or the Germans. The annexation of the Baltics, the seizure of Bessarabia, and the Winter War are all related to the Second World War, but were not yet formally a part of it either. While they can be said to be strategy, they cannot be said to be war strategy for the obvious reason that it did not result in the Soviet Union at war (well, except the Winter War, obviously). But on the whole the Soviet Union was no more formally involved in the war than the United States was.
However, I make a distinction between being “not formally in the war” and being “neutral in the war” and you are correct that the Soviet Union was very much not that at all. It’s behavior between the signing of the MR Pact and Operation Barbarossa was very much pro-German and the Soviets were very much using the opportunity to maneuver on the Baltic States, Poland, Finland, and Romania.
European countries tried to map painting a lot that that time. Does not mean they were not in survival mode. For example Poland participated in the annexation of Czechoslovakia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Independent_Operational_Group_Silesia
My impression is always that Stalin didn’t really *have* a plan, so much as a rather flexible opportunism (backed by the idea that communism was going to win eventually, and so he basically had to keep improving the position of the USSR until that happened)
Similarily I don’t think the Soviets really had plan for “dominate eastern europe/set up buffer states” until pretty late and even then the specifics largely ended up dictated by the course of the war (IE: Where soviet arms were dominant)
The Nazis were essentially a successful snowball. The invasion of France would not have been possible without Czech resources (lot of military industry and equipment!) and similarly Barbarossa without France. Their annexations also kept away an economic correction. This obviously means they spiral pretty quickly if stopped early, but the fundamental necessity of loot didn’t end.
People focus on the eastern occupation, but it was the western that funded Nazi Germany. France alone was over 40% of the total with the Germans averaging extracting close to half of French GDP. Now a lot of this was assets rather than a given year’s production, but the long-run result is the same. The French economy was spiraling and that level of extraction would soon be literally impossible. Similar for rest of Nazi-occupied Europe. An economic crisis for Germany would happen I expect in the 1950s if they managed to ‘win’, when depending on how much the Nazis can demobilize based on how vigorous a western cold war is and how sensible they are in their extraction policy. Whatever the USSR’s faults, its economic management of its sphere of influence was positively benevolent compared to the Nazis.
Incidentally even if the Nazis managed to defeat the USSR***, unless some agreement or informal cooling down happens they have an issue, which is they will be stuck in high gear for war economically. The USSR may have been paying more blood, but the Western Allies were demanding similar resources in economic terms even before D-Day.
***I think this is more plausible than people think. The USSR was on a fine line between victory and defeat spiral by 1943. It was a fragile triad* between military manpower, industry, and agriculture with very little spare manpower . The months around Kursk had the lowest recruitment of the entire Great Patriotic War. Both Stalingrad and Kursk were must-wins, though admittedly hard to see the Germans winning either in the historical setup.
The idea of the Germans winning quickly I am skeptical of, the gates of Moscow is very different then taking it. But a long war much more plausible (which is where a bit more German success in 1941-42 might decide it). The issue is realistically 1944 is when I would expect the USSR to truly disintegrate.** Which by then the Germans rapidly have a Western Ally problem in spades. The USSR ending up in 1939 borders with 10-20 million more dead is far more plausible than the Nazis actually winning the broader war.
*land-lease was not that important to the early parts of the Eastern Front people tend to see as key. However the contribution is much greater than I believe the USSR margin of error in this area was by 1943.
**In 1941 and 1942 there is significant reserves even if USSR does worse. While in 1943 you start with a huge army even if replacements fall short in quantity and quality.
I don’t think it’s that implausible to try for WW1 russia defeat? Like push the central government to the brink and have them collapse on itself, letting invaders dictate terms.
Collapse into what? In a war for survival, you have very different motivations than WW1. Even if you get warlord factions, everything valuable those factions could fight over is under control of the hated enemy that kicked out/enslaved them. The greatest disagreements are gonna be over when or how to fight back.
Not the first time. China was incredibly divided even under Japanese invasion.
The Nazis had already peeled off just about everyone who was “gettable” well before Kursk. Their most capable “test case” at that time had approximately the area of modern-day Lebanon (about half of New Hampshire, if that makes it easier to visualize.)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lokot_Autonomy
It is also best-known not for any battlefield prowess but for Antonina Makarova (Machinegunner Ton’ka), a turncoat Red Army nurse often described as the most prominent woman mass murderer in history, as she ended up executing an approximate room-full of partisans a day, more-or-less every day.* Likewise, the SS formations made up of the Ukrainians, Georgians, Armenians, etc. willing to side with Hitler for a promise of some form of autonomy or another were primarily relevant when fighting partisans, not on the battlefield.
The largest of those formations, “Russian Liberation Army” did not get formed until 1944 (and even then it amounted to 10 understrength, undersupplied divisions), and it was primarily made up of the POWs who survived the encirclements of early 1942 and were willing to defect. While it’s conceivable the organizational hurdles to its formation could have been cleared by 1943 (“if only the Nazis weren’t Nazis” and didn’t have the core of their very ideology discouraging that), there’s still no real scenario where they get the supplies they need to be particularly effective, at the expense of the actual German forces (or even most other allies, for that matter.)
*Even more remarkably, she was able to withdraw with the Wehrmacht all the way to Berlin – and, as Zhukov and Konev were closing in, she stole the ID of another imprisoned nurse and was able to combine it with the details of her early-war service to pass as a POW. She married a Jewish (!) veteran almost immediately, had children and led a completely unremarkable life as a clothing factory worker afterwards, only getting discovered in 1979 practically by chance.
@hafizh makmur China was very fragmented already, long-term, with KMT in a precarious position. The Japanese invasion didn’t induce civil war, just jumped into an existing one, and in fact put it somewhat on hold until it resolved after WW2 ended – that’s the effect I describe writ small. At Barbarossa time, USSR had just gone through several rounds of power consolidation. The situation isn’t at all equivalent, a much better comparison politically would be post-WW1 or civil war Russia to WW2 China or WW2 Russia with post-civil war China. Don’t mistake pre-existing conditions for the change induced by losing in war.
Replying to this thread is a bit confusing, because you start with “defeat the USSR”, drop the mention of “disintegration” – and then drop a blink-and-you’ll-miss it “ending up in 1939 borders…[rather] than the Nazis actually winning the broader war” – which the other replies ignore to dive into speculating about 1917, which is incredibly silly. Here’s a podcast by a British historian and a Rear Admiral (I dug around to ensure the former, Jonathan Trigg, isn’t just an amateur history writer of the kind maligned by our host, and it appears he did ensure to get history Honours before getting into book-writing – but ironically, it’s the Rear Admiral, Dr Chris Parry, who actually got a history PhD a few years earlier) on the Battle of Kursk and the implications of it going the other way.
https://www.alternatetimelines.org/scenarios/the-battle-of-kursk-had-a-different-result/
To be brief, while they do argue the battle could have been won by the Germans if the concurrent landing in Sicily did not lead to a repositioning of their reserves or if it began in March rather than July (both points are contested on e.g. r/AskHistorians, it must be said), they are quite explicit even Hitler and the rest didn’t actually believe they could have had “disintegrated the Soviet Union” after winning. (Kursk only amounted to a quarter of deployed Red Army manpower, for one.) They believe the most German-favorable scenario following that is Stalin being pushed to agree to an armistice soon afterwards – and an armistice which restores the 1939 borders (i.e. the Germans and other fascists withdraw from all of Ukraine and Belarus) as opposed to freezing the conflict at the then-front line (like e.g. where many expect the current war in Ukraine to end up.)
Kinda like what you said, to be fair, except without the “10-20 million” part. (The peak number of soldiers committed to Kursk was 2.5 million, and assuming all or even most of them would have died in even the worst-case scenario is Ridley Scott’s Gladiator thinking.) They also suggest even that wouldn’t have saved Germany – but merely caused the thrust of the Allied effort to be repositioned to the South of Europe, to attack via Italy, Greece and Provence, as Churchill had always wanted, as opposed to landing at Normandy.)
I suppose the counterargument here is “What if Lend-Lease also wasn’t in play?” – but the thing is, unless we assume the alt-US was so isolationist it refused to provide it to anybody (which is just deeply implausible), those wartime factories would have still been pumping out more-or-less all the same stuff as historically – it would have just reinforced first the North Africa campaign and then the landing in Sicily and other places (and, to a much lesser extent, Nationalist China) instead, so the German strategic situation does not improve all that much (I.e. it seems at least conceivable the Sicily landing might end up pushed forward a month or so earlier with all the extra resources, which potentially more than offsets weaker Soviet forces at Kursk). Besides, the majority of equipment and material provided by Lend-Lease made the most difference in offensive operations – i.e. high-capacity trucks are never amiss, but they are significantly less important when one is on the defensive. (Stuff like e.g. foodstuffs wasn’t nothing, but was still fairly limited – i.e. ~1% of USSR’s total calories came from Lend-Lease.)
If Hitler was actually delusional enough to attempt to march all the way to Moscow again (a mere 500 km from the closest German-occupied point at Orel – and all the fortifications from 1941 at places like Kaluga in between would have only gotten reinforced since then), the Soviet artillery factories would have switched from predominantly producing 76mm artillery to 57mm anti-tank guns (already designed in 1941, but not produced in any number as they weren’t thought to have enough worthwhile up until the Tigers arrived), and the greatest advantage of “the big cats” – the near-immunity to contemporary Soviet anti-tank artillery, which far outnumbered tanks – would have been reset to zero. (This would have also reduced explosive filler consumption, doing a lot to offset the assumed lack of deliveries via Lend-Lease.) Likewise, the mine production, which became of little importance once the USSR went on the offensive, would have kept on going. These and other technological improvements would have allowed the USSR to defend the same locations in 1943 with far more efficiency than in 1941.
*And while they don’t go into such detail, I should note that even the Germans do achieve a mass encirclement at Kursk,, not all encirclements are made equal. The ones the Germans had accomplished in 1941 or especially around Kharkov in 1942 did in fact annihilate whole armies at a limited cost – but not only were the Soviet armies back then much less prepared, but the Germans had effective air supremacy (and at Kharkov especially, artillery supremacy). Neither was true at Kursk, and nothing Manstein, Kluge and the rest did on the ground could have had affected the outcome in the air, where they lost air superiority a week before Prokhorovka. Attempting to destroy dug-in Soviet troops which can be partially resupplied from the air (and the longer they hold out, the more time there is for relief armies to strike your troops in the rear) is very, very different from dropping cluster bombs and artillery barrages at the formations caught out in the open in the Kharkov encirclement.
Admittedly, the Soviet advantage in the circa Kursk very well could have been conditional on Lend-Lease, which had delivered ~7,800 aircraft by then – Stalin himself, in a late 1942 letter to Roosevelt, was prepared to forego everything else, if only the fighter deliveries had continued. However, it is conceivable the lack of Allied fighters as a backstop would have forced the Stavka to abandon their love affair with cool-yet-strategically-ineffective Il-2 (the most-produced military plane ever, at ~36k) sometime in 1942, and redirect the same effort towards Yak and Lavochkin aircraft, which could have offset that. (It’s also conceivable all the cockpit/engine armor on those thousands of planes might have been better-used to create even a fraction as many APCs.) Either way, the fortifications and e.g. the anti-aircraft artillery which largely didn’t exist in 1941/1942 wouldn’t have disappeared from Kursk.
Accidentally posted the wrong link up above (to a pure slop website; while the enumerations might still be vaguely interesting for some, it’s not really capable of understanding the differences in technology and the rest). This is the podcast I meant.
https://shows.acast.com/history-undone/episodes/what-if-germany-won-the-battle-of-kursk-d-day-would-not-happ
Interestingly, Equestria At War did have a little bit of controversy over its depiction of southern Equestria during the Equestrian Civil War, given it was very clearly modeled after the Confederacy with the indigenous American coded Bison as their primary target for enslavement. I understand they completely overhauled the civil war content a few years ago so this is no longer the case, and it seems like they’ve been making a real effort with more recent additions to not just create lazy analogues of real historical regimes which I think is generally less fraught.
The Soviet Union in this playthrough
The Facists didn’t lose because their armies were insufficient, they lost because they kept on starting wars until they lost. If we don’t start wars we don’t have to lose.
The Chinese Civil War is so popular to play becuase it has such a clear endgame: Survive, and Unite China.
Also it’s a non-major with content. People here vastly over complicate the reasons people choose what to play. Germany is worse and I couldn’t make myself play it, but I’ve played plenty of historical villains with no problem. I don’t play timurids because I believe it’s moral, but because I think it’s interesting. I can see accepting Nazi germany for the same reason, on a base level (and the losers are inherently more interesting to play than the immediate winners).
So, how can we make a HOI5 that is both historically accurate and still balanced?
First, I would penalize German production and manpower due to the failure of Fascist economics.
Second, use the political system to allow Germany to become less fascist. When you trigger Operation Valkyrie you get a splash screen that says:
“Congratulations. You have purged the National Socialist Worker’s Party” and lists the benefits – more manpower, better economy, smaller garrisons in occupied territory, the chance that parts of the Soviet Union will switch sides, etc.
Historically the best way to improve Germany’s war fighting ability is to make them less fascist.
Funnily enough that’s kinda what you do get if you go the various alternate history paths. (IIRC the operation Valkyrie plot is in there somewhere but it’s of the “you’ll never see it” variety of content) generally you trade various early game bonuses for ultimately stronger ones that come online a bit later.
Basically you kick out Hitler so you can conquer the world better than he did. Ironic.
“So, how can we make a HOI5 that is both historically accurate and still balanced?”
Why make it balanced? I think a better option would be to have the country you select be the thing that determines difficulty. Pick the USA and you are playing on easy mode; pick Germany and you are playing on hard; pick Belgium and you are playing Nightmare Mode.
I guess one must be quite Offline to write something like this. Otherwise, it’s kinda hard to spend any time whatsoever around either Ukraine or Palestine partisans online (referring to both those people themselves but also their supporters from other states) and not to notice how their respective sentiments are near-ubiquitously “It’s not Putin, it’s Russia(ns)” and “It’s not Netanyahu, it’s Israel(is)”. (Just look at the online reaction to the recent Israeli election, for one).
So, even as a general principle, the notion it would have been any different during the actual WWII is remarkably blinkered. What pushes it into a realm of wild fantasy is that one of the most important coup plotters, Henning von Tresckow, had ordered this literally three weeks before Valkyrie.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heuaktion
There were a surprising (as in non zero) number of SS troops from Soviet areas, although those actually from Soviet territory were dwarfed by the anti Nazi resistance. There were also a significant number of unaligned partisans who fought against both sides.
The issue isn’t that it’s categorically impossible for a rebellion inside to soviets, or a broad coalition of the Eastern European states to aid a theoretical Germany.
It’s just that by Valkyrie that ship was sunk, buried, exhumed, burnt, then the ashes scattered. If the Soviet army had been thanos snapped the resistance from Soviet and Yugoslavian partisans alone would have been an army of over a million compared to ten thousand or so remaining collaborators.
In order to set this up Germany needs to enter the war as a different state with different objectives. Go back to 1920 and a German alliance of anti Soviet states seems reasonably likely, even Poland had decent relations with Germany immediately post war. Go to 1930 and some bridges are burnt, but the situation is not unsalvageable. But by 1936 the Nazis are taking Germany down precisely one path, and by 1939 the idea Germany could be a reliable anti Soviet nucleus was on life support; only the most delusional tried, after the partition.
I would also caution against reading “it’s not Bibi it’s Israel” or “it’s not Putin it’s Russia” as being irrational. Russia and Israel do have collective responsibility for their actions as states. In Russia this is limited to the oligarchs, mostly, who are the state, but in Israel they do vote and their policies is just so fucked that both Bibis party, the main opposition, Bibis coalition members, most of the minor coalition members, and a few interest group outsider parties all support forever war.
Only the Arab list, the Democrats, and a few minor parties actually oppose the war, and they are firmly a minority. They made ground, but might still get completely frozen out of government.
So people are generally right to collectively blame all Israel for it’s actions, its violent acrs really do represent the people. The disagreements are on corruption and grift, but there’s no systemic change here.
In the spirit of unmitigated pedantry, the following statement is incorrect:
The Soviet Union plus the two Chinas are 24%, beating Germany’s 22% by about the amount of players that choose ::checks notes:: the UK??
Indeed, and if you try to resolve it by combining the two Chinas, you make the problem worse.
Part of the reason I suspect the UK isn’t played very much is that it’s just kind of finicky. The UK isn’t *weak* but you have to deal with a bunch of stuff all over the world, and a bunch of rather finicky systems (including the dreaded navy, that many HOI4 players avoid if they can) They’re also unusually “locked in”, in that since the british empire is huge and just about everyone interacts with it they often can’t really chose thier own path very effectively (something even eg. the US can do) they’re often stuck reacting rather than acting.
Which has its own charm, but compared to something like China (who has to deal with both japan and the other china(s) but still is a relatively limited position) or Germany (who while it has a bunch of complicated issue is to some extend able to pick and choose its battles, since it’s the one that starts them) it’s a lot finicker, even if not harder.
I’m missing something here.
All right, military production and rationing economically bad. Got it.
Waitaminute. Military production and rationing is economically… good?
Why was military spending in the UK “fundamentally unproductive” but in the US it was “massive economic stimulus?”
Why did rationing in the US lead to “ending the war with money in their pockets because there had been money to be made during the war but nothing to spend it on,” but the rationing in the UK (which went on for longer) didn’t, and “the economy struggled to recover?”
There’s a distinction you’re trying to draw here, but I’m unable to tease it out.
Maybe Brett has his own perspective here, but my understanding of the Great Depression is that it was a demand-side problem; the crisis that proved Keynes right. Nothing was “wrong” with US production capability, but public society got in a loop of – “the stock market crashed” -> “the economy is bad” -> “I should save” -> “nobody is buying” -> “cut jobs” -> “the economy is bad” -> even less buying and even more contraction. The Keynesian answer was for government to step in an boost aggregate demand, which the war did, even if the product being purchased was worthless shells and explosives.
It’s the same argument people make today when they say that reckless debt-laden consumers are vital to the economy, and perhaps Vicky simulates that mechanism too in some way. I have no idea what the UK situation was, but to argue that this worked differently there, I would start by observing that there are also supply-side recessions. If you are the world’s leading industrial economy producing 10x what you consume, maybe you need to loosen up and let Keynes into your heart; whereas if you are actually producing less than you consume, a Keynesian approach might be just adding gasoline to a fire.
We also have to remember two things.
One is that the United States engaged in Lend Lease before they entered into WW2 proper, which did create domestic production as the USA was exporting weaponry and supplies where it was needed. The USA was also in the best middle ground compared to the other big two as the USSR had a lot of resources but little industry to use them while Great Britain was an industrial hub with limited domestic supply.
The other was that by this point the British Empire as a whole was a huge drag in expenditure to keep around (something that France was also struggling with), which made recovery for Great Britain harder as a whole.
Yup. Put another way it became more profitable to save money than it was to invest it, so everyone not actively starving hoarded currency. The starving sold everything for sustenance.
The only way out without government intervention is for everyone to starve such that they were bought up by money hoarders once the economy was dead.
The solution was to create more money then distribute it to the poor so that money lost value relative to investment and money hoarders lost relative wealth share.
Note that investment isn’t just stocks, but also stuff like buying a tractor, opening a store, wiring a home with electric heating, all the little things people do to increase efficiency. Stocks are just the main manifestation of this in finance.
Going to be honest; I think it’s the usual mental skip for Americans. Don’t admit that you absorbed all the money out of Allied Europe, and only started treating relations between them and yourself as allies when they’re on the verge of bankruptcy.
America got all the money to build piles of factories, and still have the factory at the end, which the civilian industrialists can then turn around and use to make product.
And refusing to forgive any loans (or any percentage thereof, or other easement), which is also the usual hypocrisy/irony for the USA, seeing how they started.
If I had to guess, I think what’s happening is that America’s problem was monetary, so pumping lots and lots of money into the economy helped. Britain’s problem was a fundamental lack of resources broadly construed, so more money wasn’t particularly helpful and instead the war drained their actual resources.
Same government action but different circumstances.
The USA military buildup really started in the 1930s with warships, and then boosted again for the first two years of WW2 when the USA was supplying Britain but not fighting. Military items like shells and tanks and battleships don’t have a civilian use, but they do require lots of steel and electricity and other dual-purpose resources, so the government is investing in industrial infrastructure. And the civilians who make the military items get paid which they’ll spend on food and consumer goods. WW2 was not an existential struggle for the USA, so while the civilian side of the economy grew slowly or not at all during WW2, eg some rationing, it didn’t go backwards and was ready to expand at the end.
Britain also started building in the 1930s, but from a much smaller population base (although the resources of the Empire helped) and started fighting earlier. And it was an existential struggle, so manufacture of civilian goods was replaced by military manufacturing, not augmented. And the civilian infrastructure was regularly being bombed as well, so had to be rebuilt at the end of WW2. Rationing in Britain during WW2 wasn’t preventing overspend on specific items, it was introduced because otherwise huge numbers of British children and adults would be suffering from rickets, scurvy, and the like. Britain (and most of Europe) got shattered by WW2 and had to spend massively to get back to prewar levels.
So Brifaun was in a real supply shock during and after the war, and Kenysian economics does not work very well when prices rise but production falls. The underlying assumption of spending is that more production is possible on the whole, but when there are not enough inputs that’s no longer true. During the war this showed up as stop gaps on production and lower rations. After the war this manifested in empty shelves and idle factories.
Britain slowly resolved this situation with massive imports and loans from America, but was left with debt. The solution was to inflate prices by spending money to increase production and delreciate debt, which worked, but this only translated into modest productivity increases after a point; you can only employ everyone who is looking for work and only buy all the raw mineral and agricultural goods you need.
Basically, there are limits. Kenysian spending might get another two percent gdp growth for the first 1% inflation, but the next 1% inflation might only increase growth by 1%, next 1% by 0.5%, etc.
Plus after a certain point the population writ large start changing behaviors, like demanding inflation pegged wages which breaks Kenyes formulas.
This, plus imperfect information, led to a fundementally sound but practically confused recovery. Britain inflated currency, depreciating it’s debts and triggering growth, but also experienced periods of rapid hyperinflation that needed a slowdown and deflation to fix, reducing worker and consumer confidence. Workers would strike as their wages were outpaced by inflation, necessitating wage increases that increased inflation. Meanwhile bond holders and the unemployable were the bag holders; if you were on retirement with a fixed income a cumulative inflation rate of 120% between 1945 and 1960 meant you went from tentatively comfortable to destitute.
This problem was famously called the stop go economy under the conservatives, but the earlier labour government had basically the same issue. High spending, growth, inflation, Go! Outspent production, hyperinflation, Stop! Deflation, recession, calming, but now you have debt repayments, Go!
Repeat.
It didn’t help matters that Britain insisted on maintaining its empire and spent aggressively on defense during this period.
This struggle between welfare, defense, inflation, and debt is what Britain could not rationally deal with with and led to significant turmoil. America had to deal with precisely zero of that, so had no issues.
Of course this all basically blew up in everyone’s face during the oil shock of the 70’s and the Thatcherite monetarist alternative was to fuck over workers so hard it can be felt in Britain’s bones, but Kenysian economics struggled with the weight of the debt cycle. It was winning, but it was hard going and resulted in strife.
Britains only real option to avoid this would have been to default on it’s war debt to the USA, but the USA had every possible ounce of leverage in this relationship. A trade freeze would have crippled Britain’s wounded economy, and even a brief cut of military aid would have instantly doomed Britain’s already quite doomed empire.
The limiting factor for Britain was foreign exchange. Its domestic economy was an industrial/financial core within a web of trade dependencies. Its main export industries (coal and textiles along with industrial goods) were being squeezed out by competition from the US, reviving Europe and then Japan. The investment needed was in competition with the attractions of financial returns from overseas. Growth demanded imports, which required exports. Any mismatch led to a foreign exchange crisis.
To be clear a lot of economies have foreign exchange based limitations, even the US had significant temporary or permanent dependencies post WW2 in key areas like rubber, it just wasn’t also saddled with such an insurmountable degree of debt that the only conceivable way to pay it back was a 400% inflation of the currency supply in addition to doubling of the real economy.
For example, compare Britain and Japan. Basically identical situations with import export limited economies, but Japan was allowed to default on it’s war bonds and avoiding crippling reparations by abandoning a measure of its military sovereignty and all its colonial claims.
And both faced quite similar shocks, but the Japanese economy basically responded like Britain did in it’s best day because it didn’t have the spectre of public debt or 7% gdp defense spending. When the oil shock nearly knocked Britain out it merely rocked Japan, despite the incredible reliance of Japan on middle eastern oil.
It wasn’t a choice Japan made willingly, but Japan had a better post war era despite being more damaged because of it.
At this point, I believe that you cannot have a Hearts of Iron that’s more aware of the implications of the state endgoals and beliefs by focusing solely on World War Two.
There’s just too much that must matter for the player to have an informed idea of what truly happened in that timeframe that goes beyond the scope of just World War Two. De Gaulle once referred to the period between the World Wars as the Second Thirty Years War, and while that’s not completely accurate, it does give a picture of how much of what happened between 1939 and 1945 depended on everything that happened from 1914 onwards.
Now, I previously said that the scope of a potential Hearts of Iron V that was more responsible would be one that covered the full Twentieth Century, and while I still stand on the idea, I think the focus on a game like that should be away from the operations (though it can inherit a more refined system) and instead focus on ideology and beliefs as the core pillar of design.
One of the things that defines the Twentieth Century is that it was an era of clashes of ideologies: from the Victorian/Edwardian style monarchism, the US-promoted liberal democracy, the fascist reactionary movements, the rise of communism along with its various variants across the globe and, why not say it? The rise of Islamism as rejection of both Soviet communism, Usonian liberalism and the legacy of the New Imperialism era.
“Imperial Japan’s aims were almost entirely for resource-extraction-overlordship, with very little colonial settlement.”
I thought the Japanese did intent to resettle Manchuria with Japanese settlers?
There were some attempts at settling japanese but these were often… How to put it, specialists? Like they’d bring in japanese specialists to work in the resource extraction operations (and intended to stay there forever) but there AFAIk was neer really n intention to make the area “japanese”.
I thought most of Japanese settlers were farmers?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_settlers_in_Manchuria
Less ambiguous would be the settler colonization of Hokkaido and Okinawa, which were settler colonized to the extent that they are just considered Japanese today.
In the 1970s, I read Liddell-Hart’s history of WW2, and I recall that he opined that the UK would have done better if it had not joined the war. The argument being that the war was costly and served to quicken the independence of British colonies.
Does HoI allow the UK to make this strategic choice? I’ve not played the game.
I’ve no idea whether this strategy would have worked out as Liddell-Hart suggested. And of course, there is also the question of the implications this strategy would have had for the Axis-occupied countries.
“Does HoI allow the UK to make this strategic choice? I’ve not played the game.”
Sorta. As the allies you can just decide not to joint the war. (don’t ally France, don’t guarantee Poland, etc.) *Eventually* this will lead to someone declaring war (IIRC, the japanese will do it first if they’re on historical)
There are also outright alternate history paths (one that basically has you try to more aggressively join the war early, as well as the fascist and monarchist branches that ends with you in various different configurations (either teaming up with Germany, or Italy, IIRC)
There’s also a branch were you simply decide to decolonize, relatively quickly granting indepenence to all your colonies (known as the “lag path”, because all these newly independent states start doing focuses and building armies etc. quickly brings the gmae down to a crawl)
From the whole series, it feels like a fundamental part of the problem is precisely that HoI is so narrowly focused on smashing armies together in operations. The economic balance underlying the war is just too one sided, there was no way for the Axis to reasonably win by lining up in a modern total industrial war and bulldozing their way through the Allies. But because that’s how HoI basically works, it has to put a finger on the scale in ways that basically all line up with the “pro-fascist” angles.
Something with a much deeper political model (on both the national and international levels) could be able to instead show some of why Britain and France aren’t doing mass rearmament as early as Germany does, why France is so brittle in 1940, etc. And looking forward, that would also let it show some of the more plausible ways that Germany might have been able to beat Britain, or Japan might have been able to beat the USA: not simply by smashing them in war, but by combining key successes on the battlefield with existing fault-lines in domestic politics such that continuing to fight was no longer politically feasible.
To be accurate, the Italian rail service made improvements to the rail beds and rolling stock between WW1 and WW2. It still featured single tunnels through its mountains. Thus, any delay could cause cascading delays.
Italian rail service was being interrupted by communist railway workers going on strike. The counter-strikes by the fascist railway workers significantly improved on-time performance. If the communists hadn’t caused problems, the fascists wouldn’t have anything to celebrate.
Just a quick question in good faith: Do you think strikes are a valid tool in labor negotiations in general?
Why are you citing r/socialism and r/shitliberalssay as evidence HoI4’s community is right wing? I don’t know the former too well, though I suspect their definition of “rightist” includes liberals like you and me, but the latter are straight up tankies and I’m near certain would consider you to be a “rightist”, possibly even a fascist. Like, the post you linked to is literally mocking people for calling out North Korea for being an impoverished totalitarian shithole precisely because they’re a bunch of Juche loving tankies.
I think the answer to “why does HoI4 appeal to neo-Nazis more than other WW2-themed media” isn’t to be found in the game’s implicit validation of Nazi economic thinking or whatever – that’s reaching way too deep. I propose a simpler explanation:
HoI like all Paradox games is made for geeks. Normies can watch Band of Brothers or even Der Untergang, or play Call of Duty, but you have to be pretty geeky to enjoy figuring out the complexity of a Paradox game. Modern neo-Nazis – not the simple populist far right of “I hate brown people and woke liberals” which (unfortunately) has mass appeal, but the hard core who actually get off on the uniforms and symbols – are also very geeky and online, and thus overrepresented among the kind of people that will play a Paradox game in the first place. And of course they’ll flock to the one about WW2. There’s something deeply LARPy about extremist movements and especially fascism, that makes them more likely to appeal to geeks than to the average person.
It’s similar to the attraction of some fascists to Tolkien, which Bret has talked about elsewhere. A large part of the appeal of the fantasy and sci-fi genres is in the grandiose aesthetics, heroic quests, epic battles between mythical good and evil… which is also the appeal of fascist propaganda! Of course they’re going to draw partly the same crowd, however unfortunate we may find it.
We’re all geeks here so this may not be on everyone’s radar… we’re fish who don’t realise we’re in water.
Yeah, it attracts extremists of any kind, including tankies than this very article cited.
I remember when I stumbled upon the Stormfront forum in the past. They weirdly loved Skyrim as they think themselves as the Stormcloaks, the Empire is the EU, Elves/Thalmor are Jews/Israel…
Remarkably, not long after you wrote this comment, there had been an entire wave on X of describing the Star Wars prequels and their depiction of Anakin as the argument for why fascism is good.
https://archive.li/pvlRU
The…counterarguments (?) are so obvious (i.e. Anakin is notoriously a child murderer who destroys his family himself and is rendered a disfigured tool of the Emperor almost immediately – before renouncing it all at the end of his life) as to be barely worth reiterating, so the more interesting question is how and why this happened.
One persuasive argument I have seen is that a lot of such stories depict villains as always being at the top until they are undone by what amounts to a plot contrivance. That is, if you can somehow remove the Ring from Lord of the Rings but keep the rest of the set-up, the Wages of Destruction are totally and completely stacked in Sauron’s favour and he is going to win through that alone. If you go by the Star Wars movies alone, absolutely nothing forced Palpatine to go for “victory with a single confrontation” theory of warfare and to be personally present at the unfinished second Death Star. (It gets even stupider in the sequels, where the entire Rebellion/Resistance apparently consists of three ships at one point, and everyone else seemingly prefers a guy who blew up an entire star system to the alternative.)
Up until that contrivance, the very things which make the villains evil are also the things which allow them to quite easily prevail over “the corrupt Jedi” and the like. (Palpatine famously folding up the Old Republic “with a cheer”, a single secret Order and a bit of slaughter via Anakin.) Hence, one could very well decide that the “grown-up reading” of those stories is that behaving like those villains is in fact the way to achieve your goals (or to be part of the successful country/political movement), and because real life is not scripted, the contrivance which undid them probably won’t happen to you.
Here’s a version of that argument made as early as 2020. (I believe I am again restricted to one link per post, but you can easily paste any part of that quote into your search engine and find the article.)
Perhaps an even simpler way to look at it: heroes in fiction are just about always underdogs. Because they are underdogs, they generally cannot win without the hand of the author supplying something unlikely to rescue them. If you do not believe that there a friendly “author” who will in fact supply something that’s going to rescue you, then the way to win in real life is to be a villain.
So, from this POV, something like Hearts of Iron IV would in fact reinforce the notion that WWII from the POV of the Nazis and the Japanese military was quite rational and they were on track to win for the same reasons as the fictional villains, while the turning points like Stalingrad, Kursk or El Alamein* amount to “unfortunate narrative contrivances”, which the game encourages you to bypass. All as opposed to the very opposite, when the events generally kept contriving in the Axis’ favour for the first three years of the war, and the Axis going for war was an insane spit of the face of the odds which had eventually crushed them.
P.S. Ironically, this suggests the most effective way at breaking down the fascist mindset might be via stories with Nazi protagonists as the narrative’s underdogs who use horses, bolt-action rifles and lack winter clothing, and thus get crushed through the Allies’ superior technology. If the fascist-inclined identify with strength and power, portraying Allies as “the villains” with strength and raw power is ironically the way to make the actual fascism unappealing. Of course, there’s still the challenge of balancing it out with insurgency stories like The Battle of Algiers (historic) or Andor (fictional) to also avoid the embrace of both “bombing to win” and the urge to turn domestic power towards the state’s opponents.
*Or even Dunkirk – I saw someone earnestly argue the other week that losing the evacuation would have ended the war for the British and, by extension, eventually won it for the Axis…which is really not in line with either the actual amount of forces or the fact about 2/3rds as many troops got evacuated from all the other French ports at around the same time.
Well, the actual counterexample to the point via Star wars is that Lucas’s message wasn’t merely that the Empire lost because of love and faith and cosmic coincidence, but if one looks at his moral philosophy that the Empire was doomed to lose. Of course the point that the force was acting through Luke, and that Luke was merely a vessel for an inevitable defeat, is subtextual and therefore beyond most viewers. And also utterly undermined by the Emperor being actually a nigh immortal clone surfing ghost.
A point people can better understand is that, in Star Wars, the rebellion, not Luke, physically wins. Everything on the second death star actually doesn’t matter, it was Han, Leia, and Joe Rebel (Wedge Antilles, Lando, the Ewoks, the unnamed troopers) who disabled the shield and defeated the Empire. Luke’s victory, while vital to the moral and spiritual defeat of the Empire and soul of Anakin, was physically unimportant. The death star still explodes with the Emperor on board.
This Rebellion is a statement that the consequences of Tyranny will always, eventually, come due. Not from coincidence but by the will of the people to be better. If this is beyond your ability to read you’re legitimately just stupid. Or a sociopath.
HOI 4 has a problem with both providing the Axis the means of conquest and not providing the means by which their conquest would inevitably dissolve. Politics are a joke, economics basically doesn’t exist, popular resistance is a distraction. Mods can’t fix this by depicting a world where the Axis loses once not under player control, outside the games timeframe, because the games systems are at fault. Even if they could the base game would still be what it is.
If you want to make a game that depicts WW2 responsibly playing the Axis should feel like, well, how Hitler felt. Like the walls are closing in and no victory is possible, like every operation, even if correct, can’t win, like every action causes a dozen unsolvable problems that you cannot overcome, as your support shrivels. Until you are, at last, in the bunker.
Alone.
Playing the axis should be a game about despair, and inevitably, and isolation.
I would say it’s not so much that the point is “too subtextual” for most viewers, but that many of them just do not see it as profound or particularly relevant to the real world because it’s undermined by a lot more than just the Emperor’s “clone surfing” (which just hasn’t been a thing for most people’s frame of reference – first confined to EU stories only consumed by a small fraction of the films’ viewers*, then finally rearing its ugly head in a film most people want to disown).
For one, there’s basically the same issue that crops up in so many religious(-inflected) stories: why did it have to happen at that point specifically? If the Force was always going to act to destroy the Empire, why did it even have to allow it to arise in the first place? Why did it have to first “rebalance” itself via a mass slaughter of children? And why did it need to allow for the millions on Alderaan (according to Obi-Wan in the film; though I heard later canon placed the death toll at two billion) vaporized before guiding Luke so that he could save a tiny fraction of either number? Whatever idealistic Watsonian reasons one can provide, they are unlikely to stand up to the cynical Doylist reading of “Luke is the audience surrogate going through Campbell’s Hero’s Journey, as Lucas had himself said, so the story unfolds according to his timepiece, not anyone else’s, and the Force only cares to intervene on his behalf.”
Then, there’s what I’ve said already. “the death star still explodes with the Emperor on board” – but based on where the fifth film ends and the sixth begins, the Emperor did not even need to build the second Death Star – let alone to be physically present on it! “The will of the people to be better” can seemingly be thwarted by an ounce of caution. You might argue that this is a sociopathic/psychopathic reading – but even if we accept this argument, the prevalence of psychopathy in the general population is generally estimated at between 1.2% to 4.5% (and the variation is primarily down to the strictness of diagnostic criteria; i.e. the clinical vs. subclinical difference.) That’s not insignificant (compare it to e.g. prevalence estimates for sexual/gender minorities) even before we account that these traits are (in)famously associated with criminality…or with leadership roles.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34421717/
In fact, if you refer to the Politico article where I got that quote about the Death Star and Captain Bligh, it rounds off by examining how Trump simultaneously considers Citizen Kane his favourite film – and believes that Kane went wrong because he simply “should have gone with a different woman”, as opposed to, you know, the fundamental personal flaw of his pursuit of unrestricted power to compensate for childhood trauma. In other words, the same mindset as reading Star Wars as coming down to tactical errors of the Emperor. You might mock it all you like – but it clearly exists, and one’s position in opposing it would become stronger if there aren’t, in fact, obvious and totally avoidable tactical errors.
Further; while you are right that it’s Han, Leia, and Joe Rebel…who disabled the shield and defeated the Empire – this leaves unsaid that they could do so because in the text (the Return of the Jedi), the Stormtroopers on Endor are puzzlingly soft for a fascist-coded army guarding a genocidal weapon and repeatedly (!) allow Han and co. to mock-surrender – only for some other rebel squad to emerge from offscreen and hold them at gunpoint. People have frequently mocked and/or despaired at remarks from a number of high-profile figures about “suicidal empathy”, and I have done the same. On further reflection, though, I think we cannot quite separate it from this context – that the instrumental reading of a surprisingly large fraction of the contemporary pop culture, which forms the collective headspace of so many people, is that the villains were undone by being too soft. Be it the Stormtroopers giving quarter in the most pivotal battle of their lives, or all the stories where a villain/antagonist spares (one of) the defeated opponents at the last minute, only for them to cause so many problems later. So many revenge action stories, from Kill Bill to The Last of Us Part II, can be interpreted as telling the viewer that Bill, Abbie, etc. screwed up by showing empathy to someone who would never reciprocate it (due to their own actions immediately prior to that, tbf) – and that would be wholly consistent with the text! (Never mind works like that one comparatively recent speculative fiction novel about a future civil war in America, which ends with untold millions dying in an engineered pandemic because one guard’s misplaced empathy stopped him from doing his duty.)
Remarkably, there are already a number of games which explicitly place the player in an unwinnable position, and the challenge is about how long you can last. Now, usually, they still try to make it fun in one way or the other (i.e. I’m thinking of Crimsonland, frequently considered the forerunner to Vampire Survivors and everything which followed it, where you cannot outfight the swarm of bugs, but the process isn’t despair per se), but I think there are still exceptions. I.e. I have heard the Belorussian This is the Police 2 being described as “a trapped beast simulator”. From what I recall, the police commissioner the player controls had been undone by his corruption and explicit collaboration with criminals at the end of the first game (to be fair, you apparently get assassinated about halfway through the story if you try to play it completely clean) and flees to a small town P.D. where he attempts to assume a new identity – but any choice made after that only delays the inevitable. There are definitely other examples (besides Terra Invicta you have cited below), but I cannot think of any at the moment.
P.S. Come to think of it, “showing why the bad guys lose via mechanics” kinda was present in Star Wars: Battlefront II (the 2005, at least; not sure about the EA versions). That is, I recall that in singleplayer, by far the two hardest maps were Endor as the Empire…and playing the “Dark Side” in the “Cantina” mode of Mos Eisley (which had a team of all the playable heroes, from Luke and Leia to Mace Windu and the Twilek Jedi, pit vs. villains like the Emperor, Grievous and the Fetts). For the former, it was because the indefinite NPC Ewoks were surprisingly useful, as they could capture spawn points just the same as any of the (finite) troops on either side, quickly leaving all the NPC stormtroopers outnumbered as the rebels spawned in at a much greater rate. In the latter, it’s because Leia in particular could just render all the heroes around her invulnerable (a play on the notorious “Stormtroopers can’t aim” plot armour), while the villains’ moves synergized pretty badly.
The thing is, though, it didn’t exactly feel like a logical and inevitable result at the time, because so many other parts of the game were so obviously janky that it was easy to write these moments off as the AI being too dumb to protect spawns/target Ewoks and the game not balancing powers properly. (I.e. AoE attacks like the Emperor’s lighting or the Fetts’ flamethrowers were remarkably useless, since the game didn’t simulate the pain interfering with attacks at all. Jedi/Sith characters in general were frequently much less deadly on the battlefield than the properly upgraded Snipers, Engineers (who could just self-heal with supply packs, AFAIR) or Anti-Armor troops with missile launchers.) Our host has routinely remarked on the way verisimilitude lends credence to wrong or outright dangerous ideas; the necessary corollary is that the lack of it rapidly undermines a depiction of otherwise good ideas.
*Though hilariously, perhaps the very first example of those “Anakin shows why fascism is good” posts claimed that the Gen Z was radicalized by Revenge of the Sith novelization specifically. It’s especially funny because the novelization is apparently much, much more explicit in depicting how Anakin’s choices screwed everything up even in his own life than the film (i.e. it ends on a gruesome first-person depiction of that surgery), so if anything, it betrays even the OOP most likely hasn’t actually read it.
**As in, to give but one example, the Death Star was the only map in the game where the NPC troops from either side could crouch down behind cover, as there were specific triggers for them behind a handful of crates there – it was beyond their reckoning everywhere else. The NPC troops with mines (Anti-Tank) or drone turrets (Snipers) virtually never deployed them. The map of the Hutt’s palace had a small side tunnel the NPCs just wouldn’t enter. The map of the clone vat facilities on Kamino allowed you to rack up insane K/O ratios by blowing up clones/droids running up/down narrow walkways with a single mine/missile and/or by headshotting them when they prioritized climbing into open-top turrets over doing literally anything else.
Even funnier, the otherwise-tough “Officer” classes of either of the four factions (I believe you literally couldn’t play them or the “elite” troops (Bothan Spies, Droidekas and the jetpack-equipped clones/stormtroopers) from the get-go, and had to rack up some amount of score during the match) kept freezing up right in front of you to deploy and control recon droids, exposing them to an easy headshots. (When by far the most logical approach under the game’s mechanics is to camp at a spawn point in front of the supply droid which would instantly replenish the drone once destroyed. The only issue is that the officers are also the ones buffing allies, which they cannot do while controlling droids.) To add insult to the injury, the drones actually were really deadly when controlled by the AI (fast, hard to aim at and about the same firepower as most combatants) – but nearly useless in your hands, because the AI aimed at them about as well as usual. (The same factor rendered the aforementioned jetpack elites largely useless, as they simply became a more visible target.)
As an aside your comment reminded my of another game I’m playing, terra incivta.
Terra incivta is a modern day geopolitical space game where you fight an alien invasion. The factions are idealogical cabals whose goals are varied. The servants want to support the aliens, the protectorate appease them, the academy cooperate with them, the resistance expel them, exodus escape them, humanity first destroy them, and the initiative wants to exploit them.
Each faction has quirks and an easier or harder game. They don’t really line up on left to right idealogical goals, but instead are defined by being pro or anti alien, and cynical or idealistic. The servants are pro alien and idealistic, humanity first is anti alien and cynical, exodus is anti alien and idealistic, etc. but all can fundementally win, and the idealistic factions often fight harder but win bigger in terms of goals
…Except the protectorate, which are pro alien and cynical. Spoilers.
Oh, the protectorate can get a victory screen, but they can’t win. Their entire goal is to achieve a conditional peace via appeasement, but they rapidly run into a problem where their desire to avoid opposing the aliens taking over earth means they have no leverage to argue for conditions to their peace; the better the protectorate does the more unconditional the peace is.
They also have nearly the hardest game. Practically any game the protectorate wins the servants could have won decades earlier. The aliens barely help you but give the servants loads of resources, every other faction fucking hates you, the aliens and servants will often accidentally trip you up, a winning game often resembles a war with every faction at once except you have strict rules of engagement because if you piss off the aliens too much they’ll hammer you.
Eventually you manage to win, blow up all human opposition, and plunge the world into a slave state ruled by aliens with humanity as battle thralls. Yay.
Then you play the servants. They likewise want the aliens to win, but have a to an actual idealogical goal, the idea that the aliens are better at running earth but need humans to help rebuild a shared culture.
And they have the balls to reject the alien ultimatum, as being bad for the aliens culturally, and push for a much more equal relationship.
Their game is, again, much easier.
The protectorate struggles to lose while the servants cruise to a better version of the protectorate goals.
That’s effective propoganda against the protectorate; they look stupid, weak, and evil. It’s a harder game with no pay off. You achieved failure.
The happiest ending is the academy, who are only slightly pro alien,idealistic scientists, and want true peace. Their campaign is a Herculean struggle that involves consolidating earth almost completely, overcoming many unique challenges, resolving all major geopolitical problems in the process, then punching the aliens teeth in until they agree to talk to you with respect. It’s idealistic and metal as hell. Slightly less idealistic endings are easier, but the academy is glorious.
That’s how you write and design a game that pushes a conclusion.
Hey, I actually own Terra Invicta! Still never played it, though, because I always assumed strategy games like this would take up way too much of my time at present.
In fact, I always figured that I would do the first run as the most pro-alien faction (apparently the Servants, who as you note, get the most of their support) – because one of the few things I picked up about the game is that fighting the aliens (particularly their fleets) is very hard, and so by extension, a faction which logically shouldn’t have to worry about that at all ought to be the simplest, and thus the fastest way to ease into the game. I was also confused why the factions in the trailers seemed to sorta-duplicate – but you explaining it as idealism vs. realism does make a lot of sense. (Although it is remarkable that after digging around on the wiki, idealism apparently also means that you get to justify atrocities far more easily – apparently, the Servants get to frame their atrocities as inevitable outcomes of total war, but the Protectorate does not.)
I’ll add that I generally find the usual applications of the “Appeasement” framing conceptually flawed, since it is virtually always applied one way – i.e. ‘We [the speaker’s side] are appeasing them, and That’s Bad’. I don’t think I have ever seen it analyzed in reverse – i.e. “have others been trying to appease us”? By and large, actions which are seen as appeasement when “we” do it, are just taken as a given when they are done “to us”. Then again, I suppose appeasement frequently not even being recognized, let alone appreciated, would highlight yet another reason why it (generally) does not work.
P.S. I must say, I am stunned that the game not only includes climate change (after all, Civilizations have had it for a while, AFAIR), but that its representation includes all three main greenhouse gases + the aerosols, begins with real-world values for all of them + sea level rise and goes as far as to actually include the CO2 ppm threshold at which it is generally believed it’ll begin to negatively affect cognition across the board!
https://wiki.hoodedhorse.com/Terra_Invicta/Climate_Change
It is still not perfect (i.e. the sea level rise events seem very simplified as virtually all of the glaciers in question are believed to take centuries to collapse even with high warming, “Arctic Methane Eruptions” most likely won’t actually happen, “Wet Bulb events” probably require more than 1.5C globally and definitely wouldn’t happen in “random” countries – and conversely, some long-term sea level rise is locked in even if temperature goes “back to zero” (preindustrial), while I’m pretty sure their assumptions of sci-fi technology also make stopping/reversing emissions much easier than it’s actually likely to be), but it’s definitely increased the standing of the game in my estimation by a lot.
P.P.S. For all the immense work Terra Invicta appears to do, I still long for a game which treats the (hostile) first contact scenario from a framing where even that wouldn’t actually take precedence over the pre-existing politics. I.e. present-day nation-states are still in charge of just about everything that matters rather than being inherently manipulatable by transnational orgs, and the aliens’ primary play is divide-and-rule via the already existing geopolitical conflicts.
I.e. the aliens don’t deal with abstract factions but already existing national governments, and seek to identify least one nation which simultaneously has enough resources/power to be useful to them, yet is also in a sufficiently troubled position it would accept becoming increasingly dependent on their technology without worrying too much how they’ll eventually have to fight whoever the aliens tell them to. Others then have to react to this rapid alteration of the balance of power – even as their own politics remain in the way.
The atrocity scaling had a few other influences; at least in some starts certain factions get hard bonuses that influence atrocity impact. The academy always gets hammered, humanity first mitigates effects, and the servants get the inherent modifiers.
Part of Terra Invictas brilliance is it’s determination to take edge cases into account. For instance the artic is only passable to navies during northern summer, unless global warming has progressed far enough. Further aerasols increase when a region is nuked by a set amount, unless the target is a micro nation small enough that the exposed land is smaller. I’ve actually experienced this with alien landings in the Pacific during early builds, which caused the delightfully callous thought that “at least when I nuke Tahiti to rubble the environment will be fine”.
More gameplay relevant examples include that Titans thick atmosphere make it an ideal fortress in the outer solar system; lasers and kinetics get deflected or weakened.
Of course the game still has to simplify and ignore many things to be playable, and there was a long discussion on the forums about climate change and how to model it, with the conclusion being to modify the campaign settings (which you can do by default) to minimize how much investment factions can do and how fast technology progresses to slow the fixing of the climate if you wish. I know there are further mods, too.
I hesitate to recommend this, but Solar Nations 2 with mods is what you’re looking for, it’s just…deeply problematic in both exactly the HOI 4 way and many others. At its most basic its creator is at least partially into the far right replacement theory conspiracy in ways that show up extremely clearly in how the polycrisis is framed, but also the later start has such charms as the “gay alliance” on mars, which forcibly converts people to be gay and trans in a neo-woke neo-fascist dystopia that is just…oh so deeply ridiculous. And the maker has gone pretty deep into the anti woke meme space to defend the politics.
Still, it’s the closest to being what you want. It’s just rough.
@YARD,
The president has favorably likened himself to the vile Captain Bligh of Mutiny on the Bounty.
Minor point, but hasn’t subsequent historical writing (and the court inquiries at the time) mostly exonerated Bligh, at least by contemporary standards?
I mean, after Bligh survived the mutiny (he and his loyalists managed to sail an incredible 6,500 km distance in a small boat with few tools), he was eventually appointed the third Governor of New South Wales – only to be deposed within two years by a mutiny there. I think this says enough.
Either way, Trump almost certainly based his attitudes on the famous film depictions rather than written history. After all, consider this episode.
https://lacmaonfire.blogspot.com/2025/04/trumps-tariff-rosebud-is-at-academy.html
Well, it does say something about Bligh, just not what you might think it does.
Rum Rebellion – Wikipedia
Bligh’s problem was less that he was a tyrant of any kind and more that he wasn’t a good enough leader to overcome people’s tendencies towards venality.
I appreciate that “might think”, since I never in fact explicitly called him a tyrant or the like.
If anything, the fact he lived through two mutinies highlights otherwise; those who are really hated don’t get the grace of surviving them even once. Alternatively, if they die for some other reason earlier, they end up with songs like this devoted to them, much like this counterpart to Bligh further to the north.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moreton_Bay_(song)
Nevertheless, it seems like we are in agreement he shouldn’t have been in leadership positions in the first place, and I think it’s obvious that even following the most positive interpretation of his character (which requires one to downplay clearly risky actions like choosing to slash in half the rations of Bounty’s entire crew after someone stole his coconuts), associating oneself with him is a deeply strange behaviour for a world leader.
@YARD,
Yes, Donnie the Depraved really is sort of a caricature of the kind of person who bases their entire understanding of history from Hollywood movies. I just wanted to mildly stand up for the much-maligned Captain Bligh.
The next series of posts will be about the dangerous Monarchist ideas and racial implications of chess, and how it needs a robust economics/industrial/logistics/political (with MY preferred conclusions about politics of course) to avoid being…
FASCIST.
Ducks mad at idea people might not want to quack.
Patrick O’Brian did it. I think it was “Fortunes of War”; regardless, it’s when Aubrey and Maturin are captured and taken to America (War of 1812). Maturin is playing chess with an American surgeon and doing his spy thing with the French agent, and says he loves playing chess because it appeals to his liberal instincts, as no matter how the game ends a monarch must be made uncomfortable.
That said, monarchism doesn’t rely on specific theories of economics. It works best in agrarian societies, but can work in pretty much any economic system.
I’m curious if you expect positive feedback for this comment. Like, what’s your expected reaction?
Now that this series is over I can understand what happens in a game of Erika Chappell’s True Imperial Japan Experience.
“you would have to be a little daft not to recognize the bit of marketing work being done by a mod which overhauls basically the entire map calling itself Kaiserreich“
So just specifically about Kaiserreich, which has developed into kinda its own thing over time, but, hmmm…. How should I explain this.
The original creator (long since stepped down) of Kaiserreich goes under the handle of Sarmatia. He’s an actual historian (though his speciality is the history of paleontology IIRC) Kaiserreich (and its predecessor mod All the Russias) was, hmm… How to put it? It’s kinda taking the piss in a very british kind of way. It has since developed into a bunch of people basically taking the slightly tongue-in-cheek joke about alternate history mods and became the very thing it was making fun of. The important bit here is that there was already a kind of weird alternative history modding scene with various scenarios, and Kaiserreich was largely a mild joke at their expense. (with, in that particular british way, a good chunk of the joke being how po-faced and semi-serious it was)
For instance, in the original version of All the Russias (and Kaiserreich) the fascist candidate for russian leader is Pyotr Wrangel: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pyotr_Wrangel Not because Wrangel was a fascist, but simply because his picture made him look like a moustasche-twirling villain. This was not a self-conscious decision, “for the jokes”, so to speak. Similarily Syndicalism was chosen as the main “leftist” ideology of this timeline precisely because it’s a fairly niche and obscure thing largely represented by a few militant trade unions OTL.
As with many other things the mod was essentially taken over (after Sarmatia lost interest) by people who largely didn’t get the joke. Originally it was a (somewhat loving) piss-take at how unserious alternate history mods often are. A lot of people didn’t get the joke.
Also, Sarmy was promised a Kaiserreich mug at one point by the then current and never got it.
>This was not a self-conscious decision
Was, it was a self conscious decision.
Honestly, what made and makes Kaiserreich so successful as a Hearts of Iron mod is that it prophetically decided to full-heartedly embraced the meme politics that HoI4 has become so infamous for and which Dr. Devereaux so lambasted.
And because the dominant ideologies of the mod (monarchism, syndicalism, integralism, narodnik socialism etc.) are all obscure niche ideologies that were made irrelevant and buried by OTL historical developments it allows both players and developers to be “in on the joke” to a degree the vanilla game’s reliance on IRL historical outcomes never could (or even should, to be frank).
I do think one of the problems with HOI4 is that it’s a game about fighting World War II. And in that sense, if World war II doesen’t happen, or ends quickly, it’s not a very fun game. So World war II has to happen you can make some wacky alternate versions, but that’s *the game*. And it also has to be “fun” (IE: Challenging but not frustrating) to actually fight.
Usually these kinds of things are solved by sharply limiting the players agency. (“You’re in charge of putting divisions where they go, and actual politics is handled outside the game”) this can also help make playing the allies more fun since you can restrict what you’ve got access too (“Yes, if you fail this mission to take this italian city realistically they’d just bring in another division to take it but that’s not what the mission is about and if you fail you’ve failed”)
For a variety of reasons they’ve decided not to do that and that creates problems. (there are, actually, I think significant problems beyond this in the game, like the german Inner Circle mechanic is… Well, let’s just say problematic)
What’s wrong with the Inner Circle?
“You’re in charge of putting divisions where they go, and actual politics is handled outside the game”
The game is sort of doing it by the focus tree system. The politics of the game is intended to be railroaded rather than sandbox. Older games of the series just use popup events to drive the game.
And it didn’t solve the “clean Wehrmacht” problem. Even if you have a choice not to allow your troops to commit war crimes, basically you will still try to win a war for the Nazi.
It’s not just that you win a war for the Nazis, it’s that winning a war for the Nazis “wins” you the game (there is no real “win condition”, but it’s the closest you get to an actual “game won” screen in a Paradox game).
I know what leaving this disclaimer is going to sound like, but: I am not a Nazi or Nazi-adjacent person, but I do prefer to play a difficult game, and the main reason I don’t play most of the Allies is that it is too easy to do so! My games as Britain and the United States have resulted in crushing wins, much like in this AAR.
I have played France a few times, once to keep the Little Entente together and beat Germany with it (which I did), and once to give Napoleon VI a crack at Empire again (more difficult but doable). And when I do play Germany I like to take the monarchist tack to conquest because Nazi conquest is abhorrent to me.
I am just saying here that 22% of the userbase playing Germany is not all that hard for me to believe. The Allies won the war in RL. They are naturally going to be the easier path by default, and I feel like that’s at least part of why the majority of gamers are going with Germany.
There’s also the irony that making the game more historically accurate in the ways our host wants would make the game even easier, and thus more boring, for the Allies.
As I have already remarked last week, this is only really true if it is presumed the Western Allies wouldn’t have gone on to fight the USSR. Given that there’s a case to be made that only the Fall of France had prevented an attempt to bomb the nexus of Soviet oil industry in 1940, that assumption isn’t very plausible, and designing a game to generally steer the Allied player into such a conflict (unless immense effort is taken to push against it) hardly seems like an insurmountable challenge.
https://acoup.blog/2026/10/23/teaching-paradox-hearts-of-iron-iv-part-iva-the-fires-of-industry/#comment-113098
That is the appeal of alt history mods like Kaiserreich to me. I don’t need to do any mental backflips playing as syndicalist France or integralist Brazil or narodnik Russia because none of those ideologies were the historical causes of mass genocide and multiple millions of war dead.
A great series, but the author is far too kind to the western allies, and blind to the USA in particular. This blog is necessarily limited and I see why it cannot cover much outside the time frame of the game, but it is quite hypocritical for him to call out paradox for giving a misleading view of history when he himself does not mention relevant facts.
The axis are described as seeking racial empires and genocidal resettlement, but the western allies’ aims are merely described as “the status quo”. This is just an irresponsible way to frame things.
The ‘status quo’ in the 1930s was racial empires. Britain and France obviously conquered and enslaved their colonies, and the American project of genocide and resettlement had seized vast portions of that continent for the expansion of racially defined whiteness.
Fascism was a direct descendant of ideologies of imperialism and colonialism; it is a moral failure to pretend that the allies fought for some neutral status quo, or to ignore the crimes of that status quo simply because the atrocities that created it occurred before the war (rather than during it). In his narrow focus, the author fails to place fascism in its full context. The allies were accomplices of fascism before they were its targets, and defending their positions as rulers of brutal empires was as inextricable from their war aims as conquering such an empire was for the axis.
Well to be fair, Bret tried to say fascism did not work, not that imperialism and colonialism did not work, or else he had to criticize Victoria 3 too.
And yes, Bret is a liberal so naturally he thinks the western liberal world order is the best.
He has said on a few occasions that “empire” is the most common form of government. If by “worked” you mean created a society that was stable across multiple generations, empire absolutely worked! It’s worth remembering that Rome was invaded multiple times because Germanic peoples wanted to be part of the Empire and did not take “No” for an answer.
Colonialism also worked. It’s basically an extension of the concept of empire. Even the Founding Fathers were not (entirely, anyway, there were hardliners) opposed to remaining colonies, they just objected to the terms and conditions (see Franklen’s attempt to negotiate with Britain). The real problem with colonialism is that people got greedy. Bacon suggested that you wait 20 years before extracting any profit from a colony, because it takes that long to build up self-sufficiency and a surplus. People tend not to want to wait that long.
It is worth noting that the Allies were not entirely innocent in WWII. There were many (Ford, for example) that admired the Nazis, and I’ve read that the original German plan was mass deportation of Jews, only they couldn’t find anyone willing to take them. That said, the atrocities of the Axis powers were on such a scale that comparison really isn’t useful. It’s a tu coque argument where one side is on the bad end of normal and the other side is literal demons. Doesn’t mean we should ignore what the Allies did, just that we should be very careful in equating what the Allies did and the horrors the Axis powers perpetrated.
I am exactly arguing that we can compare the axis and the allied powers.
I am not arguing that the axis and allies should be weighed on a scale to calculate the most evil, nor am I making a mere “both bad” argument. The ends and means of the axis and allied powers were very similar in kind, if the not one and the same.
My point is closer to the one the author makes about bombing, the axis deployed terror bombing, but the allies were much ‘better’ at it. The axis sought to build empires, and discovered the allied powers had built empires with far more land, raw materials, or population than they could match.
To take an example:
The Japanese war aims were to subjugate an empire to provide resources, labor forces, and captive markets. In ‘contrast’, the British war aims were to preserve a status quo where they subjugated an empire, which was providing them resources, labor, and a captive market.
These are the very same thing.
That the USA had no need to seize ‘living space’ in 1936 is because genocide was already over. Their own ‘generalplan ost’ had already looted and murdered from the Atlantic to the Pacific, for no purpose other than the ideology of the white racial class.
For an case within the timespan of the game, he egregiously suggests that Germany might take the blame for the Bengal famine, as though dependence on the generosity of Britain for basic necessities was some neutral state of affairs and not the result of a deliberately brutal system of overlordship.
The “real problem” with colonialism is not greed. It is that colonization is completely and totally evil. Colonies mean murdering, they mean rape, they mean torture, they mean slavery, colonialism is the utter spiritual corruption that will happen when one man is given unchecked power to abuse another. It is the reduction of human life to extracting profits. It is ignoring that suffering because it happens far away from you, or to a people you are willing to think of as lesser.
The comparison with the axis powers is in fact ESSENTIAL. This dehumanization, this endorsement of the right for once race to exterminate another. Fascism is colonialism when it comes for Europe. It is precisely the same ideology, of classifying entire groups as subhuman, and it leads just as inevitably to cruelty and misery.
Allied atrocities cannot be separated from the war any more than the axis’ can. They are how the allies fought (with people and material from their colonies/the population and industry of the settler-colonies of the USA), they are they way the allies fought (starving millions in Iran in order to use the transport network for lend-lease), and they are why the allies fought (the preservation of their empire-ruling status).
A blog post series is not as influential as a video game, but it speaks with authority and will influence his readers. I maintain the author has failed to present fairly the Western Allies as they existed during WW2. And, in doing so, has propagated misunderstanding of the ideology that killed so many; before during and after that conflict.
The author urges us not to remain indifferent, urges us to not forget the horrors of the past, I agree. Yet he has written as if the status quo was a thing that just happened to be the case, and not the end result of atrocities against humanity on a scale exceeded only by the axis powers themselves, and no different in ideological cause.
Given that, despite having ample opportunity to actually commit genocide against the Native Americans, the United States did not do so, I’m gonna have to call nonsense on this one.
…we did though? The trail of tears itself is a genocide, it alone represents an attempt to exterminate a people, in whole or in part.
I haven’t read the above post except to skim that it might be nonsense, but the US committed genocide against the native Americans, that’s a thing that happened.
A probably more accurate statement is that the US committed several genocides against several native america groups, but it’s harder to argue for a general genocide against all native americans.
Virtually all native American groups in contact were displaced and massacred, this is one of the very few situations where nuance is more wrong than just saying there was a genocide against all of them; it is only a meaningful distinction in the hypothetical. Or Hawaii, but that acquisition is from a different process and era.
If your definition of genocide includes the Trail of Tears, you’ve defined it overbroadly.
Then the Armenian genocide didn’t happen. It shares all characteristics with the Trail of tears. Hell, the Holocaust becomes arguable; there are still Jews in Israel, after all, hell Hitler even deported a few, must just be a forced displacement!
If the trail of tears wasn’t a genocide genocide doesn’t exist. It’s an assault on the concept to exclude one country from judgement, and it’s an insult to that countries values.
You’re arguing the same thing neo Nazis argue, and if that’s your position those are your people, intellectually and morally. Not Americans.
“You’re arguing the same thing neo Nazis argue…”
Yup. Pretty much the counter-arguments to my argument can be summed up as “The Allies did some bad things so the Nazis weren’t really that bad.” As you say, this is the line of reasoning the NeoNazis use. It’s logically and morally indefensible, and it’s quite telling that as soon as someone says “The Nazis were bad and we shouldn’t pretend they’re not bad” the cockroaches come out of the woodwork going “Well actually you’re just as bad!”
@Terry: Yeah, no. If you look at the actual history and records, the Trail of Tears was not carried out with the intention of annihilating the people it was done to, while the Armenian genocide definitely was.
So, spare me the dramatics of your last paragraph.
@Terry: Now as to your arguments about how by my definitions the Holocaust becomes not a genocide because there are still Jews, that also doesn’t hold water. The only reason Hitler stopped killing people was because he was forced to stop by outside forces. For that matter, that was also the only reason the Turks stopped killing the Armenians.
Meanwhile, there was no outside force who could, or would, have stopped the United States from killing every last one of the Native Americans it could get its hands on if it had chosen to do so. Yet, it did not, and did not even try to.
Now, if you want to argue that the US brutally oppressed the Native Americans, sure, yeah, no question. Genocide, though? No.
@60guilders: It should be noted that the Nazi plan for eastern Europe was not to completely eliminate the Slavs, but to kill a part, enslave a part, then drive the remaining part out beyond the Ural mountains – which is not much different from what happened to the native Americans.
@guilders theatrics? You’re alone. It’s a fact. You can die in denial or change, but if you ever want a voice you have to abandon this ridiculous, disgraceful, unamerican bigotry.
If you want to blatantly, openly fucking lie about the trail of tears fine, but the record is abundantly clear. Jackson’s administration took an edict to use economic forces to encourage migration that could potentially be interpreted to merely be oppressive, and with indifference, outside the remit of the law, and with intention ordered the US military and diplomatic apparatus to enact it in a way that killed more than ten thousand people. This was done to remove them from American land.
You’re not the smartest, so let me break down why the Armenian genocide is relevant; Turkey didn’t invade Armenian enclaves in other states, like Russia. There was no attempt to exterminate literally every Armenian. Just every Armenian in Turkey. You can draw a similar parallel to the Greek Genocide, which involved the massacre of Greeks in Turkey but which didn’t involve a wholesale invasion of mainland greece.
If this represents a failure of means or ends is irrelevant, because again, this is what Armenian genocide deniers argue. Your argument, applied there, is reproduced word for word; there’s no proof of intent, they didn’t destroy them, nothing outside stopped them, etc.
The argument about a failure to enact genocide is hence madness. Not only does it ignore all context that limited Jackson, like that he barely had the authority to enact any of this and that he had to beg for a military, it rewrites the actual fucking Holocaust to remove the displacement aspect because it’s inconvenient to your narrative. America didn’t have the resources of Germany, obviously, it was a different century with much weaker military and state apparatus.
Further Jackson had to avoid being seen as an outright tyrant, and hence had to frame his genocide as being paternalistic. The intent didn’t change, just the rhetoric, but this influenced the methods. A genocide using sterilization is a genocide, a genocide using starvation is a genocide, a genocide using gas is a genocide, and a genocide using forced march is a genocide. But some take longer, and look “cleaner” to the foolish.
I don’t know what psychological neuroses makes you argue otherwise, but it’s a sickening and self debasing betrayed of American values to do so. And yes, your people are Holocaust deniers, neo Nazis and Turkish ultra nationalists, lunatics and idiots. Your rhetoric is identical and hence you have made yourself like them; pathetic.
@Terry: That was a lot of words to say “I don’t actually know what I’m talking about regarding the Trail of Tears or the Armenian genocide.”
Compare the numbers: The Trail of Tears resulted in the deaths of one-fifth of the people involved. To be clear: This was bad.
The Armenian death marches, on the other hand, resulted in the deaths of more than 80% of the people involved.
By itself this demonstrates a clear difference in intent between the two.
I’m very sorry that you can’t distinguish between degrees of wrongness, but throwing out thoughtstopping cliches isn’t going to change the actual facts on the ground.
I have no horse in this race but…
@Terry You’re committing Appeal To Consensus and No True Scotsman in one sentence, then proclaiming yourself more intelligent/opponent less intelligent/crazy which is both meaningless and a form of Ad Hominem. Your argument would do perfectly fine without these things.
That the host now quotes redditors is very fitting for what this blog is at real risk of becoming: an ideological bubble where dialectic is abandoned in favour of rhetoric, dissent is only over cosmetic details or different ways to phrase things and anyone that says something more different must be dogpiled with YOU ARE EVIL YOU ARE EVIL. The way you talk is on the way there, which is a shame since you do have a decent argument underneath.
@60guilders The details of what exactly USA did to Amerindians for what reasons and what it should be called don’t really change the argument you were originally replying to: that USA had already obtained its Lebensraum by WW2 through deaths and expulsions of previous inhabitants. Surely you won’t deny that many people died and the rest were expelled.
The exact timeline, degree of organisation or intent behind the actions USA took isn’t particularly relevant (and intent is hard to solidly argue either way).
@xellos thank you for your ignorance, it is useful to expose.
My argument in the first part is not an argument. I am not claiming I am right because Guilders is a stupid, lonely, petty, evil fuck who is intellectually identical to lunatics, im right because I am factually correct. My condemnation of him is not my argument against him.
In the same way I can condemn Hitler’s character by pointing out he was an egotistical, sexually frustrated near incestuous freak, but that’s not why he was bad at war. It is, however, why he was personally reprehensible. I feel no shame in expressing that opinion.
As for idealogical bubbles, I am perfectly fine with completely excising everyone like Guilders from society everywhere. There is no negative to becoming idealogically ruthless in our confemnation and suppression of people like him.
You’re appealing to a consequence I want. I want every single place I go to be completely and comprehensively free of people denying genocide. I want humanity to be an idealogical bubble where evil people are dogpilled. Why wouldn’t I?
Just because I fucking hate this neo nazi doesn’t mean I’m being irrational; falling on platitudes about fallacies like I’m violating some compact is absurd. Fuck him, he’s evil, evil, evil.
I didn’t say imperialism and colonialism not working either. Basically the idea is that western democracies were more successful than the nazi at creating racist, genocidal empires.
We are talking about economic goals here, not comparing who was the baddier guys in the war. Nazism is clearly an inhumane ideology. But the economic goals of the Axis and and western Allies are not that much different, especially if you bring up the Imperial Japanese – who was following the steps of western empires. The goal of the Nazi lebensraum is also to recreate North American colonies in eastern Europe.
Bret talked about “autarky is bad” but remember that the British Empire didn’t like to depend on China for tea either, so they grew tea in India and went to war to force China to depend on British opium. The west’s free trade system is not always free.
While I appreciate the reminder of what the “status quo” pre-WW2 entailed (there’s a reason most of the SEA people see the Nazis as another western empire but worse, not “Literal Demons”), i feel like we’re reading differently on Mr Devereaux’ usage of “Status Quo” here. Yes, the allies are a bunch of empires built with uncountable suffering and death, the ways of which becomes blood-soaked blueprint for the Lebensraum and Sankou Sakusen. It was also, by the war’s start, the way things were for most people living then, and thus it is the state in which they want to _go back to,_ as opposed to the Nazi’s and Meiji’s goal of an imperialistic state they want _to become._ It is by this meaning that they are the “status quo”, not as the way things (moralistically) should be but as the people being warred on.
This is yet another victim of HoI4’s extreme shortness, I feel. By focusing solely in the happenings of WW2, and thus the time where the Nazi (and Meiji) are an active, total and unignorable (or at least no longer ignorable) threat against the allies (and allies-exploited zones), it makes the context of the birth of fascism as imperialism backfiring on Europe natii unimportant on the moment, _and_ can’t show how much they didn’t learn from it at the end of the war (namely, the waves of wars of independence fighting against Britain, Holland, France etc.). And this sery is focused on the game, not on the history of fascism in general, so too she has to focus out those.
Your use of the word Meiji is incorrect. Meiji is the posthumous name of the Japanese Emperor Mutsuhito, who died before the First World War, let alone the second. The Meiji period is simply the period during which Mutsuhito was Emperor, just as the Showa period, which includes the Second World War, is the period during which Hirohito was Emperor. Referring to the the Japanese Empire in the 1940s as the Meiji is like referring to the British Empire in the 1940s as the Victoria.
Indeed! By the time Hitler took power, for one, Mussolini’s Italy was already deep into its genocide in Libya. This event is wholly in the rearview mirror of the game, given that it begins in 1936 – a year after Mussolini’s invasion of Ethiopia and around the outbreak of the Spanish Civil War (and the Palestinian uprising.)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libyan_genocide_(1929%E2%80%931934)
Really makes me wonder if the release of Europa Universalis IV was their last attempt to set an off-ramp to a more responsible treatment of interwar history. That is, my understanding is that the intended progression is to have one Paradox series’ end date be the other series’ start date. Hearts of Iron appears to have always began in 1936 and the Victorias also end in 1936 while beginning in 1836 – the year EUV ends. However, EUIV ended in 1821 – implying perhaps that their initial intent was to have an 1821-1921 Victoria III, and thus a 1921-1951 (?) HOI IV (yes I know that in practice, HOI IV arrived 4 years before Victoria III.) I believe the others have already remarked that the ludicrous political fluidity of the game would make far more sense if it were to begin right after the end of WWI, and hence the political developments were given far more room to breathe.
I suppose the one major advantage of their chosen start date from the perspective of the company is that Hitler is already firmly in power. With the plurality of the game’s userbase apparently being what it is, the whole “player-led government is trying to coup itself” issue is likely to be exacerbated to all-new levels with a ~1920 start date. At the same time, from the Allied players’ perspective, your main concern for much of the game wouldn’t even be devoted to rearming, but to trying to renegotiate Versailles and extend its arms controls as far forward as possible. (Historically, they expire in 1935 – i.e. right before the game begins.) Likewise, you would need reasonably detailed “cheating the Versailles” mechanics for the Germany player.
Meanwhile, from the USA player’s POV, you might be able to avoid the entire war by averting “The Roaring 20’s” economic policy – or even failing that, simply not passing Smoot-Hawley might be enough to keep Weimar afloat. From the Soviet POV, the whole post-Lenin power struggle is yet to happen, so Stalin might not even reach power, and there’s a very wide range of possible timelines in that period. On the other hand, the USSR could well confront far more intense export/technology controls than historically (as noted earlier, the primary Soviet tank models in the 1930s were built off exported American and British blueprints.)
In all, if done right, it ought to be a far more intriguing game – but it would really require abandoning “the spirit of the state” and tie the player down with far more of the political grind so that they cannot just optimize for WWII 20 years ahead of time. A promising idea would be having the player choose a specific political party in a specific country – a party which could easily spend years in opposition with very few options available and potentially not even reach power within the game’s timeframe at all (hey, if you want to e.g. place Mosley in charge of Britain, you gotta work for it!) Likewise, reaching power but trying to rearm too early in a Western country easily risks getting thrown out at the next election and not regaining power until it’s too late. (Or vice versa in other states – i.e. that notorious “you lost the game in 1925” co-op ruleset for the Japanese government). The player might even begin in charge of a small-d democratic party but be tempted to suspend elections once they realize their vision isn’t resonating – but the earliest possible game over is having your party crushed in every meaningful sense (not just banned, which triggers “underground” mechanics and can yet be recovered from, but a series of critical losses of leadership and popular support after that.)
There is one aspect in which the Nazi Hunger Plan was more pointlessly cruel than the conquest of the American West they were trying to emulate. Which is that they imagined they could fill all that new, empty territory with people by all the good Aryan Germans breeding like crazy.
Except that this was not how the US filled their interior with people. It wasn’t some birth rate explosion that filled the interior, it was importing people. Both literally in the form of slavery and figuratively in the form of enormous levels of immigration. And despite all that, the American interior was (and still is) less densely populated than the rural parts of Europe. Plus of course, by this point, anyone who was paying attention was noticing how urbanization was already well underway, with the people moving from the rural farmland into the cities.
So the textbook example of what the Nazis wanted to do was actually a case study of why their plan could not work. And yet they did it anyway.
“equally unwilling to summon the will to spend even more money and even more lived”
->”lives”
“massive obligations the state was incurring doing all of the war”
I originally thought “doing” was meant to be “during”, but I see now that the current phrasing is grammatically correct. However, if “doing” was intended, I think “all the war” is better than “all of the war”.
I’m reminded of the board game Westphalia, about the 30 and 80 Years’ Wars. Of course, being a board game, meant to be playable within a few hours while remaining relatively accessible to non-grognards, it can’t simulate nearly as much as a Paradox game (i.e., all battles are resolved via a single die roll, and the operational layer isn’t represented at all). However, I can’t help but feel that, in certain limited respects, it might actually represent the economics and strategy of war better than HoI4.
First of all, at the start of the game, all the powers are deeply in debt, and are only likely to go deeper in debt as the game progresses (in fact, debt acts as the main (negative) currency of the game); it’s clear that these wars are ruinously expensive for pretty much everybody. Furthermore, it also makes an effort to represent strategic aims other than territorial conquest (i.e., the Protestant powers want to increase religious tolerance in the HRE, while Austria and Bavaria want the reverse; the Dutch would very much like to just sit back to just make trade deals with everybody, etc.), although territorial conquest is still present.
I don’t want to overstate things here. Most notably (and likely most objectionably to our host), the game doesn’t represent the impact of these wars on the civilian populations at all. And yet, I think it’s remarkable that a board game manages to represent certain aspects of war better than Paradox’s super-complex super-serious WW2 simulator.
Proposing HOI4 to be more open about the human cost of war and the economic destitution of Nazism just to immediately discard TNO for being ‘mod about nazis’ is crazy. Well my boy, then you have indeed proposed no solution! If ‘being Nazi-themed’ is some kind of uncurable fatal terminal flaw, if no amount of ‘Nazism Bad’ narrative points can be enough to absolve the sin of having nazis in your game in the first place, then we literally just can’t have games about WW2.
The criticism of TNO seems to be, at least in part, inherited from a very tankie subreddit (because reddit tends to create extermist bubbles, and tankie are more numerous extermists than posadists, for example), and is mainly based on aesthetics.
Don’t tell that subreddit, or indeed the author, about Laibach.
OK, I ordinarily have very little interest in political subreddits, but now you have made me search either place for “Laibach”; let’s just say this (only the most prominent of a dozen or so mentions there + a single positive mention on the other) disproves your thesis! (For those unaware of the context; Laibach is believed to be the first band from outside the country to have performed in Pyongyang since the fall of the USSR or thereabouts. Like many (most?) people who are aware of them at all, I first found out about them because they did the soundtrack to the notorious Finnish “Nazis on the Moon” satire Iron Sky.)
This seems intentionally obtuse. When I search the full name of the mod (and nothing else) in NoAI DuckDuckGo in private browsing (i.e. pretty much the closest to a “median”, non-personalized search experience you can get nowadays), the top result I get is the link to its wiki’s front page, and this search preview:
Needless to say, a ‘mod about nazis’ ≠ a mod which grants the majority of the premises this series had been dismantling at the very start! (And I also don’t think it does us any good to pretend a mod creator whose chosen profile name literally has “Panzer” in it didn’t choose to undertake the project about the utter victory of Nazi Germany without at least a sincere belief in the myths of German military-industrial superiority, even if that belief might no longer be present today.)*
Your argument essentially assumes that the only way to critique Nazism in a WWII game is to allow it (literally allow, given how we have to assume the already-incredible lucky streak Hitler had IRL just keeps going, as well as to basically keep inventing additional ways to cripple each one of the Allies) to win WWII first, which is generally not something we do for anything else. Compare and contrast with the pet project of the notorious Game of Thrones‘ showrunners, who wanted a TV show set in a world where the Confederacy wins/avoids losing the Civil War, then seemingly does the same again (the surviving promotional material said it was to be set “in the lead-up to the Third (!) American Civil War”) and thus apparently continues to exist as a slave state in the 20th century (maybe even in the 21st?) As you can probably tell, it got cancelled at some stage of pre-production.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confederate_(TV_series)
There’s no real reason to doubt the show would have depicted this Confederacy as being bad. There is also no reason to pretend it could have plausibly done so in a way that would have made up for the lie they had a chance to avoid getting crushed “if only Antietam went the other way” (never mind that the whole reason McClellan was loathed by Lincoln and the abolitionists yet beloved by Union soldiers till Grant came onto the scene is that he was an expert at logistics and force preservation, who valued avoiding disastrous defeat over victory) and then survived a rematch, when the industrial gap would have only widened in the Union’s favour. In both cases, there’s also the overall effect of narrowing the collective imagination to these widely-unlikely scenarios, as opposed to so many fresher alternate timelines. (I.e. a timeline where Aaron Burr’s plan to carve an independent state out of Louisiana Purchase succeeds is, if anything, significantly more plausible than either of those, and would have had enormous ripple effects over the following 200+ years – yet there’s virtually no exploration of it, AFAIR.)
*I suppose a generous interpretation here is that the most recent series of Wolfenstein games (another The New Order, from 2014, 2017’s The New Colossus and the large standalone DLCs to either – Old and Young Blood, respectively) are quite similar, in that they also grant the idea of the Nazis being able to win WWII (to the point of taking over the entire US!) in the first place, before they use that setup to critique the ideology. In Wolfenstein’s case, though, that is at least conditional on technology like cybernetic implants which hardly even exists now and very clearly couldn’t have existed in the 1940s (perhaps even breaking too many laws of physics like the conservation of energy to exist at all – though certainly not to the same extent as in the earlier versions of the setting, where some Nazis had outright supernatural powers.)
However, while a number of journalists and the like did praise that concept a lot, I have no idea if our host had ever been on their side (I cannot find any mention of “Wolfenstein” either here or on his Bluesky), or if he would also argue that even granting this in the first place is already far too generous. I’ll also note that nowadays, we are nearly a decade removed from The New Colossus (let alone the 2014 game) – and the cultural impact of the entire series appears so limited (the closest to a “consensus gamer opinion” appears to treat as an “ugly stepbrother of the Doom reboot) that it is at best unclear if it had actually done anything at all to dent the appeal of fascism/Nazism amongst its target demographic. (The least generous interpretation is that it might have done more harm than good by e.g. actually incorporating a powerful (benevolent) Jewish conspiracy into its plot – basically reversing the moral valence of the Protocols.)
“Your argument essentially assumes that the only way to critique Nazism in a WWII game is to allow it to win”
It does not.
I would add that the “trade is and unalloyed good” attitude is not some unchallenged economic orthodoxy, and wasnt in the 1930s either. Of course our esteemed host is steeped in the anglo-american tradition, and his biases are coming through a bit harder than usual (see dismissing TNO beceause it looks fash, when it is one of the more anti-fash mods out there), but it is, and was, possible to be open to trade and end up poorer, not richer, than you were. In our actual lived world, the economic disparity between Portugal and England increased as trade between the two increased.
Apart from any “trade is for sissies” view, it was reasonable for some powers to view unrestricted trade, especially unrestricted trade on someone else’s terms, especially sea-borne unrestricted trade that a hostile power can blockade. Germany remembered the starvation of WWI (and of the post-WWI period, when the blockade was not lifted sufficiently), and it was not an unreasonable proposition to want a world where Germany was never at risk of starvation by London. Starving other, “lesser” people to achieve this goal was the unreasonable bit, not the idea of caloric autarky.
“and was, possible to be open to trade and end up poorer, not richer, than you were.”
Not wrong, but this:
“In our actual lived world, the economic disparity between Portugal and England increased as trade between the two increased.”
doesn’t prove your point. First, it would be very easy to argue that the disparity would have occurred even without Portugal trading with England; second, there’s a difference between “I’m getting poorer” and “I’m not getting wealthier as fast as you are.”
I mean, WWI Germany would not have actually been in a position where London had cut off its food imports if it hadn’t, you know, declared war on the Russian Empire first. (Never mind doing the same in 1941, of course.)
Granted, there was the matter of that pesky Tripartite Alliance with Austro-Hungarian Empire – but even if we assume the mobilized Russian army would have in fact went on to attack the Austro-Hungarians* in 1914, it was still the German Empire’s strategic choice to prefer an alliance with a power that couldn’t have supplied them with food overland over one which ought to have managed it.** And of course, it was the German choice not to extend 1887’s secret Reinsurance Treaty after 1890, openly signifying hostile intent and driving the Russian Empire to ally with France.
*There’s have been arguments that the Tsar only wanted to performatively intimidate them and wouldn’t have gone on to war on his own – though admittedly, it’s hard not view this via the lens of the 2021-2022 military build-up which many hoped was performative but did in fact cross the border.
**Yes, the logistical issues with overland vs. maritime trade would have still existed. Still, contrary to what one might think, the Russian Empire was apparently the world’s largest wheat exporter in the 1861-1914 period (i.e. from the start of the U.S. Civil War to the start of, well, WWI.) Admittedly, this source dates to 1998, but I doubt there had been momentous changes in such statistics since then.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0014498398907069
While there was a notorious famine in 1891-1892 (albeit much less devastating than either the Holodomor era or the end of the Russian Civil War), a lot of it had to do with the terrible management of stocks intended to alleviate such. In any case, a properly conducted German grand strategy (i.e. one which did not cancel the Reinsurance Treaty, for one) would have encouraged all their scientific advancements in agricultural/storage/processing techniques that led to significantly greater net yields per hectare in their agriculture to also percolate into Russian agriculture between 1890 and 1914, thus substantially increasing their collective food security. And of course, their expertise in railroad-building would have been well-applied in better connecting the Russian Empire’s grain-growing regions with East Prussia.
“driving the Russian Empire to ally with France”
If Germany intended to go to war with France at all then the Russian Empire would ally with France regardless to contain Germany. It’s just the nature of world balance grand strategy before ww1.
Do you have any ideas how such a game can bde designed, so that it doesn’t force fascist ideology to be true, while still allowing Germany to be playable and have a chance of winning?
Maybe having the world reflect reality that fascism has large costs and doesn’t work, while at the same time make the early game (1936-1939-1941) slow for the democracies through a political/international system: democratic governments can’t rearm without broad public support that comes from showing they did everything they can for peace diplomatically.
This way Germany just gets a large headstart, and no need to actually give them a superior socieconomic system to have a chance at winning.
I think in addition to Germany getting to rearm before the allies do, the Axis standard win condition shouldn’t be world conquest but negotiating conditional surrender from the US and Britain after taking out France and putting the USSR on the back foot. It should be really difficult to conquer Britain and essentially impossible to conquer the United States but achievable to submarine-blockade Britain, destroy the Pacific Fleet, and drive the Red Army back. Then the production numbers say the US still rebuilds its fleet and army and continues to be able to supply the USSR, but the public becomes less than convinced conquering Japan and retaking Europe is achievable at a price they’re willing to pay and the US and UK bow out, conceding Nazi control of Western Europe and abandoning their colonial empires in the Pacific to Japan and suspending exports of military material to the USSR and Nationalist China while lifting the US embargo of Japan, and then the Axis have a shot at forcing the latter to surrender.
Makes sense; though how do the nuclear weapons then figure into this? It’s still a fairly powerful card backstopping the Allies even if the Axis achieves the more conventional military goals you outlined.
Actually, this just made me realize this series seemingly didn’t cover nuclear weapons at all. After a quick search, this tells me that they are “not very good”, as it is apparently largely impossible to reach nuclear reactors before 1943 and the bombs themselves before 1945; furthermore, a reactor can only produce one bomb per year.
https://www.pcgamesn.com/hearts-of-iron-iv/nukes-nuclear-weapons
Admittedly, the above is from 2022, so perhaps it changed by now. (I also noticed that there’s apparently a mod literally titled “Nuclear Deterrence”, which attempts to add more gravity to their presence and deployment.)
Well, if the Axis achieve those goals by 1944 nukes haven’t been made ready for operational deployment and the allies may not have confidence they can deliver them since Japan holds the naval advantage and presumably Germany is still at least able to contest the skies. This is well before nukes can be loaded onto uninterceptable missiles and it’s become clear the bomber does not always get through.
I’m not sure how I’d handle nukes once they’ve been researched but I’d be inclined to say that deploying a nuke isn’t an automatic win, instead having it deal catastrophic damage to a single city as well as forces deployed in the region and a huge additional morale blow, but if the US nukes Iwo Jima or even Okinawa Japan should be able to continue the war at least until there’s an air raid on the Japanese mainland. I’m also inclined to say that in a game with HoI’s timeline it shouldn’t be 100% guaranteed the Allies get and maintain a nuclear monopoly. They should have a considerable research advantage assuming historical political paths are taken but it’s not like Nazi Germany didn’t have any nuclear physicists whatsoever after 1939, and even if they as historically don’t realize a nuke can even theoretically be made small enough to fit in a plane on their own once the Allies use one they’ll work out generally what happened.
As I see it, by the time the war is still going in 1945 (which is what it needed for nuclear weapons to be able to be used in real history), there’s no feasible way the Axis were winning it regardless. The ways they could have won implied by the comment above are either taking effect by 1943 at the latest, or they’re gone.
I suppose that might work, but it’s based on an assumption that any armistice the Axis might achieve by 1943-1944 is going to hold up in the face of Allied temptation to deploy the most powerful weapons on Earth in order to break the stalemate and achieve more favourable terms – which is just that, an assumption.
This could actually intersect with the proposed atrocity mechanic. That is, if the Axis player does achieve this kind of a hard-won armistice, their struggle is far from over – they now need to ensure none of the atrocities they are so prone to perpetrating become so large and so well-known that they motivate now-nuclear Allies to restart the war. (Similar to how it was the news of Japanese atrocities in Nanjing which have set in motion the train which led to the American embargo.)
P.S. And it is again worth noting that if Germany does not defeat France quickly, the Axis do not form at all. Conversely, if the events unfold such that the Western Allies attack the USSR before 1941 for any one reason (be it the bombing of Baku oil or the Norwegian government being less cautious and allowing nearly 150,000 French and British troops to pass via their territory to join the Winter War on the Finnish side), the USSR could be driven sufficiently close to Germany that those who opposed Barbarossa (according to a pre-LLM StackExchange discussion below, that describes a lot more Nazi leadership than one might expect!) prevail – though actually cancelling Lebensraum clearly requires some sort of an anti-Hitler coup, and there’s still the incredibly thorny question of how the “Britain First”* Nazi leaders are going to move on past the whole “Judeobolshevism” thing.
https://history.stackexchange.com/questions/54279/were-there-any-top-nazi-generals-who-opposed-the-idea-to-invade-the-ussr
So, getting to this outcome would be rather unlikely and it would be fragile. (Just imagine watching this arrangement – a Germany that’s continually backstopped by a Western-hostile USSR, even a full-on alliance with joint troop deployments would most likely remain a bridge too far – from the perspective of lesser fascist states like Hungary and Romania.) On the flip side, if it actually survives till 1945, it’s deeply implausible any Nazi leader would risk breaking it in the face of the Allied nukes. (In theory, the inverse isn’t true, as under some sort of a “Normandy with nukes” scenario which makes the Nazi defeat seem like a manner of time, the USSR might risk going for the OTL Iron Curtain borders – but since this timeline had already evidenced the Allied willingness to attack USSR, such a gambit would be balanced against the obvious risk of getting nuked.)
*A play on “Germany First” Allied strategy, in case anyone here is unaware. I hesitated to add this disclaimer, but then I recalled the time some other commenter thought “Greater East Asian Co-Prosperity Sphere” was a Shadowrun thing…
In the interests of clarity: for “this outcome would be rather unlikely”, read kieslowskifan’s answer from 11 years ago to recognize just how unlikely, even with the countervailing pressure of the USSR already in combat vs. the British and/or French in this scenario.
Conversely, remember that the Manhattan project only gets underway in a serious “we’re going to actually try to build a bomb” sense in mid 1942, and spinning up the infrastructure takes quite a while even at all out investment level applied in the real war. If we’re hypothesising an armistice agreed at say the end of 1942, then: the very first breaking of land on Los Alamos has only just started; compulsory purchase of the land for Oak Ridge is underway; and Hanford is just one of a potential cluster of sites being surveyed.
If the war had ended at that point, would the sheer level of focus and resources still be applied? Or would it be run at a much lower pace, and then you’re not seeing results show up for several more years? With the full wartime crash programme, it really was pretty touch and go that they managed to get any weapons ready for use in 1945.
After checking r/AskHistorians, it seems like doing this effectively would have required at least 6 times as many U-boats in service in 1939 as had been the case historically. (From 57 to 300+) – i.e. at least 250 extra boats.
Luckily for the Kriegsmarine, the U-boats of Type VII which did nearly all the work were small by modern standards (750-770 tons), so as a really basic rule of thumb, cancelling every German ship heavier than a destroyer nets you;
So, that just about gets you there, with approximately 237 extra boats. (Assuming Tirpitz, which wasn’t commissioned until 1941, already had all the sheet metal stuff committed to it by September 1939 and only had finer components like the wiring worked on throughout 1940.) There’s not much else to sacrifice from the Kriegsmarine, as there were only German 22 destroyers in 1939, and given the difference in “empty” displacement (750-770 tons vs. ~2,200*), it seems like not ordering one destroyer only nets you three extra Type VIIs. (Even less from ground troops, when one U-boat still weighs akin to a few dozen tanks.) Technically, there are 6 German cruisers, but 5 of them were built in Weimar times, so unless you posit a change in doctrine so far-reaching it extends into late 1920s, the most you can get there is 11 or so extra subs via cancelling Nürnberg (yes, literally named after Nuremberg!) about as soon as Hitler takes power.
Still, you can actually fulfill Donitz’s requirements from the outbreak of the war in this manner…but then a) the requirements doubled after Pearl Harbor took the brakes off the US war machine; b) if the Allies do the reasonable thing and discount strategic bombing in order to use these same planes for submarine-hunting, the logistics become very unfavourable for the submarine warfare once again. Just look up how effective Leigh Light-equipped aircraft were – and note that there were way more bombers which could carry them then there were U-boats. (~11,460 Wellingtons and 18,188 Liberators – and while Liberators didn’t enter service until 1941, the Wellington had been there since 1938.)
Admittedly, Britain as an island is almost wholly dependent on oil shipments, primarily from the US (the local Nottinghamshire oilfield produced less than 0.1% of what they received in imports), so theoretically, its own ability to fly those patrols could end up curtailed before Leigh Light enters service (1941 historically; potentially on accelerated timeline here). However, we must consider that a Kriegsmarine which clearly stops building large ships to focus so totally on submarines is just too blatant of a strategy shift for anyone’s intelligence to ignore, so it’s reasonable to expect that it would likewise accelerate both the timeline of anti-submarine warfare development in the UK and the relative investment into it. In all, still far from a guaranteed success from the German perspective, but at least there’s a conceivable chance here.
*Similar to the American Fletchers. I must say, I was under the impression the German ones were only about half that displacement, but it appears I confused them with the British and Soviet destroyers, which frequently were smaller (i.e. the British I-class and the Soviet Type 7 both had ~1,400 ton standard displacement).